5 ms·
You know that the Linux kernel was used as a stop gap for creating Android? Google didn't want to be always tied directly to the Linux kernel and it's medieval
by rvz 5y ago
You know that the Linux kernel was used as a stop gap for creating Android? Google didn't want to be always tied directly to the Linux kernel and it's medieval development structure; hence the reason why Fuchsia was made.
As much as I hate saying this but I'm so sorry but the reality is, Fuchsia is going to replace Android and ChromeOS and the Zircon kernel will probably be optimised to be used on Google's own Silicon; super-seeding the need for using Linux anyway.
If you're already worried by Fuchsia, are you already afraid that Google will stop contributing to Linux? Possibly. But this only concerns Android and ChromeOS. Linux should be fine on the server. However, it's just that it has no path to the desktop commercially.
> But isn't it a good thing? Should we run all jump ship ASAP?
Change is very good.
The obsession of the Unix philosophy and its clones had a great 50 year run; with Linux almost in its 40th anniversary. It's time to move onto modern and secure alternatives with a clean slate. Not another Unix clone or another Linux distro.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- kleer001 5y agofwiw > super-seeding supersede : To take the place of; replace or supplant. > Change is very good. Hmmm. Not always and not for everyone. Evolution is good, but not for the 99% of extinct species. Still, better adapted systems persist. The real danger is local maxima. Which is why predators are needed. Still, lots of infrastructure is based on outdated technology, generations behind the bleeding edge, for the very reason that it works predictably. And we want infrastructure to work for a long time.
- rvz 5y agoFuchsia/Zircon is and already can be made compatible via a virtualised Linux kernel running under Zircon. So your point is? Fuchsia is acting as a compatibility bridge to migrate over the fragmented Android arena you see before you onto a unified system that Google can push updates seamlessly just like it did recently; starting with the Nest Hub. It was invisible to the user and was updated without warning or fanfare. In this context, it is better to replace this 'outdated technology' than to keep fixing the existing system because it is riddled with hidden bugs and holes. Perhaps this cannot be solved with the Unix philosophy (or in its clones) as it is riddled with holes and legacy oddities. This is why technologies like Rust exist to eventually replace C/C++ and Fuchsia exists to eventually replace Android. Unix had a good run (and is not designed for security in mind). So it is time for a clean slate.
- kleer001 5y ago> So your point is? My point is the wider evolutionary context. Otherwise I don't have anything new to add to the discussion. I don't disagree with your main idea except its aspect of totality. Even Lunduke said as much. There will still be pockets, there will still be extant lineages.
- gabrielsroka 5y agoLinux is 30 years old, not 40.