5 ms·
In its heyday Wikileaks was lauded by the left mainly because it provided evidence that the US did “bad things”. It didn’t matter that there was nothing bad co
by mc32 5y ago
In its heyday Wikileaks was lauded by the left mainly because it provided evidence that the US did “bad things”. It didn’t matter that there was nothing bad coming from China or Russia or Nigeria. All that mattered back then is that he had dirt on the US.
But... then there was a falling out between the left and Assange when he found out Hillary wished out loud that he was dead and he then cherry picked the bad stuff even more... though he never had inauthentic releases. They just didn’t like what they saw (in the mirror).
So, it’s clear his motives shifted (given the circumstances it was reasonable), but the left suddenly didn’t want more dirt from him cuz he was making them look bad (and forced the question, are WE the baddies?)...
So here we are, he was the useful idiot they now can throw under the bus accusing him of being in cahoots with the Russians (a charge dismissed when people on the right claimed the same back in the good old days way back when Wikileaks and the left were aligned)
- at_a_remove 5y agoCan't we just drone this guy?
- gadders 5y agoI agree. He's harmed both the left and the right. Perhaps he actually is politically neutral?
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- mr_overalls 5y ago> It didn’t matter that there was nothing bad coming from China or Russia or Nigeria. All that mattered back then is that he had dirt on the US. Because liberals hate America, right? This sort of thinking from conservatives baffles me. Improvement of any sort - personal, cultural, political - depends on acknowledging legitimate criticism. US citizens aren't required to be blindly loyal to their country. To state an obvious near-tautology, the only way to make things better is to encourage and facilitate useful criticism, so that bad things can be improved. The relative lack of freedom to criticize is exactly why so many autocratic states become mired in corruption; there's no non-destructive mechanism for accountability and change in government.
- mc32 5y agoIt’s a legitimate concern and we can always improve, so it kind of baffles me that now the left find him antithetical when they used to laud him just because he doesn’t follow their narrative. Never the less, what he releases can always be used for improvement even by the left, but it seems they don’t want to hear it any more.
- mr_overalls 5y agoI think it depends on your definition of constructive criticism. Assange breaking news of US coverups of war-zone crimes is useful, imho. Assange serving as a mouthpiece of Russian disinformation is not.
- mc32 5y agoWhere has he released inauthentic (untruthful) information?
- mr_overalls 5y agoHe kept claiming that DNC staffer Seth Rich was the source of the leaked DNC emailes (and not Russian military/GRU hackers) and that Rich had been killed as a result. He also released actual CIA hacking tools (Vault 7), which was a monumentally stupid, destructive act.
- knodi123 5y ago> In its heyday Wikileaks was lauded by the left mainly because it provided evidence that the US did “bad things”. That's because it's a valuable service. Look, I'd love it if sunshine could shine equally into all corners of the world, but if an ideologically impure weirdo with bad hygiene and some vile sexual habits wants to shine sunshine just into my own country's dark corners.... then fine! I want my country to live up to its own ideals, and that requires making everyone aware of when it doesn't. Justice isn't a zero-sum international game of tit-for-tat.
- simiones 5y ago> some vile sexual habits If you're referring to the allegations made against Assange and investigated by the Swedish prosecutor's office that forced him to remain confined in the embassy in the UK, then those were dropped, and the UN special investigator who looked at Assange's case found that the whole investigation was conducted in bad faith: https://www.exberliner.com/features/julian-assange-trial-2020/nils-melzer-assange/ https://www.exberliner.com/features/julian-assange-trial-202... > But that’s exactly the point. I don’t know whether Julian Assange committed sexual assault or not, but what I do know is that Sweden never cared to find out. They wanted to use these allegations to discredit him. And once they had actively spread these allegations into every corner of the world, they then made sure that there would never be a proper trial because, as the prosecutor finally admitted in November 2019, they never had sufficient evidence to even press charges against Julian Assange.
- knodi123 5y agoQuoting the source you linked, > Sweden went out of its way to make sure the public was informed of the allegations against Assange, even against the will of the concerned women, So- these women (plural) DID make allegations. And if publicizing them was against the womens' will, then we know that they didn't make these claims for the sake of publicity. I'll readily believe that Sweden publicized them with political intent, and that they didn't have enough evidence to successfully prosecute. But what evidence there is (regardless of legal standards) definitely exists, and has not been recanted, and I have seen nothing to suggest it was a lie. And in general, I believe women. Just because it's not up to a legal standard of convincingness doesn't mean we have to just ignore it.
- slg 5y agoWhy are you criticizing the left for only caring about corruption from the opposing political side but Assange gets a pass for only caring about corruption from the opposing political side? The truth is only being anti-corruption when your opponent is corrupt and ignoring corruption from your allies is itself a form of corruption.
- tootie 5y agoThe criticism of Assange I'm stating isn't that he's choosing his targets, it's that he is fundamentally dishonest.
- moksly 5y agoI’m not an American so I may have a different perspective on it than you, but is Hillary Clinton the left? From my perspective she sort of make Margret Tatcher look like a socialist. I do think most of us were fooled by wikileaks because it starter out being against the Iraq war. This was before snowden, back when people weren’t actually being serious when they joked about echelon listening in on us. It was also back when we, at least in Europe, figures that Russia was going to be our friend and it was sort of pre-information war. Apparently the information was was already well on its way, but we didn’t really know, and we didn’t take anyone who warned us serious. Us being the general public. It was also a world where everything surrounding American politics, and to some extend all western politics, wasn’t always this us/them, left/right, blue/red nonsense that it is today. Anyone, from the most conservative to the most liberal who watched the wikileaks leaks on the journalist and the children being killed by drones (or maybe it was far away airplanes) were appalled by it, because it was simply appalling and back then, people cared more about wrong/right than their “team” looking good. So I think it is understandable that people bought into wikileaks being genuine but these days… well… let’s just say that the west still hasn’t recovered from in the war on truthful information and that we are still struggling with trust issues and all the wonderful things like flat-earth, anti-vaccine and what not stupidity that’s running ever more rampant in our society. Among other things, because people like Assange showed us why we shouldn’t trust our institutions.
- Mediterraneo10 5y agoIn the 1990s, while first lady, Clinton served on a task force for public healthcare [0], and she wrote a book entitled It Takes a Village arguing for this and other state intervention. Regardless of how left she is compared to parties in other countries, this immediately placed her on the left of the USA's partisan divide. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Clinton_health_care_plan_of_1993 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Clinton_health_care_plan_of_19... [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/It_Takes_a_Village https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/It_Takes_a_Village
- simiones 5y agoI'm sure that as a child she also believed sharing is caring. Her current political positions are significantly to the right of that.
- DyslexicAtheist 5y agothe point is that the US is the only super-power. so comparing BadThings done by the US with BadThings done by Russia or Nigeria or some other place would be nothing but whataboutism. if a country is nr. 1 and runs the biggest propaganda operation the world has ever seen (Hollywood, Netflix, but also US based social media companies inventing algorithms that influence and steer behavior) then they need to be treated with large amount of pressure and critic to everything they do (justified or not). The problem in all of this is that the emperor has no clothes. E.g. the emperor being the polarized US public that doesn't see that their country didn't have any form of coherent foreign policy that wasn't a racist, war-mongering and hypocrite "America first" (since at least Reagan).