5 ms·
Don’t Worry about CO2, Worry about the Earth’s ‘Energy Balance’
- traskjd 5y agoOh great, I was running low on things to worry about.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- LatteLazy 5y agoDon't worry about either, worry about climate change because we've decided not to prevent it and it will be your problem to survive it when it starts to bite. Edit: to be clear, I mean as individuals. I don't think humanity is going to die out, I just wouldn't by a house on low lying ground...
- Guthur 5y agoOf course we'll survive there is no scientific basis for apocalyptic alarmist nonsense that says "heed thee the end is nigh because you drive a car". There may be other reasons to switch to different energy sources but some environmental apocalypse is not it.
- ehnto 5y agoThe climate will be changing, there is plenty of science supporting that. It doesn't take much change to push a lot of places into unlivable territory, it doesn't have to be apocalyptic to cause immense instability. If temperatures keep trending upward where I live I don't plan to stick around, it's already peaking at 50c.
- adrianN 5y ago"We" will almost certainly survive. Whether that also includes me or you is a completely different question. Famine, wars, natural disasters etc are quite likely.
- XorNot 5y agoOr just plain old financial destruction: the US government isn't bailing out anyone who's house is on it's way to being inundated by rising sea levels, it sure isn't going to expand that non-existent program when it hits low lying coastal areas which discover they're suddenly vulnerable to storm surges. Guess who wants to buy land you can't live on: nobody.
- throwaway0a5e 5y agoIf you follow the news in the kinds of places that are washing into the sea you'll note that many of these people and towns have been very successful in getting the state to bail them out or at least spend stupid money delaying the inevitable.
- LatteLazy 5y agoI'm not saying civilisation will end or ALL humans will die out. I'm saying expect famines in places that are currently breadbaskets. Ditto floods, droughts, hurricanes, plagues, heart waves etc. You may well die in any of these, lots of people do, it's very popular and no one expects it to happen to them... So maybe move way from the coast and to higher ground, get an air conditioner, stay in shape and take weather warnings seriously. If I actually thought civilisation or the species were going to end, it wouldn't make sense to do anything except maybe party till its over...
- ehnto 5y agoI don't think this is a cynical take, can anyone seriously look at how the 50 years played out and assume anything else? It's clear prevention isn't going to happen, so we need to get very interested in remediation and defense against an evolving climate. Maybe one day we will be able to engineer our way free of the effects but prevention was clearly a pipe dream.
- cameronh90 5y agoEnergy balance is the effect, CO2 (and other greenhouse gases) are the primary root cause. To fix the energy balance, we need to fix CO2, so we should indeed worry about that.
- eptcyka 5y agoThat's backwards. CO2 is the outcome of the civilization using up stored paleolithic compost as an energy booster. But I do also disagree with the main premise of the article, CO2 is an issue that we should be looking to solve.
- float4 5y ago- "Don't worry about bugs, worry about your program crashing." - "Don't worry about extreme weight gain, worry about cardiovascular disease." - "Don't worry about your bad parenting skills, worry about your child being a brat."
- dgellow 5y agoJust for the last one, even the best parents can have horrible kids. I feel that we often overestimate how much influence parents have on children compared to their peer group, genetics, and other factors.
- forinti 5y agoIt takes a village to raise a child. We've forgotten this old wisdom.
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 5y agoWe've forgotten how to be communities because everything is now run by sociopaths.
- arbitrage 5y ago> even the best parents can have horrible kids it is very much unlikely, though. and you know that.
- bjornsing 5y ago
- aliasEli 5y agoThe article makes the very valid point that global warming is of course about the energy balance. An increase in carbon dioxide is one of the factors that will influence this energy balance. But there are several other processes that could influence this. The processes that are the most worrying are the ones with positive feed-backs, i.e. they are faster when temperature increases. Virtually all physical, chemical processes run faster when the temperature increases[0]. There are some simple feed-back processes that could become important, such as the thawing of permafrost (releasing methane, also a greenhouse agent) or the melting of snow/ice (reducing the albedo of the earth and enhancing the radiation it absorbs). [0] It is also true for most biological processes.
- HPsquared 5y agoMy personal concern is, if those positive feedbacks start occurring we will need to intervene in the energy balance directly. It would be worthwhile to research those methods so they're available if the worst happens.
- hulitu 5y agoWe already do this: we sell energy certificates. In a certain country i heard: we are not polluting enough. We will have to sell more energy certificates. My faith in humanity is quiet limited.
- AstralStorm 5y agoLike what, painting Earth white? Constructing a massive dust cloud in space to reflect/disperse sun? Nothing short of that or removing GHG will fix things. And even if we do those, we will have problems with increased CO2 concentrations, acid rain and seawater acidification comes to mind. Current biosphere is unable to adapt to huge CO2 levels on a short notice.
- HPsquared 5y agoThose kind of things become relevant once positive feedback starts. If an overweight patient is having a heart attack should the doctor give diet advice or CPR?
