7 ms·
EFF Browser Tracker Simulator
- cod3rboy 5y agoChrome does not protect from web tracking whereas edge has strong web tracking protection.
- spullara 5y agoI'm unique!
- ec109685 5y ago> Within our dataset of several hundred thousand visitors tested in the past 45 days, only one in 11983.11 browsers have the same fingerprint as yours. Given the way iOS works, does this mean only one in about 12k users are on iOS 14.6 using a iPhone 12 (my configuration). That seems to be what the fingerprint boils down to?
- spoonalious 5y agoTime zone, your phones memory, screen size (eg, 12 Max, Mini, otherwise), what browser you accessed it with (more using Safari on iOS than Chrome).
- ec109685 5y agoTime zone is good point. Just tested a iPhone 12 Pro and iPhone 12 and results were identical (despite having different amounts of memory).
- cyral 5y agoIt uses a lot more advanced techniques too, like rendering text and shapes in a hidden canvas + webgl, which will render slightly different between hardware, drivers, etc. Was also surprised to see that my HTTP_ACCEPT header was unique in 1 of nearly 5,000 devices, considering I am on a fresh (literally days old) MacOS install.
- Rebelgecko 5y agoFor me the most interesting part is where they break down how many bits of information is leaked by the various signals. Do browsers ever try to fuzz any of these values? For example lying about what GPU I'm using, or occasionally swapping between equivalent timezones?
- KirillPanov 5y ago> Do browsers ever try to fuzz any of these values? Brave does, and it is absolutely the right approach to fingerprinting. They call it "farbling" rather than "fuzzing": https://github.com/brave/brave-browser/issues/8787 https://github.com/brave/brave-browser/issues/8787 The alternative is what Firefox does (halfheartedly), which is to try to make users look similar to each other. It really bothers me that Firefox is so stuck on this approach -- in every other way I prefer Firefox over Brave and I really do not want to switch just for this one feature. But Firefox's halfway implementation of "try to make everybody look similar" is doomed: a serious effort would turn Firefox into TorBrowser-with-javascript-disabled or worse, which is never going to work. To Firefox's credit, one area where Brave is having problems with this is font fingerprinting, because they don't control their own rendering engine (it's Chromium). So Firefox could "do Brave-style antifingerprinting" better than Brave does, if they got serious about it: https://github.com/brave/brave-browser/issues/816 https://github.com/brave/brave-browser/issues/816
- olliej 5y agoGPUs specifically are hard to mask. Because gpus are terrible ( ;D ) and you have to expose a lot of details for webgl apps to work correctly (despite my efforts to limit feature set in the distant past), and hiding or adding details to that could break them so you have to assume that any site that's interested can know exactly what GPU you have.
- PeterisP 5y agoIMHO for most users it would make all sense to just break webgl apps except if you explicitly whitelist a particular site where you really want to use a webgl app there. If some random blog or webstore pretends to be a webgl app for tracking purposes, the browser should just auto-deny everything.
- qiqitori 5y agoWebGL Vendor & Renderer Intel Open Source Technology Center~Mesa DRI Intel(R) HD Graphics 630 (Kaby Lake GT2) One in x browsers have this value: 13012.06 Also 1920x1200 isn't as common as I thought, "One in x browsers have this value: 95.68"
- PaulDavisThe1st 5y agoYes, the 1920x1200 feature was surprisingly rare given that my h/w concurrency (16) was scored at about 1 in 39.
- supermatt 5y agoApparently I have strong protection against tracking, but it’s also saying I have a unique fingerprint among all users that have used the app (220k)? I’m just running IOS/safari (same UA as 1/113 users) It seems I’d be easy to track based on my unique fingerprint? Or is there some other factor not mentioned that means my fingerprint isn’t expected to be unique in a larger set? If so, how large?
- SimeVidas 5y agoAFAIK, the only un-fingerprintable browser is Brave (because it randomizes certain web API return values between navigations).
- Santosh83 5y agoSomewhat unrelated but the Brave website is broken under the latest Firefox 89 + uBlock Origin (I have no other extensions/themes installed). The entire site is just a blurred, acrylic like mess. If you open in Firefox's safe mode though, it works fine. Which suggests it is uBlock Origin, but curiously the site doesn't work even if I disable uBlock for the domain. PS. It seems Mozilla have removed the "report broken site" option from Firefox's Help menu. There is only report deceptive site.
