3 ms·
ISPs have a high cost to entry: you have to run fiber everywhere to offer service and you don’t get revenue until you do that and people sign up. Major players
by acdha 5y ago
ISPs have a high cost to entry: you have to run fiber everywhere to offer service and you don’t get revenue until you do that and people sign up. Major players can slash prices below cost until you fold and then jack the rates up (I live in an area with 3 gigabit options: service here is cheaper and better than only a few blocks away where it’s just Comcast - and everyone you call on the phone knows whether you have competition at your address).
The model I’d like would be having fiber either be owned by the city or a highly regulated utility, with a market for ISPs to provide service on that infrastructure. It’d be much easier to enter the market if you just need to peer at a few locations rather than each house, and it’d be nice if there was a no-frills option for people who only want reliable IP without all of the add-on services.
- naveen99 5y agoThat high cost of entry is paid to the municipality isn’t it ? Why build and run a business when you can just collect rent / taxes instead.
- acdha 5y agoThe idea is that it’s a long-term investment which everyone can share, similar to how most places build roads or water pipes rather than expecting businesses to build those with duplication and gaps.
- eecc 5y ago> The model I’d like would be having fiber either be owned by the city or a highly regulated utility, with a market for ISPs to provide service on that infrastructure. That's how telecoms are organized in NL, although through loosening of regulations, mergers and acquisitions the service geography is reducing to separate islands of non-competing monopolies. Yet, it still works decently well. Also energy is the same (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Electricity_sector_in_the_Netherlands https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Electricity_sector_in_the_Neth...) As a counterexample, the creation of the "energy free market" by spinning off the local infra from the energy brokers and producers has turned into a convenient excuse to screw customers over billing and passing the buck back-and-forth to keep the money.
- _djo_ 5y agoAgreed. One interesting approach that took place in Johannesburg was that a suburb took matters into their own hands to get an open access fibre network installed. They formed a ratepayers association, got a critical mass of the households to sign up for an installation fee and a promise to join, and appointed a company (Vumatel) to install and run the network. It was transformational: Within a few years average internet speeds in every neighbourhood that adopted the approach went from 5-10Mbps to 100Mbps-200Mbps, with some areas getting 1Gbps. And being open access, it means that you still get competition between commercial ISPs offering their services over the shared infrastructure with a small amount of their fee going back to maintain the network. What's more because the barrier to entry for ISPs was lowered there were a bunch of new and extremely competitive options. I thought it was a really smart way to overcome the chicken and egg problem of high speed internet infrastructure.
- lotsofpulp 5y agoThat’s the same thing as municipal broadband.
- _djo_ 5y agoNot quite. What makes this interesting is that the municipality (and other government structures) had no involvement beyond approving the permits for trenching. There's also no ongoing contract with the municipality, nor is it funded through taxes.