4 ms·
I think the point is that I haven't seen anything to imply that Adichie is transphobic. This is taken from her Wikipedia page: > In 2017, Adichie was criticize
by hn_throwaway_99 5y ago
I think the point is that I haven't seen anything to imply that Adichie is transphobic. This is taken from her Wikipedia page:
> In 2017, Adichie was criticized by some as transphobic, initially for saying that "my feeling is trans women are trans women."[44][9] Adichie later further clarified her statement, writing "that there is a distinction between women born female and women who transition, without elevating one or the other, which was my point. I have and will continue to stand up for the rights of transgender people."
Now granted, there may be more to the story that I am not aware of, but stating that there actually are differences between "women born female and women who transition" shouldn't be considered transphobic, it should be considered acknowledging reality.
- leephillips 5y agoTautologies are transphobic.
- jolux 5y agoBasically I think “trans women are trans women, and are in some ways different from cis women” in this instance is a motte-and-bailey with “we should be allowed to discriminate against trans women because they are different.” See: https://www.pinknews.co.uk/2020/11/15/chimamanda-ngozi-adichie-jk-rowling-transgender-essay-reasonable-twitter-backlash/ https://www.pinknews.co.uk/2020/11/15/chimamanda-ngozi-adich...
- oh_sigh 5y agoOkay - you've shown us the motte, but where is the bailey? Where does Chimamanda advocate for discrimination against trans women? Because there is nothing in your source that implies that. Also, that is only a motte in liberal circles. Saying "I have and will continue to stand up for the rights of transgender people" is not necessarily a no-brainer moral stance for the general population.
- arkaniad 5y agoThe bailey is in the othering of trans women as a separate class which opens opportunities for discrimination by separating them from women-at-large. And since we still have binary gender norms to contend heavily with in the US and beyond, this ends up playing out as bills banning trans women from playing in a league in accordance their gender, bathroom bills, etc. [1] There's a fantastic book about this written by Julia Serrano called 'Whipping Girl' [2] that goes over these things and more and describes these phenomena as 'Transmisogyny' - trans individuals being subject to both misogyny and misandry depending on the situation, and sometimes both when it's convenient. [1] - https://freedomforallamericans.org/legislative-tracker/anti-transgender-legislation/ https://freedomforallamericans.org/legislative-tracker/anti-... [2] - https://www.amazon.com/Whipping-Girl-Transsexual-Scapegoating-Femininity/dp/1580056229 https://www.amazon.com/Whipping-Girl-Transsexual-Scapegoatin...
- googlryas 5y agoWhy is speaking of "trans women" othering them into a separate class, but the same isn't true when speaking about "black women" - which is something that is celebrated in modern intersectionality theory? Don't trans women face unique challenges relating to their womanhood - just the same way that black women do?
- arkaniad 5y agoIf you're interested in an intersectional discussion, then sure. But too often this framing of 'trans women are trans women, not Women' is used in bad faith to open the dialog of "What should we do about them in women's spaces then, since they aren't?'
- googlryas 5y agoIsn't it bad faith to assume that someone who says something like "I have and will continue to stand up for the rights of transgender people" is actually arguing against the rights of transgender people without any evidence otherwise?
- hn_throwaway_99 5y agoI mean, I think what you are saying is the very thing so many people have an issue with, that if I try to say something that is definitely true, "trans women are trans women, and are in some ways different from cis women", automatically implies your second statement, "we should be allowed to discriminate against trans women because they are different." I mean, sure, some people may mean that, but one of Adichie's main beefs is that we always assume the worst in a very "if you're not with us it every way then you're against us", and that given Adichie's other actions and support for the LGBT community (no small feat in Nigeria) that she is at least somewhat deserving of the benefit of the doubt. Otherwise what you're left with is people feeling that their only option to not be considered transphobic is if they say "trans women are women and are the same as cis women", which gets at the heart of why people are so concerned about public discourse today.
- jolux 5y agoHave you read the Rowling essay? She advocates many discriminatory positions in it. Among them, she doesn't think trans women should be allowed in women's bathrooms, or other "single sex spaces." I don't think everyone who agrees with that statement is transphobic, but it's become a bit of a shibboleth amongst people who are, as it's often posed against the statement "trans women are women."
- Udik 5y ago> she doesn't think trans women should be allowed in women's bathrooms, ... a shibboleth amongst people who are, as it's often posed against the statement "trans women are women. Because the right to call yourself "trans woman" has been widened to the point of including people who didn't undergo any gender reassignment surgery or hormone therapy. And yes, I don't think that those "trans women" are, or should be considered, women. Actually, not even "trans".
- arkaniad 5y agoTransitioning is centered around the needs of each individual - many choose not to or are outright unable to receive surgery or medical transitioning, yet that doesn't make them any less trans. At the end of the day, it's their decision what to do with their body, not yours. All that is asked of you is to respect their decisions and treat them with the same amount of respect as you'd treat any other non-trans individual.
- ambicapter 5y agoCan you point out the bailey here? Because otherwise its just a motte.
- tyleo 5y agoI see your motte-and-bailey and I raise you a straw man. I don't think there is much to read into “trans women are trans women, and are in some ways different from cis women” from this author. I certainly don't read “we should be allowed to discriminate against trans women because they are different.” out of it and thus I'd consider the interpretation to be a strawman: its easier to attack the author for it but I don't think its what she meant. I think this gets at her point in the last paragraph, "the assumption of good faith is dead." If we interpret what the author said as the latter statement we are assuming it was said in bad faith.