7 ms·
Google Messages end-to-end encryption is now out of beta
- greatgib 5y agoI'm the only one annoyed that they try to hijack sms to discreetly replace it with their own messaging system, in a desperate move to finally have a "messenger" service that is successful? If I use a sms, it is to use a sms. If I want to use an advanced heavy messenger, I will use one. No one prevent them to lunch a dedicated app...
- devoutsalsa 5y agoYup. I don’t like how iMessage also hijacks SMS.
- mnd999 5y agoDeprecation and EOL coming in a couple of weeks then?
- runnerup 5y agohttps://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27497207 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27497207 'dang says: > All: please don't post shallow, reflexive reactions to a story like this, even if you're sure you're right. Such reactions are 100% predictable (e.g. see https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27497174 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27497174), and predictability hurts more than rightness helps [0]. Predictable discussions are tedious and invariably lead to worse—for example, tedious discussions turn nasty because that's the only thing the mind has left to amuse itself with [1]. Edit: I saw that your post got fully flagged during the time it took me to copy/paste this from a previous post I made. I didn't downvote you or flag you, but other people may have based on this guideline.
- drcongo 5y agoGoogle Messages wasn't end to end encrypted?!
- smt88 5y agoSMS/MMS have never been encrypted. Messages is only able to add encryption because of RCS, a new cellular messaging protocol.
- approxim8ion 5y agoUntil very recently, it was just SMS. So no, far from it. Then they switched to RCS where available (although it might have been opt-in), but the encryption was not implemented. Now it looks like it is.
- drcongo 5y agoThanks, I hadn't realised it was just SMS.
- pmlnr 5y agoUh... no SMS is not encrypted.
- drcongo 5y agoAnd to think you could have politely explained to someone who has never owned an android device that Google Messages is what Google calls SMS for some reason, like the other replies did. But you chose this response, which I think says more about you than me.
- bushbaba 5y agoWhat is google messages. Is it the new name for gchat/hangouts?
- izacus 5y agoIt's the default Android SMS client (think iMessage on Apple devices). Not all OEMs use it though (e.g. Samsung being the major exception).
- smt88 5y agoFor posterity: Google Talk (often called GChat) became Hangouts. Hangouts is being deprecated. A separate app named Hangouts Chat was released and has been renamed to Google Chat. Google Chat and Hangouts share message history, but are otherwise separate. Google Messages (previously Android Messages) is the Google-supplied SMS/MMS/RCS app for Android.
- sliken 5y agoHeh, yeah it's a mess. There's been talk, chat, hangouts, but also duo, allo, messages, and meet.
- runnerup 5y agoI believe it's the "Rich SMS" feature similar to iOS messaging. It transparently uses the SMS application but when messaging someone with a compatible app on their own phone, will send messages over a TCP/IP protocol, "RCS", instead of using the fairly outdated SMS system. This allows better transfer of videos, pictures, audio clips, etc. SMS has MMS for these but it's tuned for very low bandwidth so it mangles a lot of attachments by limiting their size. More info here: https://arstechnica.com/gadgets/2019/11/google-to-roll-out-rcs-messaging-to-us-android-devices/ https://arstechnica.com/gadgets/2019/11/google-to-roll-out-r... When I had a Samsung galaxy I had to go pretty far out of my way to install google's messenger and use it instead of the Samsung SMS client. I'm pretty sure that' will be similar for the vast majority of android users. This would only be the default SMS application on google's Pixel phones. However, maybe carriers' and OEM's SMS applications are now integrating RCS protocol as well. Edit: I thought that a Google Pixel using Google SMS app with RCS and a Samsung galaxy using Samsung SMS app with RCS would be able to communicate over RCS. User 'hocuspocus claims this is, surprisingly, not the case: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27526166 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27526166 User 'dcomp is able to do this with his wife though, so maybe YMMV?
- speedgoose 5y agoHow can we be sure that the messages are not analysed before being encrypted ? Gmail reads the emails to suggest ads and they don't have a good privacy reputation.
- deadmutex 5y agoI think you should really spell out what you mean by analysed here. E.g. does a spellchecker that doesn't leak info and is all on device count as an analyser, etc. > Gmail reads the emails to suggest ads. Is this still true? IIUC, this is no longer true, and hasn't been for years. [1] https://support.google.com/mail/answer/6603?hl=en https://support.google.com/mail/answer/6603?hl=en [2] https://www.nytimes.com/2017/06/23/technology/gmail-ads.html https://www.nytimes.com/2017/06/23/technology/gmail-ads.html Disclaimer: Work at Google, but not on ads/gmail, etc.
- Arnavion 5y ago>IIUC, this is no longer true, and hasn't been for years. Their privacy policy says otherwise. https://policies.google.com/privacy?hl=en#infocollect https://policies.google.com/privacy?hl=en#infocollect (This is the "Privacy" link in GMail's footer.) >We want you to understand the types of information we collect as you use our services >We collect information to provide better services to all our users — from figuring out basic stuff like which language you speak, to more complex things like which ads you’ll find most useful, the people who matter most to you online, or which YouTube videos you might like. >[...] >Things you create or provide to us >[...] >We also collect the content you create, upload, or receive from others when using our services. This includes things like email you write and receive, photos and videos you save, docs and spreadsheets you create, and comments you make on YouTube videos.
- hocuspocus 5y agoIt's great but among my contacts, I can count the people using Google Messages on one hand. I cannot send an RCS message from my Pixel to my wife's carrier-provisioned RCS app on her Samsung phone. Google doesn't seem to be interested in a federated and interconnected RCS infrastructure anymore.
