4 ms·
The home computer has been replaced with the iPhone. What boggles my mind is that the industry accepts Apple's restrictions on what kind of computing can happe
by echelon 5y ago
The home computer has been replaced with the iPhone.
What boggles my mind is that the industry accepts Apple's restrictions on what kind of computing can happen, how their software can be distributed, and how their gross/margins are taxed.
These devices have done a perverse thing to our field.
Consumers love them, but fuck are they awful for freedom, business, and small time success.
We used to build platforms in the open that we all benefited from (ie. the Web). Even Microsoft Windows was and is more open than these goddamn monopoly devices.
The DOJ needs to rip Apple's control of the iPhone away. It's not their device anymore. It's the industry.
Computing belongs to the people. It'd make for a healthier playing field, and Apple would still be making bank.
- threatofrain 5y agoPersonally I'm in love with the fact that Apple found a business model selling privacy and safety, while I'm also torn on the idea that Apple has been using their weight to bludgeon the competition into giving up a massive share of revenue. At the same time, the weighing of leverage is precisely how the market has and still works to this day. Thus if you send me out there to negotiate with Popeye's (which really wants you to create an account), or Walmart, Facebook, or even a small company making todo apps, I will simply not win, and neither will my family members. I love that cross-app tracking is now opt-in, because that's not something I'd ever imagine negotiating with any company, ever. I love the fact that all subscription-based services purchased through the iOS platform can be managed in a centralized place. And I will of course resent in my tiny, futile, pathetic way, those voices which say "Well, you as a free agent made these concessions in the marketplace. Didn't you get what you deserve?" Why can't there be a consumer choice to throw your weight behind a mega-giant who intercedes forcefully on your behalf, in a marketplace that is all about the weighing of leverage?
- shadowgovt 5y agoThere are dozens of hardware platforms running hundreds (if not thousands) of software stacks that a user can play with that aren't Apple's ecosystem. Everything from a Raspberry Pi to a Lenovo ThinkPad. It's a color-wheel of hardware and software out there.
- echelon 5y agoAll 300 million American consumers doing all of their business, emails, dating, instagram, phone calls, photography, etc. on Raspberry Pi? No. The solution is to regulate iPhone and make it a common carrier / open platform. It won, and now Apple has to bear the consequences. If their device was in niche usage, you might have a case.
- shadowgovt 5y agoWhat is stopping 300 million American consumers from doing their business, emails, dating, instagram, phone calls, photography, etc. on Raspberry Pi? ... and if it's "They don't want to; Apple's user experience is better for their use case," why should the government intercede to take that away from them?
- echelon 5y ago> why should the government intercede to take that away from them Because Apple is the new Standard Oil. We've decided that too much power and control in one vertically and horizontally integrated company is bad for consumers, bad for business, and bad for the health of our capitalist enterprise. Under Apple's thumb it's much harder to launch a new product and be profitable. Apple takes too much and demands unreasonable things. Apple is the face of computing today. They've installed themselves as the troll on the bridge. They need to be reminded that this is not the correct or healthy role for them to play and that there are plenty of other opportunities for them to pursue. Microsoft post-DOJ emerged a healthier company. Apple will too.
- shadowgovt 5y ago> bad for consumers In contrast to the EU, where monopoly protection guards the market itself from lack of competition, the US standard centers on harm to consumers. ... And that's the hardest part to prove regarding bringing antitrust against Apple. Millions of users and they aren't switching to another computing platform when the barriers to transition are extremely low, which suggests they're happy with Apple's products. "Satisfies customers' needs" isn't harm to consumers.
- ergot_vacation 5y agoTurns out the PC was an accident of history. Not an endpoint like some of us saw it, but simply an unfortunate stepping stone to the ultimate goal of making a really smart toaster. The end goal was never really to empower people, it was just to create a new market for rent-seeking via lock-in on a shiny new black box. No repairs allowed. No modding allowed. And you can go fuck yourself if you want the source code for anything. "Micro-computing," as it used to be called, was never intended as way for ordinary people to gain freedom and agency. It was just supposed to be another tool for the rich and powerful to extract wealth from everyone else. And now, thanks to always-online requirements, inescapable updates and aggressive planned obsolescence, that dream is finally a reality. Welcome back to the farm serf. You never really left.
- sigstoat 5y ago> Turns out the PC was an accident of history > The end goal was never really to empower people whose end goal would that have even been? you're talking like history possesses some sort of inherent narrative, instead of just being a bunch of people doing shit.
- echelon 5y agoYou could have a million downvotes, but you're eternally correct. Thank you.
- selfhoster11 5y agoI disagree. Micro-computing was not "intended" for anything, it just was and that's it.
- armadsen 5y agoApple has ~20% smartphone marketshare worldwide. It's higher in the US, but the last numbers I saw put them <50%. In what world is that a monopoly?