4 ms·

> In Sanskrit Asura means evil people (demon) Are you sure? I was under the impression this is a mistaken translation. Rakshasa would be the more demonic one a

> In Sanskrit Asura means evil people (demon) Are you sure? I was under the impression this is a mistaken translation. Rakshasa would be the more demonic one and not asura.

Arnavion 5y ago
Do you have a reference to it being a mistaken translation? I'm a native Hindi speaker, and I would've told you asura and rakshasa are both demons. "Asura" == "not sura" == "not good" sounds generic, sure, but everyone grows up hearing that word only used for demons in mythological stories. (This is far from the only case where a generic word ends up being used to refer to something specific that has that category. Everyone in Hindu mythological stories has a bajillion alternative names that are generic-sounding but only apply to them, based around some aspect of their personality or actions.)
- qart 5y ago
  Current Indian mythology has a lot of differences from ancient Indian mythology. The nature of asura is among them. Many of the then major gods were described in Rig Veda as asuras. Wikipedia gives a good overview: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Asura https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Asura
- naruvimama 5y ago
  Very many Indian words that have exact meaning loose their meaning when they get translated to English. A Rakshas is just someone blinded by the need to accumulate wealth and power, they may be kind but often take the wrong path.
- chupchap 5y ago
  I used to think so as well till I read more about it. Asuras are equivalent to lords and divine beings equivalent to devas and not inherently evil. Even more interesting is how Asuras are treated in Budhism and in Hinduism-like religions that are prevelant in various parts of SE Asia.
gautamdivgi 5y ago
Referring to [0] where Asuras originally started out under the stewardship of Varuna but gradually the terminology changed to be synonymous with Rakshasa. 0. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Asura https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Asura
- chupchap 5y ago
  Did you seariously share the whole wiki article as the source? :D
KorematsuFred 5y ago
There are subtle differences in Rakshasa and Asura indeed but they are nearly interchangeable.

> In Sanskrit Asura means evil people (demon) Are you sure? I was under the impression this is a mistaken translation. Rakshasa would be the more demonic one and not asura.

Arnavion 5y ago

Do you have a reference to it being a mistaken translation? I'm a native Hindi speaker, and I would've told you asura and rakshasa are both demons. "Asura" == "not sura" == "not good" sounds generic, sure, but everyone grows up hearing that word only used for demons in mythological stories. (This is far from the only case where a generic word ends up being used to refer to something specific that has that category. Everyone in Hindu mythological stories has a bajillion alternative names that are generic-sounding but only apply to them, based around some aspect of their personality or actions.)

qart 5y ago
Current Indian mythology has a lot of differences from ancient Indian mythology. The nature of asura is among them. Many of the then major gods were described in Rig Veda as asuras. Wikipedia gives a good overview: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Asura https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Asura
naruvimama 5y ago
Very many Indian words that have exact meaning loose their meaning when they get translated to English. A Rakshas is just someone blinded by the need to accumulate wealth and power, they may be kind but often take the wrong path.
chupchap 5y ago
I used to think so as well till I read more about it. Asuras are equivalent to lords and divine beings equivalent to devas and not inherently evil. Even more interesting is how Asuras are treated in Budhism and in Hinduism-like religions that are prevelant in various parts of SE Asia.

gautamdivgi 5y ago

Referring to [0] where Asuras originally started out under the stewardship of Varuna but gradually the terminology changed to be synonymous with Rakshasa. 0. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Asura https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Asura

chupchap 5y ago
Did you seariously share the whole wiki article as the source? :D

KorematsuFred 5y ago

There are subtle differences in Rakshasa and Asura indeed but they are nearly interchangeable.