3 ms·
It sounds to me like "channels" are defined by the poster, but "public group" (which I don't see you talking about anywhere on this discussion) would be taken f
by saurik 15y ago
It sounds to me like "channels" are defined by the poster, but "public group" (which I don't see you talking about anywhere on this discussion) would be taken from a global namespace. The way I choose to carve up reality is going to be slightly different from someone else's, and that difference is important.
(...and, in fact, the way I'm now reading the original poster's concept of "public circles" also seems like it is defined per-poster; but the mechanism on Flickr for "public groups" that mc32 is talking about is quite different: it requires a bunch of shared coordination over what that group means.)
(...and now I've skimmed through a bunch of your history on HN, and found that you talk about "public circles" occasionally, but do not mention "public groups", so I'm just confused. You do, however, compare them to Facebook Groups, which to me have that same global namespace problem. It is useful and important that my public circle might be called "Android Bytecode Manipulation" whereas someone else's might be called "General Instruction Manipulation", as these aren't even hierarchically related; "Sneaky Programming Hi-jinx" from someone else may be relevant and interesting to you as well; once you force things to be maintained in a public namespace it becomes a lot less personal and a lot less social in the particular "sharing is what it means to you" way that Google+ is all about.)
- btilly 15y agoRead more carefully. I was not the one to compare it with Facebook Groups. We're both talking about the exact same concept. The user says, "These are groups of people that I want to send information to" and anyone who wants can add themselves to those groups.