3 ms·
I'm all for applying whatever tool works. If somebody is suffering, and religion/spirituality can help them without too many side effects, let's apply it. Howe
by jfengel 5y ago
I'm all for applying whatever tool works. If somebody is suffering, and religion/spirituality can help them without too many side effects, let's apply it.
However... it's not like people haven't been self-treating with religion since time immemorial. Certainly longer than psychiatry. And it's usually cheaper than a therapist. So people tend to try that first, and go for a medical route only after religion has failed them.
The article cites a study with some positive results, but psychiatry is an area rife with unreproducible studies. This seems to warrant more study, but it wouldn't surprise me if there are a lot of contradictory results.
I'd really like to see it work. It does seem reasonable that some patients find spirituality to be a tool for coping, and psychiatry can benefit from that. At the least it sounds as if it shouldn't be, "Well, religion failed you, now let's chuck it and try something different."
- ggggtez 5y agoIt's amazing the cognitive biases that are present in every example. A person who writes about how he doesn't believe in atheism, stating his "secular" client believes in god and such... In a country that is 80%+ Christian... Even if he had an atheist client, they would leave his practice as soon as he continued to insist that they pray and talk to priests as a solution to their problems... It's a self fulfilling prophecy
- groby_b 5y agoNote that "organized religion" and "spirituality" are often very different. Helping people find out that they can be spiritual without having to buy into a prescribed belief system is an extremely helpful step that many don't undertake on their own. The fact that the author ignores that entirely makes me fairly convinced that he's advocating to proselytize, not to introduce people to spirituality. (Part of me wants to book a session with them and talk to them about wood fairies, just to see what happens :)
- aarpmcgee 5y agoI didn't have a feel for what the word 'spirituality' meant until I left organized religion and began the working-it-out for myself. Its relatable and understandable when I see how often people mistake the two, since we're nearly all raised into confusion by confused people.
- pstuart 5y agoI think organized religion is more about organized religion rather than spirituality.
- squarefoot 5y agoOrganized religion is what happens when few greedy people realize they can make money out of many spiritual people.
- corobo 5y agoI think the actual results here are "have a solid support network" rather than spirituality. If you can get that in spirituality, awesome, but I don't think spirituality itself is the actual fix - it's the people you share your beliefs with that help. Community and that, it's a thing humans do (and haven't been able to do in a while)
- dTal 5y agoSpirituality is not religion. Imagine being "prescribed" 50mg of caffeine in the morning - certainly a therapeutic dose of a psychoactive chemical - but instead of taking an abstract pill, you are to incorporate the ritual of teamaking into your morning routine. You are to take the time to do it carefully and properly, and to savor the experience of drinking it, and to use the time to reflect on some aspect of life - perhaps one that your therapist suggests. Is this not a plausibly useful treatment? Might you call the experience of venerating the act of making tea in some way spiritual? Spiritual things need not invoke nonsense - they just have to touch the human spirit.
- sharadov 5y agoYou are equating religion with spirituality, most organized religion is a madhouse. Buddhism is an anomaly and IMO it's more a faith, and offers a real path to spirituality.
- ghthor 5y agoBuddhism is great and all and I used to agree with you until I found the research of Stan Tenan about the torah. He is a phycist that got interested in the patterning in the letters of torah and what he discovered is a very logical path to the sacred mystery of ego death and conscience expansion, buddhism was never able to walk me there the way the mysterious of the torah was. Meru Foundation, check out his lectures about his discoveries.
- Smithalicious 5y agoAll religions are mad except the one I like - a tale as old as time.