5 ms·
I think this is great, if only as a way to kill the bullshit consumer VPN business, which sells snake oil.
by Spooky23 5y ago
I think this is great, if only as a way to kill the bullshit consumer VPN business, which sells snake oil.
- VWWHFSfQ 5y agowhat is bullshit about it
- KMnO4 5y agoHave you noticed all the ads say “Hackers can spy on your connection when you log into your bank at Starbucks.” That’s complete FUD. HTTPS completely avoids this issue (especially with a bank). Very few websites use HTTP now. While VPNs do have their valid use (preventing your ISP from spying, changing geolocation, and private networks for eg, work), most of the marketing is spreading misinformation.
- anonymouse008 5y agoI've never understood how a VPN doesn't get too carried away to pull a MITM with some central cert
- gjsman-1000 5y agoBecause if you used a central cert, every device would have to whitelist that cert, and just clocking the lock icon in your browser would reveal it.
- jen20 5y agoMany consumer VPNs install a client, and it would be trivial to ship a new trusted certificate with it.
- acdha 5y agoThis is true, but note that, for example, on iOS an application can't do that without prompting. Now, most people would probably hit “Approve” if one of their security products said it was necessary.
- gjsman-1000 5y agoThat wouldn’t change that clicking the lock icon in your browser would show the same certificate on every website, and that this certificate was universally valid. Pretty obvious…
- AdamJacobMuller 5y ago> show the same certificate on every website Not really, because, you can use on-demand certificate issuance. Hell, if you really want to, you can even name your certificates the same as existing certificates and the only way to detect the forgery would be to compare the actual public keys (and who does THAT). I feel like I'm writing an evil roadmap here, but, you can even do multiple root certs with different names and trust them all, do a whole "fake" PKI infrastructure which would be impossible to detect unless you were comparing the actual keys.
- anonymouse008 5y ago> I feel like I'm writing an evil roadmap here, but, you can even do multiple root certs with different names and trust them all, do a whole "fake" PKI infrastructure which would be impossible to detect unless you were comparing the actual keys. Yeah, just imagine being beholden to some federal statue impropriety (easiest in taxes) and running one of the these vpn organizations...
- 0x0 5y agoIf and when browsers start requiring pre-certificate transparency logging, anything like this should no longer be possible to pull off, since none of the fake certificates would be able to contain a stapled pre-certificate "signoff" from a trusted CT log.
- throw0101a 5y ago> Many consumer VPNs install a client, and it would be trivial to ship a new trusted certificate with it. A lot of browsers have their own root chain, and also now do certificate pinning, so will (IIRC) only accept specifically designated certs for particular sites (doesn't Google/Chrome/Gmail do this?).
- Nextgrid 5y agoOn the other hand, a lot of VPNs provide proprietary client software (even though all the major OSes have built-in support for the common VPN protocols such as IPSec, L2TP, etc) so they could very well sneak the root cert in there too.
- flixic 5y agoI've seen stats for a couple of the biggest VPNs. Massive majority of their traffic is just switching geolocation restrictions (US Netflix and similar). They don't tend to advertise that. Some do, but it's not their main message, because "prevent ISPs from spying" is cleaner. iCloud+ does not solve this, so there will be a sustained need for VPNs, particularly those that invest effort into into avoiding Netflix blacklists.
- tpush 5y ago> They don't tend to advertise that. IME of podcast advertising they all advertise this very openly.
- dehrmann 5y ago> “Hackers can spy on your connection when you log into your bank at Starbucks.” I've also heard this from a reputable news source (NPR) in the past few years, even though it hasn't been true for banks for at least 15 years, ~5 for most websites.
- Spooky23 5y agoYou’re “protecting” yourself against Starbucks monitoring you by establishing a secure connection to a grey market entity with more of an interest in your activity.
- vmception 5y agoInternet reselling doesn’t have nearly as much privacy as internet resellers suggest If you are only hiding from your local network and ISP its fine If you want to do that and change your location to a website it’s fine If you are hiding from any government for a civil or criminal charge it is not fine If you are hiding from any government intelligence so nobody knows anything it is not fine It doesnt matter what “no logging” claims the internet reseller has, this is not verifiable and can also change at any moment
- olivierestsage 5y agoI think that's painting with a pretty broad brush. What's wrong with Mullvad, for example?
- casefields 5y agoThe issue here preference falsification: >Preference falsification is the act of communicating a preference that differs from one's true preference. The public frequently conveys, especially to researchers or pollsters, preferences that differ from what they truly want, often because they believe the conveyed preference is more acceptable socially. The reason why the VPN business is booming is to avoid those pesky content infringement letters, and to workaround geo restrictions. OP is upset that they advertise themselves as privacy tools, but that's just marketing.
- KingMachiavelli 5y agoYea you don't legally market your product as a tool to commit a crime but 'privacy' is pretty broad term and partially true so it works.
- symlinkk 5y agoWho runs Mullvad? I find it funny that people here mistrust companies like Facebook and Google, but then turn around and hand off their entire network activity to a faceless, anonymous VPN company.
- olivierestsage 5y agoI think a lot of that distinction turns on how well your network data is linked to your identity. In the case of Mullvad, you can pay them anonymously by putting cash in an envelope and just mailing it to them,[1] which lowers the trust factor involved. [1] https://mullvad.net/en/pricing/ https://mullvad.net/en/pricing/
- woah 5y agoThey still have your real IP address, which is what you were trying to hide in the first place
- wintermutestwin 5y agoDoesn't a consumer VPN keep my ISP from building a data profile on me? Yes, I get that now my VPN provider can build that data profile, but I am certain that my ISP is a vile monopoly that has corrupted the regulators that are supposed to represent me.
- dehrmann 5y agoI have Sonic, so I trust my ISP more than a random VPN provider. Even if you have AT&T, they have a legal team that makes they provide a lot of opt-outs. I don't trust that they work, but there are a lot more eyes on them than a VPN provider.
- izacus 5y ago> I think this is great, if only as a way to kill the bullshit consumer VPN business, which sells snake oil. Having a US megacorporation kill a whole market segment and pull it into their monopolized walled garden sure seems like an improvement. After all, they pinky promise they will not ever abuse that! /s
- massysett 5y agoBy this logic our computer operating systems would not improve, ever. Web browsers, built-in networking, music players, image editors, mail programs, even Solitare - all things that at one time were separate market segments.
- izacus 5y agoAll of those products have been improved by COMPETITION. The most critical, most important and ONLY thing that makes modern capitalism work for non-rich human beings. Every single field you mention was thriving when there were multiple players fighting over your money and have started to become exploitative and abusive as soon as one player killed the others and started rent-seeking. Competition is crucial for market economy to work. I find it utterly bizarre that someone educated would think that a death of market by megacorp monopoly would somehow drive improvement.
- Spooky23 5y agoConsumer VPN isn’t a market where competition is driving better products. All of the products are the same technically - it’s a trivial service to standup. Sort of like a home security company… there are good ones, but most are garbage peddling FUD, especially fear. The differentiation is purely marketing. Some VPN providers are basically grey market means to bypass TV blackouts. Others claim to be privacy focused, but are in fact the opposite. A few are actually privacy focused. IMO, having megacorp(s) roll up the junk use cases actually drives meaningful competition by putting the lousy players out of business or driving consolidation in a crowded market.
- amazingman 5y ago