4 ms·
Yes, except that's not practical. I don't want to give up meat but I'll give up beef and pork.
by 2OEH8eoCRo0 5y ago
Yes, except that's not practical. I don't want to give up meat but I'll give up beef and pork.
- estaseuropano 5y agoThat does not seem to be a matter of 'practical' but rather a matter of eating preferences. Honestly our food habits are just out of whack. If you go to any Asian or African country (outside the touristic areas) you'll find how many classical/common dishes taste great without meat. From Chinese noodle soups to Thai curries to Ethiopian bean dishes or Indian anything, you miss neither nutrients nor flavour without meat. I would argue the vegetarian movement has made a huge impact in reawakening many 'western' recipes which disappeared when near became cheap. From beetroot to Brussels sprouts to pickles to lentil stews and grilled vegetables - lots of things are back on the plate. All that long said for a short message: yes it can be very practical if we collectively (or individually) want it to be.
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 5y agoI already cut meat out of my lunch and I don't eat a breakfast during the week. No thanks. It's not practical to demand the entire planet become vegan.
- snet0 5y agoThat is not the argument, though. I firmly believe that an overwhelming majority of people who read HN would be able to practically remove meat from their diet. It's not about everyone, it's about individuals, and individuals should strive to do their best given their circumstances.
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 5y agoI don't like the dogmatic absolutism as well. All meat? I can't eat sustainably farmed, smoked mussels? And if we are talking vegan I cannot eat sustainable honey or cheese? It's asinine and arbitrary. The vegan/vegetarian cause would create more pragmatic change if it were more welcoming and respected those who are willing to cut back.
- snet0 5y agoSo it's not practical and you don't want to do it anyway?
- throwaway20234 5y agoYou get slammed for people not liking your response, but yet your point is spot on. The number of vegetarians has been pretty steady over the last decades in the US. Hoping people become all vegetarien isn't practical. If I was a dictator I'd ban meat eating, but I am not and that's good. As always: it's not allowed to ask for better people! We need to create a system that makes the wrong people do the right thing.
- nitrogen 5y agoWe need to create a system that makes the wrong people do the right thing. Or even better, a system that makes the "wrong" thing right (e.g. lab-grown meat).
- sokoloff 5y agoI have to admit as a meat eater that Impossible ground beef substitute is “there” on a taste basis now. If they can get it to 25% of its current cost, I could see it become viable to replace many uses of ground beef now. If they get it to 12-15% of its current cost, I think it would displace a massive percentage of purchases of meat protein. It really is good, not just “edible” and I can imagine they’re nowhere near the economic minimum cost to produce.
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 5y agoPeople aren't liking the response because it seems like it is saying "it isn't practical for me to take on this tiny inconvenience for the betterment of the world".