- goodpoint 5y agoReminder: Overfocusing on CO2 and ignoring other metrics is dubious at best. People tend to confuse "carbon neutral" with "sustainable", instead it's not enough. Many people described this pattern as a deflection tactic.
- js8 5y agoActually, I kind of disagree with the article, as I see its message can also be misconstrued as a delay tactic (especially the claim that the imbalance is only 0.3%, a similar claim was used with CO2 to misrepresent the magnitude of the problem). Yes, experts who study Earth as a system should worry about energy imbalance. But the general public should worry mostly about CO2 (and to a lesser extent, methane).
- AstralStorm 5y agoEnergy balance is something to worry about on scale of few thousand years, when we start running out of fissible materials and fusion never arrives. Global warming and greenhouse gasses, less than 50 years. If we don't fix it, we get no food, less water, mass migrations (possibly with war) up to extinction events. Problem is solar heat being trapped, not running out of energy sources.
- hulitu 5y ago> People tend to confuse "carbon neutral" with "sustainable", instead it's not enough. They are not confusing anything. They are treating the earth like the brothel treats an old prostitute: Due to your services you will not be raped everyday but only on Sundays. Thank you for working with us. Sorry, I'm really courious what word they will pervert to continue polluting as usual.
- dotancohen 5y agoFrom the fine article: > Earth’s global average temperatures have risen by > nearly 2 degrees Fahrenheit over the last 150 years or so. I get that this is Scientific _American_ but in discussing climate change / whatever we're calling it today we have a well-known benchmark of 2 degrees _Celsius_ that we warn about. As we are talking about a Δtemp and not absolute measurement of a specific temperature, in my opinion we should continue to use degrees Celsius for this purpose. And 2 degrees Fahrenheit is over three and a half degrees Celsius - far more alarming.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- gorhill 5y ago> 2 degrees Fahrenheit is over three and a half degrees Celsius 2°F is ~1.1°C
- dotancohen 5y agoI multiplied when I should have divided - thank you for catching that. Even so, I do not believe that it invalidates my point about using the same measurement units across media.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- Kydlaw 5y agoI find the the title of the news really misleading. We MUST worry about CO2, as much as other greenhouse gases to stop the energy imbalance. Some journalists are irresponsible to beat around the bush of global warming, constantly trying to reinvent terminology to drown their readers.
- adrianN 5y agoEven if the energy balance were fine, too much CO2 leads to ocean acidification, which is really bad for the ecosystem. Anything with a carbonate shell has a harder time forming its shell in an acidic ocean.
- AstralStorm 5y agoGreenhouse gases would have been so much better to use than CO2... and the worst common one is methane. But the oil industry did not want to be associated with it, hence CO2 which makes it seem like the problem is burning coal. It partly is, but not just that.
- arbitrage 5y agoso why can't we worry about both? this isn't a sophie's choice of what massive global problem to fix ... we can work on multiple things at once.
- choeger 5y agoSo all we need to do is to get these pesky 0.3% out of our atmosphere, right? Let me do a few quick calculations ... Ok, ..., thats, ..., 520 trillion watt years. So, if we create 5.210^6 sqkm of photovoltaics farms, say by covering half of China, move all bitcoin miners into low earth orbit and power them with said photovoltaics, emitting the waste heat away from earth* (take that, sun!), we are golden. We just have to ... produce three thousand times as much photovoltaics as we do today. This is certainly much simpler than any alternative, right? Right?
- culopatin 5y agoAnd producing those PV might just move your goal up a bit too
- gmuslera 5y agoDismissing the causes means that they won't be addressed. Something else will be tried to be done instead of the most obvious course of action if you know the cause. And that something else could go horribly wrong, as we are dealing with a very complex system that we don't properly understand, and taking drastic/massive measures because of the urgency it will take. Yes, positive reinforcement is adding more factors to the game than just CO2 or GHG emissions, so the problem is not just CO2 anymore. But doing nothing about the source, and in fact keep worsening it won't do any good.
- rbanffy 5y agoWhat we need to stop doing is one thing, but what else can we do (paint the planet white?) is also important. If we can, with artificial structures, increase the amount of energy we radiate, then it should be easier to control than industrial production chains, which have long feedback loops that make their behaviour harder to predict
- gmuslera 5y agoYou can die from fever, so taking or doing something for controlling your temperature seems a good approach for avoiding that. But if you only care about that symptom, and forget that it comes from a disease, infection or something like that, it won't be a solution, just a short-lived (as you) mitigation. If the message is to not mind about the source, it won't be addressed, and the mitigations may or not work, or turn the original problem into something much more complex or harder to solve. I'm not talking about the future, but about the past. The problem was known, and put under the rug, dismissed, ignored, and delayed, even if there was something that could had been done about. Then nothing or too little was done already, and while a lot of effort will be diverted to short term mitigations, nothing will be done in the future neither.