- SimeVidas 5y agoThe recommended place to report such an issue is https://webcompat.com/ https://webcompat.com/
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- ttprru 5y agoThe Tor Browser is designed to be "un-fingerprintable" as well, though instead of randomizing return values it prefers to return the same thing for every user.
- 5y ago
- new_realist 5y agoI’m not sure this site takes into account correlations between different attributes. If not, it overestimates how unique you are. Also, it doesn’t include your IP address, which is the most identifying piece of information. All in all, a slanted site fit to push an agenda.
- theiasson 5y ago> All in all, a slanted site fit to push an agenda. What kind of agenda is it trying to push?
- gundmc 5y agoThe EFF is a lobbying group. Presumably pushing the agenda they lobby for - namely digital rights and privacy as they would envision it.
- MauranKilom 5y agoMy IP address changes daily. As do the IP addresses of most people in several countries.
- new_realist 5y agoThat’s enough to track you across recent sites, and if any of those sites use a cookie that spans a day, to track you across days.
- SCLeo 5y agoIf it doesn't take correlations into account, then the total # of identifying bits (aka entropy) will simply be the sum of # of identifying bits in each category, which does not seem to be the case. Therefore, I will guess it does take correlations into account (presumably by calculating the total # from uniqueness of the fingerprint only).
- scott_1635 5y agoThanks for sharing, I found a lot of interesting information here. A really good post, very thankful and helpful. https://www.mybalancenow.bid/ https://www.mybalancenow.bid/
- 1vuio0pswjnm7 5y agoMost traffic on the web is from "bots" not browsers. These "fingerprint" analyses all seem to fail to account for that fact. "Bots" generally do not run Javascript. The more information the client sends, the easier it is to create a more complex "fingerprint" and the more difficult it is for users to "copy" this fingerprint. GET / HTTP/1.1 Host: firstartytrackersimulator.org Connection: close No Javascript. Of course, anyone can make a fingerprint from those three headers. However it is quite generic and very easy for any user to "copy". Many website operators incorrectly assume this must be a "bot". I can use a "modern" web browser that tries to send all sorts of information, but because I use a localhost-bound forward proxy that deletes, adds and/or modifies headers, these three headers are all the remote website will ever see. The question is, what advertiser is seriously going to spend time and effort to try to show ads to a person who only sends three generic headers and does not run Javascript. There is little value in tracking such users if they do not convert.
- beermonster 5y agoI find the more you try to protect your identity, preserve your privacy, protect your security the less sites want you to visit. You get stuck behind CloudFlare interactive prompts (as half the planet seems to be using CloudFlare in some way) whilst it tries to work out if you’re a bot. The other sites either assume you’re an attacker and say bye, or try and stick you in some kind of CAPTCHA tar-pit. In short the web becomes unusable the better you get at this.
- frombody 5y agoYou are likely getting stuck behind Cloudflare prompts because you are attempting to 'hide your identity' via tor or VPN service. You're likely attempting to use the same channels as attackers, but want to be treated differently 'just because' Kind of hard to write rules for criteria like that.
- beermonster 5y agoI do not use tor or a VPN service.
- unixfg 5y agoWhat seems to really get me on this test is having an eGPU plugged into my Mac.
- hpaavola 5y agoFirefox has "privacy.resistFingerprinting" setting which eliminated many fingerprinting mechanisms (at least time zone, resolution, canvas, webgl, maybe others). Anyone know what major sites it breaks or what other drawbacks there are setting it True? It defaults to False.
- dheerajvs 5y agoI had to reset it to False due to one annoying consequence: Since the time zone is set to UTC, all my workmates on Slack assumed I'm working from another country. And I had to mentally calculate time differences. It was the only major issue but was too much of a hassle.
- looperhacks 5y agoI just enabled it to try how it changes the results. Many data points vanished, but suddenly the screen size doesn't show my actual screen size (1920x1080, not very unique) but the size of my viewport (very unique, considering I have a sidebar active). Can somebody confirm this? Why would this setting affect this?
- red_trumpet 5y agoI made the same observation. I also have a sidebar, and after enabling resistFingerprinting, the screen size is a unique identifier for me. Edit: Here [1] is a relevant link from the mozilla support forum. It links to an old bug report in Tor, and they claim that this actually reveals less information about you. Imo it still makes tracking easier, but I didn't really dig into it. [1] https://support.mozilla.org/en-US/questions/1200851#answer-1067814 https://support.mozilla.org/en-US/questions/1200851#answer-1...
