5 ms·
Tried to find out what OP actually said in the interview she references, and it seems her point was about nuance, that the experiences of a trans woman are not
by kelnos 5y ago
Tried to find out what OP actually said in the interview she references, and it seems her point was about nuance, that the experiences of a trans woman are not the same as someone who was assigned female at birth.[0]
Which... I think should be a "well duh" sort of thing, but of course in our outrage-fueled chase-engagement-at-all-costs social media environment, that means that we have to twist things to assume the OP was actually saying "trans women are not women" (when she didn't say that and denies she was implying that). But I don't know; I'd never heard of her before this post, so maybe she has a history of saying shitty things and this is just the latest.[1] Or maybe it's what it looks like on its face, a few jealous, opportunistic people trying to smear her.
(I think it's telling that one of these people called out to their "followers" to attack OP with machetes. You've lost the moral high ground once you do that, if you hadn't already. I don't care how pissed you are, direct calls to violence toward another person, because of some words, automatically invalidates your viewpoint in my book.)
All this stuff just makes me sad and tired. And I know I'm privileged that I (being a straight, cis, white man) generally don't have to worry about any of this in my daily life. But I wish people could just listen to each other, and not immediately assume ill intent, or especially manufacture ill intent in order to bring someone down and elevate themselves. It's all just so counter-productive, and pushes people away who could otherwise be allies. Not saying that there aren't people out there who dog-whistle and say bad things just ambiguously enough for plausible deniability. But it feels like the default is to assume that of everyone who says anything, and that's gross.
> I have spoken to young people who tell me they are terrified to tweet anything, that they read and re-read their tweets because they fear they will be attacked by their own.
And all this just reminds me that I still need to get around to downloading my FB and Twitter history before deleting it all. (I'd really like to close my FB account, but outside of the pandemic use it heavily for event invitations. I might close my Twitter account, though.)
[0] https://www.theguardian.com/books/2017/mar/21/chimamanda-ngozi-adichie-nothing-to-apologise-for-transgender-women https://www.theguardian.com/books/2017/mar/21/chimamanda-ngo...
[1] Edit: ugh, seems like she's not great, at the very least: https://www.pinknews.co.uk/2020/11/15/chimamanda-ngozi-adichie-jk-rowling-transgender-essay-reasonable-twitter-backlash/ https://www.pinknews.co.uk/2020/11/15/chimamanda-ngozi-adich...
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- oh_sigh 5y agoWhat is not great about saying that "Trans women are trans women"? I thought modern feminist theory was about intersectionality, and isn't trying to rewrite a trans persons history to be equivalent to a cisgendered person's history the exact opposite of intersectionality?