- rbanffy 5y agoWe are talking about two problems. One is technical. This one is relatively easy to solve. The other is organisational: humans aren’t rational and societies don’t behave in their best long term interest. The latter is infinitely more complicated to address.
- kumarvvr 5y agoUnderstanding the fact that "pollution causes global warming" itself is an uphill task for humanity (For various reasons and vested interests). Moving that conversation to "energy balance" will doom the planet.
- rbanffy 5y agoIn fact, it’s an easier concept to grasp. That it also doesn’t put a finger in the oil industry also makes it more palatable to the politicians they keep.
- AstralStorm 5y agoNot all pollution even is warming. If you dump tons of microplastics into water, nothing will warm up (compared to burning them) but it would be a different catastrophe. Heck, creating certain kinds of waste would even prevent global warming, e.g. nuclear - and would do nothing to energy balance.
- Tempest1981 5y agoI wonder if "Energy Balance" would resonate better with more people than "CO2" or "global warming"? Ignoring the technical details, what message would be most persuasive?
- AstralStorm 5y agoDefinitely not energy balance, since to a layman it sounds like we should stop having a civilization.
- cableshaft 5y agoA bit of an aside, but if we were to want to work on these things as software engineers, what's a good way to do it? I started looking for a new job recently and I'm considering jobs that work on these problems (not completely certain I want to, seems like a drop in pay and benefits), and so far the best I've been able to find are a couple of jobs in the energy and power industry that aren't really about working on climate change issues directly, it just might give me some domain knowledge for future work.
- realreality 5y agoThe problem is political and cultural, not technical. As long as powerful people want to maintain their power, they're going to exploit the earth for temporary gain.
- cableshaft 5y agoI understand the greater problem is cultural, but I wouldn't make it very far having a go at politics or being a significant influencer or public opinion. So that leaves the technical. I'm under no illusion that we are going to make it through the next century (or even the next couple of decades) without some terrible horrible consequences of our collective inaction over the past 50+ years (and continuing today). I'm just wondering if there's something worth pursuing for my day job that uses my skills and might reduce the damage a tiny bit beyond just my own personal reduction of waste and emissions.
- jfengel 5y agoArguably, the best you can do is be a good and well-paid technical person, and donate money to the people who work professionally to fix the problem. There are a lot of routes you can take on that. You can give money to political candidates, and political groups, who want to do something about climate change. You can also donate to organizations working on it. You'll have to research ones taking an approach you prefer, but here are some starting points: https://www.vox.com/future-perfect/2019/12/2/20976180/climate-change-best-charities-effective-philanthropy https://www.vox.com/future-perfect/2019/12/2/20976180/climat... https://climatestore.com/take-action/get-involved/non-profit-organizations-working-on-climate-change https://climatestore.com/take-action/get-involved/non-profit... https://donorbox.org/nonprofit-blog/20-global-nonprofits-environment/ https://donorbox.org/nonprofit-blog/20-global-nonprofits-env... If you want to give time rather than money, most of these organizations also want volunteers, including technical ones. They've all got systems to maintain.
- HPsquared 5y agoIt's debatable at the moment, but if we continue along this path and positive feedback does take over, CO2 emissions would cease to be the main driver and would be eclipsed by positive feedbacks. In that case, direct intervention in the energy balance would be the only effective means to prevent further acceleration. Think of it like an object being pushed over - a small push at the start tips it over, but if it starts accelerating under its own weight, you need to catch it - not just stop pushing it over.
- galangalalgol 5y agoHaven't we already been told we are past this tipping point? Is anyone seriously researching climate engineering?
- slver 5y agoDon't worry about anything, worrying doesn't help.
- codethief 5y agoA while ago someone here on HN linked to a blog post with the name "Exponential Economist Meets Finite Physicist", which seems very relevant here: https://dothemath.ucsd.edu/2012/04/economist-meets-physicist/ https://dothemath.ucsd.edu/2012/04/economist-meets-physicist... Quote: > Physicist: Alright, the Earth has only one mechanism for releasing heat to space, and that’s via (infrared) radiation. We understand the phenomenon perfectly well, and can predict the surface temperature of the planet as a function of how much energy the human race produces. The upshot is that at a 2.3% growth rate (conveniently chosen to represent a 10× increase every century), we would reach boiling temperature in about 400 years. [Pained expression from economist.] And this statement is independent of technology. Even if we don’t have a name for the energy source yet, as long as it obeys thermodynamics, we cook ourselves with perpetual energy increase.
- bryanlarsen 5y agoThat argument breaks at this step: "But if energy became arbitrarily cheap, someone could buy all of it" We have lots of critical materials in our industrial processes where the total production is less than the wealth of Jeff Bezos. One example is water. In many places it's so cheap that it's not metered. So theoretically somebody could "buy all the water". Another is something like Palladium. Insanely valuable, but we use so little of it that you could "buy" a year's production for $100B. But of course you couldn't because the act of doing so would spike the price.
- HPsquared 5y agoAnd that's accounting for thermal radiation flux increasing with the fourth power of temperature!