5 ms·
It would allow them to compete to set up high quality ISPs rather than being forced to subsidize a low quality local alternative. It’s one thing to pay a bill.
by renewiltord 5y ago
It would allow them to compete to set up high quality ISPs rather than being forced to subsidize a low quality local alternative.
It’s one thing to pay a bill. It’s another thing to pay it twice.
- LocalH 5y agoIn what part of the US does this ever happen? Where are all the small “mom and pop” ISPs? Oh, right.
- criddell 5y agoThere are actually a lot of mom and pop ISPs. Mostly wireless (WISPs). https://www.wispa.org/what_is_a_wisp.php https://www.wispa.org/what_is_a_wisp.php
- only_as_i_fall 5y agoCould you explain your reasoning here? Do you expect a ban on municipal broadband to improve either the quality or price of internet service and if so are there any examples of this happening?
- Mordisquitos 5y agoSurely the "high quality ISPs" would easily outcompete the "low quality local alternatives". Let the market decide, and let ISP customers vote the local alternatives out with their wallets! And if a local authority were to insist on using public money to subsidize a thoroughly outcompeted municipal broadband, then the locals will be free to vote them out with their, well... votes.
- renewiltord 5y agoA fine principle in theory but there are serious status quo effects with governments. Governments rarely ever roll back benefits that don’t pencil out. The reason being that people are loss averse. Knowing from behavioral economics about loss aversion, it is reasonable for us to want to avoid placing ourselves in a situation where it forces us into foolish policy decisions. For what it’s worth, I am generally in agreement with you, except that majority rule to extract money from some people to provide for others strikes me as poor taste. If the ones who want the service want to collectivize to pay for it, it makes sense to me that the government run that enterprise. The difference between a market and the government is that if a product is unviable with 50%+1 but viable with 99%, that 50%+1 population can force it upon the rest. That difference to me is significant enough that I don’t think claiming voting as equivalent to market spending is reasonable.
- eecc 5y agoLots of assumptions in that statement, care to elaborate preferably with links to reputable data? TIA
- renewiltord 5y agoCare to state which assumptions you disagree with? I will target my attention there then.
- zentiggr 5y agoSomebody owns shares in an ISP, or gets their salary from one, or has somehow drunk the kool aid. ISPs, once they have a legislated monopoly in localities, have a solid track record of stagnating investment in improved capabilities regardless of billing increases. Forcing ISPs to compete against self-motivated local establishments of ISP services is what makes capabilities and prices work best for the customers.
- smolder 5y agoMost muni broadband isn't even subsidized, they pay for it with subscribership and still offer dramatically more value than comcast et al. That's how bad our monopoly ISPs are. The protection they get also gave Google, of all companies, a hard time spinning up some competition. There's something to be said for not putting our internet connections in the hands of government, but it absolutely is not a problem of stifling competition. There's none to stifle.