5 ms·
This is far more complex to model, and near impossible to. I wouldn't expect to see this anytime soon. But to give you some hints, breakaway civilizations woul
by godelski 5y ago
This is far more complex to model, and near impossible to. I wouldn't expect to see this anytime soon.
But to give you some hints, breakaway civilizations would likely happen all the time. Every space program has issues with astronauts not following orders simply because the astronauts internalize the idea of "what are they going to do? Come get me?" This is frequently talked about in settings where they are discussing Moon and Mars colonization. A Martian colony won't really belong to the US/China/EU/whatever for very long. I'd expect something very similar to Red Mars/The Expanse.
Another big reason for this will simply be time of light communication delays. Between Earth and Mars that's 8-15 minutes one way. It is highly impractical to control a territory when communication takes so long, they will effectively become independent. We've seen this historically too. Colonies operate drastically differently than their home countries. Being so far away it is difficult to communicate and cultures will diverge, especially considering that their day to day lives will be drastically different. Different needs creates different cultures. But luckily this distance also makes war difficult between two planets. You have months to respond.
- thaumasiotes 5y ago> Every space program has issues with astronauts not following orders simply because the astronauts internalize the idea of "what are they going to do? Come get me?" From the script to Casino: > Every couple of weeks I used to send Marino back to the bosses with a piece of what I made. > Not a big piece, but fuck them, what did they know? They were fifteen hundred miles away... and I don't know anybody who can see that far. On the other hand... > Between Earth and Mars that's 8-15 minutes one way. It is highly impractical to control a territory when communication takes so long, they will effectively become independent. This is totally wrong. Between Earth and Earth, empires have exerted effective territorial control while communication one way took weeks. A 15 minute delay in communication is meaningless. The problem is the difficulty of traveling, not of communicating.
- pdonis 5y ago> empires have exerted effective territorial control while communication one way took weeks. That's because the effective territorial control was not exercised by the central government of the empire, but by territorial governments that were on the spot and that had pretty much complete authority to act on their own initiative without getting permission from the central government. They only had to meet very general policy goals. So the speed of communication with the central government was not relevant to the effectiveness of the territorial control. The question is whether a territorial government on, say, Mars would have the same loyalty to the central government on Earth that, say, British territorial governors had to the British empire. Without that loyalty on the part of the territorial governments that are on the spot, there is in fact no way for the central government to effectively control territories.
- pydry 5y agoMost of the same tactics used to control colonies could be used to control Mars. Moreover, Mars would probably be utterly dependent on earth for multiple generations.
- pdonis 5y ago> Most of the same tactics used to control colonies could be used to control Mars. Those tactics only work when backed up by a credible threat of overwhelming force. I do not think the Earth will be in a position to bring overwhelming force to bear on a Mars colony. It's a lot harder to do that across tens of millions of miles of space than it is to do it across an ocean. And even across oceans on Earth it often doesn't work. > Mars would probably be utterly dependent on earth for multiple generations. I'm not so sure. We have barely even started exploring Mars; we have no idea what resources exist there. We are still discovering new resources here on Earth; I would expect that humans on Mars would be doing the same there.
- godelski 5y ago> Moreover, Mars would probably be utterly dependent on earth for multiple generations. Probably not. The reason Mars colonization is difficult is because they have to be self reliant. It isn't like expanding in the past where people could live off the land or barter or steal from the native peoples. There are no natives on Mars. There is no native vegetation nor is the land adequate for farming/cultivating. In the past colonies could rely on these things and exploit them. Mars is very different. If you aren't self sufficient on Mars you will die. Period. Astronauts visiting Mars, just visiting, will have to figure this out too because they can't just land and come back. They have to wait a full year for the planets to realign (this is also why it is difficult to subjugate Mars because it isn't just about the travel time, it is about the orbits being aligned plus the travel time).
- pdonis 5y ago> They have to wait a full year for the planets to realign This actually shouldn't be true for much longer. The only reason it's true now is that we don't have spaceships that can produce constant thrust for the entire trip; our ships spend most of their time in free fall, which, as Robert Heinlein pointed out decades ago, is the equivalent of floating down the Mississippi on a raft. As he said, what we need are the equivalent of sailing ships: ships that can put out a constant thrust, even if it's small, for an entire trip. Even a thrust of 1/100 gee, which is well within our technical capability if we get serious about things like ion drives, would greatly reduce trip time to Mars (and would reduce trip times to more distant planets even more, since the advantage over free fall increases as the distance increases) and would open up a lot of options for travel that we don't currently have. Note that this doesn't change the fact that humans on Mars will have to be self-reliant; payload mass is still payload mass and a spaceship just won't be able to carry enough of it to Mars to supply life support for any length of time staying there. Sending unmanned missions in advance might help, but I don't think even that would be enough.