3 ms·
The debt based system will not go away if we ever move the entire economy to bitcoin (laughable as that idea is). You'll have fractional bitcoin reserve banking
by tsimionescu 5y ago
The debt based system will not go away if we ever move the entire economy to bitcoin (laughable as that idea is). You'll have fractional bitcoin reserve banking with absolutely no difference compared to today.
In fact, the fact that bitcoin has no on-chain notion of credit is a major limitation that relegates it to being digital gold, not a digital dollar.
- jhoechtl 5y ago> In fact, the fact that bitcoin has no on-chain notion of credit Precisely that was the OPs point why it is a good alternative to the debt-based financial system we have.
- tsimionescu 5y agoI first addressed GP's point by observing that, were the global economy to adopt bitcoin as a store of value, they would likely still continue to use fractional reserve banking and continue the debt based economy, jjust dde nominating debt in BTC instead of dollars or other currencies. They are unrelated, especially as long as the BTC block chain isn't even close to fast enough to be used as a medium of exchange for a small town, nevermind the global economy. In this phrase I was just pointing out that, given fractional reserve banking is here to stay, with or without bitcoin, it would have been better if bitcoin had embraced it and actually made it possible to put the real transactions on chain, so that at least you could in principle have a BTC bank that is transparent about the kinds of reserves it actually holds, without being forced to hold a full reserve while competing with banks with fractional reserves.
- beefield 5y agoThis. So much this. The disruption in finance was moving from things as money to debt as money. And somehow the people who think current crop of crypto could work as money are so delusional that they fail to understand they are trying to turn the clock backwards, not forward. The thought that bitcoin would somehow limit the amount of money (as currently defined, I am talking about M0, M1 etc) in circulation is simply nothing short of delusional. Bitcoin will not stop people wanting to borrow and loan money and it will not stop people using other entities debt as a mean to pay other people (money, that is.) Defi, you say. Show me a defi project that lets people borrow more money than what they have in the first place. Show me a defi project where I actually take the credit risk for the borrowers when lending the money to them. (Show me those and I show you an emerging fractional reserve bank and uncontrolled money creation by the said bank...)
- errantmind 5y agoThe dollar was once backed by gold, so not the best comparison. Also, I don't see a way to make fractional Bitcoin reserve banking work in practice. You can't simply issue Bitcoin you don't have.
- beefield 5y agoYou do not need to issue any new bitcoin. What you need is a trustworthy entity that borrows your bitcoin and gives you an IOU slip, which you can then use as a means to pay other people. That slip, stating that whoever owns the slip is entitled to one bitcoin from the trustworthy entity, is from economical point of view as good as bitcoin. And if people want to increase the amount of those slips, there is nothing in bitcoin that stops it. Ergo, in bitcoin economy money supply is not restricted.
- errantmind 5y agoAs I mentioned elsewhere, this only works if people don't insist on custody of their bitcoin, and a lot of people (although not a majority) would. Also, do you have some strong historical evidence fractional reserve banking is good economically over long periods (100+ years)?
- tsimionescu 5y agoIt's very simple: you have a banking app that shows you an amount in bitcoin. If you want to send someone else money, you get their own bank account number, and ask your bank to wire that person 1 bitcoin. Your bank talks to their bank and tells them that they are now owed 1 bitcoin. At no point does this bitcoin have to live in the BTC wallet of you, your bank, your friend's bank, or your friend. In fact, this BTC can be entirely fictional. As long as your bank has enough BTC in their actual wallet that they are at no serious risk of running out if a realistic proportion of their customers wanted to withdraw their BTC, as determined by the Fed or other national entity, then all is well. This is anyway the only realistic possible use of BTC itself, as the blockchain is far, far too slow to use for day to day transactions even in a large village/small town. I can also promise you that this is exactly what day to day use of BTC in El Salvador will look like, more or less, if they do go through with it. Edit to add: the dollar was once based on gold. We've moved on from that after realizing that doesn't work. Today's dollar is very much not tied to gold, and it is used in ways gold is not.
- ephbit 5y agoLet's say we had a situation where everything was backed by bitcoin (as a reserve currency). Governmental budgets are one of the most obvious ways in which political decisions manifest themselves and become relevant for everyday life. Do I get this right? You think that governmental budgets would look absolutely no different in such a bitcoinized world compared to how they look in the current centralbank issued money world? You don't think the fact that central banks mostly support governmental debt shapes these budgets in a non trivial way?