- fsflover 5y agoDoesn't it mean that each time you resize your browser you get a different fingerprint? Sounds good to me. You just shouldn't make it full screen.
- boneitis 5y ago
- tempodox 5y ago> Your browser fingerprint appears to be unique among the 225,692 tested in the past 45 days. Never was the confirmation that I'm a unique snowflake less welcome.
- StavrosK 5y agoSame here, maybe it's my portrait-orientation screen.
- zamadatix 5y agoIt tells you how much each component contributes lower in the results page. Screen info should be under "Screen Size and Color Depth". For my 2560x1600x24 display 1 in ~1582 have it. The canvas fingerprint was the greatest source for me with 1 in ~2870. That being said the goal is that the vast majority of users come out unique even if everything is mostly normal individually anyways.
- Kubuxu 5y agoFor me it was Hash of canvas fingerprint Bits of identifying information: 17.84 One in x browsers have this value: 233841.0
- npteljes 5y agoThis only counts if they recognize you after you return. If they think that you're unique again, then the tracking didn't work at all. This was the case last time I used their tool, Panopticlick. Edit: I tested this current tool and it recognized me after I returned. Opened it first normally, I'm unique. Opened it in a private window, unique. Closed that and opened a new private window, and bam, one other previous browser had my fingerprint already.
- twelvechairs 5y agoAre Canvas and Webgl fingerprinting almost enough to identify almost anyone?
- Santosh83 5y agoFingerprinting seems to be a losing battle given the ever expanding browser API coupled with sites outright breaking if you disable Javascript, or blocking you as an attacker. The best strategy I can think of is compartmentalisation. Essentially use several completely separate broswers. One with Javascript, tracking and ads allowed but only used strictly for logging into GMail or banking or stuff like that. Another browser with reasonable safeguards (like say ad blocking) but nothing excessive like disabling Javascript, for authenticated sites. And finally a highly locked down browser or the Tor Browser for general "browsing" of news sites and such. This can reduce the ability for the tech giants and ad companies to track your activity outside each browser, interfering with their profile building.
- willis936 5y ago>Tor Browser I can think of no better way to guarantee you'll be put on a surveillance list of state level actors than to use Tor.
- Forbo 5y agoI can think of no better reason to normalize the use of Tor than to fight the chilling effects of mass surveillance.
- southerntofu 5y agoDepends on where you reside. In some countries (Turkey/China), Tor can get you jailed/disappeared. In pretend-democracies like here in France, that is not the case. So sure you'll be watched over to some extent. But the fact is if you don't use tor you're EVEN MORE watched over because the intelligence services have "blackboxes" (that's how they call them in law) placed on the network, and anyway your ISP is required by law to keep track of each and every move of yours for 2 years. So they know i'm using tor, so what? We're millions of people using tor, and every day there's more of us. At least they can't say i'm reading mediaslibres.org one of the only free press outlet online that's not censored by the French state. (well now they can because i just confessed, but i didn't have to)
- 5y ago
- danShumway 5y agoNote that the EFF's data set is heavily biased towards users that care about privacy (ie, the people who visit the website and test with it). My results on this site indicate that nearly 1/11 users disable Javascript. That is obviously not true. Useful tool, and I'm really glad the EFF provides it, but take it with a grain of salt. There's nothing magic going on here, and there's no guarantee that the dataset of people visiting other more popular websites will be the same.
- motohagiography 5y agoTried it with Tor to see if Tor provided much better privacy. Relatively it is better than another browser, but still 12.n bits of uniquely identifying information (1:4096). From a k-anonymity perspective, I might as well transmit a full zip code to all the parties at each site the browser interacts with. I don't have the data handy, but the idea of expressing this in terms of conceptual zip codes could be useful. e.g. a 5-digit US zip code has a wide range, but handwavy, let's say the average for all 5 digits of a given zip code is a population of maybe 5k people. 4-digits could be 50k people, 3-digits 100k etc. 12-bits of information is a one in a field of 4096, which implies to me that the Tor browser finderprint yields the unique information equivalent of sending a consistent zip code, just not your physical one. It means that your net level of anonymity requires other Tor users to also be in that "zip code" of fingerprints, which seems to have a very low probability. I am surprised Tor doesn't appear to tumble these fingerprint features.
- SavantIdiot 5y agoIf my browser uniquifies my presence every time it is queried, then yes, I will always have a unique fingerprint.