3 ms·
A curious question (from a long-time open source contributor)... From the perspective of IBM's customers of APL2 (not from the perspective of some other group
by neilv 5y ago
A curious question (from a long-time open source contributor)...
From the perspective of IBM's customers of APL2 (not from the perspective of some other group of humanity), would it best suit their interests to have APL2 spun off to a company, or for APL2 to be released as FOSS?
I'm wondering whether, whatever the needs of those APL2 customers, perhaps the company would be more likely to satisfy those needs, compared to waiting for whatever emerges from FOSS?
(Of course, with FOSS, multiple companies could emerge, and also be motivated to compete. But they'd be competing with each other, and with free FOSS undercutting them, for possibly a small pool of customers that might not grow much. And I don't know whether it'd be viable to invest in that slice of customers, or to even be in that business at all?)
- kevincox 5y agoFOSS is almost certainly better all else being equal. But what IBM's customers probably care far more about is the availability of support.
- mumblemumble 5y agoFrom my perspective as someone who's seen this happen before: "Released as FOSS" means "We have withdrawn life support and it will now die a slow lingering death. Have fun with that." Unless you can spare the resources to maintain it yourself, this marks the point when it's officially time to migrate away immediately. "Spun off to a small company" means "Someone has now been personally incentivized to take care of it." It's certainly not guaranteed to survive long-term, but it's at least been given a chance at revitalization. It's probably worth sticking around for a while to see what happens.
- geocar 5y agoSomeone who wants APL2 but not to pay anyone for it uses GNU APL: they just aren’t that far away from each other. Maybe it’s worth closing the gap, but who pays for that? APL2 has already been paid for, so it’s hard for a company to pay for it again. On the other hand, they continue to pay for support, and if there were more APL2 users then that could surely save them money, and it seems plausible that a FOSS APL2 would make more APL2 users, but the existing APL2 users would suffer because they would be able to command less money for the support they already offer.