3 ms·
I'd prefer if HN only got followup articles about such breaches, which have some analysis. Voting the actual raw data-dumps up emphasizes the other meaning of
by gojomo 15y ago
I'd prefer if HN only got followup articles about such breaches, which have some analysis.
Voting the actual raw data-dumps up emphasizes the other meaning of 'hacker' and almost looks like cheerleading.
- wxs 15y agoI'm not sure if I agree. One thing that's nice about HN is that I so often get the story early, otherwise I would use one of the weekly/daily best-of aggregators anyway. The front-page is big enough that I can handle there being one post for the original raw-data, and a subsequent post for the Ars analysis. Your other point about "cheerleading" is well taken, It is easy to get caught up in the David vs. Goliath sentiment.
- rdl 15y agoWe had this discussion about ~12 years ago with the attrition.org defacements gallery.
- bmelton 15y agoI haven't seen this (yet) in any local media, and it's at least given me the opportunity to email all the Booz employees I know and urge them to at least change their passwords. Having the information quickly is advantageous to both sides.
- mcantelon 15y agoI'd say it's newsworthy and interesting, so I don't see a problem with it.
- leon_ 15y agoIf you can live with all that business bullshit on "hacker" news you certainly can live with some security related data dumps.
- redthrowaway 15y agoIf we're waiting for Ars Technica to do an in-depth article, we'll be as late to the table as everyone else. I like learning about these things as they happen.
- w1ntermute 15y agoAnd no doubt the Ars article will be posted on HN once it's been written.
- redthrowaway 15y agoRight. Ars has a pretty solid reputation for taking its time to do an in-depth story. I'm happy to have both the quick version now and the Ars version later, and I don't mind both hitting the frontpage if the story is big enough.
- Iv 15y agoThe thing is that it is also the main source of the "official" antisec statement. I prefer to read their direct humorous prose, it is less likely to leave important informations out.