3 ms·
>“If you went to a cardiologist and they asked you how your heart feels, you would think they are crazy,” Johnson says. “You would ask them to measure your bloo
by Barrin92 5y ago
>“If you went to a cardiologist and they asked you how your heart feels, you would think they are crazy,” Johnson says. “You would ask them to measure your blood pressure and your cholesterol and all of that.”"
Depending on what condition you're suspected to have that's a perfectly reasonable question, but that aside this showcases the tendency for reductionism that has become prevalent.
The mind is not equivalent to the brain, and neither is comparable to a mechanical device. The better analogy to the statement from Johnson is, if you wanted to inspect software you certainly would not start to turn transistors on your hardware upside down, or if you wanted to get insights into a Dostoevsky novel you wouldn't start to inspect printer-ink on the pages.
For some purely physical ailment of the brain better scanning techniques may very well be a good thing, but 90% of what his project seems to be about has little to do with the physical brain and a lot to do with studying emergent phenomena of the human mind, in which case getting lost in brain chemistry is probably not that helpful, and at worst seems to lead to a sort of ML-powered craniometry.
- kirkules 5y agoTo be fair, the reason you wouldn't turn the transistors upside down is that you already know what software is and that this is not related to what software is. Similarly for the novel, though actually maybe that depends on the kind of insights you're looking for. In particular, turning transistors upside down is a good way to discover that software is fairly orthogonal to hardware orientation, if you didn't already know that. Not that anything prevents someone from claiming otherwise...