4 ms·
The key idea of a circle is that I have different kinds of content that I want to send to different audiences. Google+ currently handles that fact when it come
by btilly 15y ago
The key idea of a circle is that I have different kinds of content that I want to send to different audiences.
Google+ currently handles that fact when it comes to private content. It does not handle that fact with public content.
I agree that the whole public/private distinction is important to keep clear. But there are a lot of ways to do this. For instance make public circles blue when you add them, and private ones green. And add a tooltip to make it clear what the colors mean.
In short, I don't buy the idea that "grandma can't understand this" as a reason to deny a feature that a lot of people want. And that matters disproportionately to the top content producers.
- drivebyacct2 15y agoMy comment was not at all that "grandma can't understand this". I mean that the concept of Circles needs to either evolve to where it has almost a different meaning altogether AND/OR that there are better mechanisms for targetting content than circles. How many damn Circles am I going to end up with (politics, democrats, hacker, programmers, lgbt and allies, etc plus family, friends, coworkers) plus I now have circles that are used for privacy directionality and others used for announcements. But what about announcements I want to share, but just with my family? Circles are about privacy, I think that this tareted publishing is a categorically different idea and that Google doesn't even need to take the risk of muddling the Circles disinctions. Besides, I'm convinced a tagging system (cross reference links with other social networking sites, "read" the web pages and combine it with Prediction API, etc) or self-tagging or sharing within Sparks (like subreddits [if you've used them to understand how much they can change the experience of a social networking site], or even better because the conversation is smaller and more intimate) I feel like shoving it into Circles is brash and missing a good opportunity.
- bermanoid 15y agoIn short, I don't buy the idea that "grandma can't understand this" as a reason to deny a feature that a lot of people want. Along those lines, what people are asking for here is pretty much the ability to make Google+ a bit more like Twitter. From conversations with grandma and her ilk, grandma doesn't get Twitter, either, so I don't think you're losing very much. Google+ seems to be positioning itself as the Android to Facebook's iPhone, for people that want more control and don't mind jumping through a few more hoops as long as they have it. I think they've still got some complexity to burn, especially if they continue to make the UI as easy to comprehend as it's been thus far.