- dcomp 5y agoProbably some weird carrier RCS registration issue. My wife uses a s10e on EE (UK) and I use a Pixel 4 XL on Vodafone (UK) and I get RCS messages between us. Only use it for the delivery and read notifications but it works. I do remember having loads of problems with RCS registration failing on the Samsung side, or just disabling itself. Edit: Specifically I think it won't register whilst on WiFi and requires the correct mobile APN. I used to switch APNs to get a public IP address/ unfiltered internet
- hocuspocus 5y agoIt's not an issue on the device, I asked my carrier, Google won't let them interconnect RCS to Jibe. To my understanding, carriers were encouraged to either implement Universal Profile on their own or use a Google-operated "Jibe as a service" infrastructure. The former are now completely isolated from Google's network. To me it looks like British carriers are simply using Jibe.
- izacus 5y agoYeah, RCS is also broken on my Samsung phone and keeps deregistering itself. The dual-SIM support is also non-existent (which shows how every single of our comms services are built by Americans where dualSIM phones have been blocked by carriers for years). In general it's a completely trash fire situation where we're pretty much forced to use proprietary services without APIs to communicate.
- dcomp 5y agoI remember thinking RCS was a great idea and everyone saying it was useless as it didn't support E2E. [0] But I love that RCS has enabled cross carrier (For carriers supporting RCS) E2E messaging. And the main benefit over iMessage is that there isn't the messaging blackhole problem when changing device. [0] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16919875 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16919875
- approxim8ion 5y agoMy problem with this is that it is "Google Messages end-to-end encryption", rather than "RCS end-to-end encryption". It's not a distinction without a difference because it ties me down to a single RCS client and discourages interoperability. The moment I send an RCS message over Google Messages to someone who is using a different RCS app, I'm assuming it will just send plaintext. Having Google Messages preinstalled on all Android phones and set as the default is not a good solution either. Encryption has to be baked into the protocol, not individual clients.
- izacus 5y agoSure, but what exactly do you expect here though? Telecom operators (your own most likely among them) have decided to lobby and block any kind of E2E messaging and have also been directly dragging their feet at implementing even the unsecure RCS protocol. The pretty much only choice left is to give you messages to proprietary services - either Apple, Facebook, Google or Signal. If you can get anyone to use the last one.
- approxim8ion 5y agoWell, you have Matrix and XMPP (+OMEMO), but obviously the adoption for those is even lower than Signal. It's just sad is all.
- driminicus 5y agoIIRC matrix was started because of how terrible RCS is.
- Arathorn 5y agoThis is true. Matrix was a direct reaction to our experiences having just implemented RCS 5.1.
- izacus 5y agoYeah, still, the biggest issue was carriers (especially US ones) actively fighting against preloaded messaging clients and attempting to "compete" with their own (see Verizon RCS saga). Matrix doesn't help you if carrier refuses to sell phones that feature it preinstalled.
- jaimex2 5y agoAnything Google and messaging makes me smile. Any bets on how long this one will live?
- izacus 5y agoIt's been living for 6 years now - it's the Android SMS client after all.
- tut-urut-utut 5y agoOne more messaging solution from Google. I guess they didn't release (and abandon) enough of them ;) Anyways, I trust Google my messages even less than Facebook.
- remus 5y agoIt's not another messaging solution, it's a new feature in the google messaging app on android that's been around forever.
- pmlnr 5y agoI have mixed feelings about this, and especially about the google application: it's nearly 300MB. In comparison, Conversations, which is a full-fledged XMPP client with voice and video included, is ~70MB. Beyond this, any use of the google app comes with lengthy Terms & Conditions, which is not something I really want in my SMS application. I moved to Simple SMS Messenger[^1], which doesn't support anything beyond basic SMS & MMS, but it's small, fast, and open source. [^1]: https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.simplemobiletools.smsmessenger https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.simplemobi...
- dheera 5y agoI deprecated SMS 10 years ago and don't use it anymore. There are better, newer things, like e-mail.
- arkitaip 5y agoIt's the only async channel that works with all people as long as you have their phone number. Anything else requires that you use a specific app or network. Email is too formal for most people and, I've discovered, some people don't have it set up on their phones, so it can become too async/slow.
- dheera 5y agoWell (a) SMS doesn't work with me (b) A lot of SMS messages to my Twilio numbers get dropped so it's a shitty protocol (c) SMS based on a SIM card number can't be used if the SIM card is changed (d) SMS is limited in how many bytes it can send while with e-mail you can easily send megabytes. If it's too formal that's their problem. Also, I would never give one of my 10+ phone numbers to someone who I wouldn't give an e-mail address to, except maybe my one junk/spam number.
- pmlnr 5y agoemail is from the end of the 60s. SMS is the GSM service layer, so no, email is not newer. I agree email is better in most terms, but sms slips through without data, and nothing else does because of what it is.
- aero-glide2 5y agoElement chat (Matrix) used to be slow, but now its much better. That's what I use now. Open source, e2e encrypted, and you can even setup your own server.
- xchip 5y agoIt will be encrypted until they get a big enough base of users, then they will be like the rest. I am on signal.
- trasz 5y agoOne thing I don’t understand here is why would anyone bother with RCS?
- bjoli 5y agoSo, has anyone been able to use it in the beta? Me and mo brother are both in the beta programme, but no sign of encryption for us despite being RCS-enabled. We have tried every few weeks without success Is it only rolling out in the US?