3 ms·
The existence of that database under the control of a surveillance company is the problem. If Google published the dataset so that many others could use it free
by mindslight 5y ago
The existence of that database under the control of a surveillance company is the problem. If Google published the dataset so that many others could use it freely, then they would have an argument that they're just promulgating public data. However, by keeping it to themselves and forcing queries to go through Google (with a bunch of fine print attached), they're agglomerating personal data for their own private purpose.
- xvector 5y agoThere are open, crowd-driven databases like Wigle with over 10 billion SSID observations. I just don't see why this is a problem when apps can't even access your SSID without a location permission.
- scottyah 5y agoIsn't that just what companies are all about? Anyone can do it if they want, (it's not like Google has a State defined monopoly), it's just that it isn't worth it to others. If you want everyone to have that data publicly then have your government do it...
- mindslight 5y agoThe point is to weigh whether the mass collection of personal data is justified. The reason why it is being done matters - if the data is easy to collect and is merely being format shifted by a curious person, then there clearly isn't much of a barrier to anyone doing the same. Meanwhile a company investing a significant amount to create a proprietary database for their own purposes has much different incentives - cf Google's sorry excuse for an opt out. Furthermore, a published dataset is transparent in that it allows individuals to see exactly what data has been collected about them, act to remove themselves, complain politically, etc, whereas most people will never become aware of the proprietary database.
- 8note 5y agoThey're adding value to the public data by organizing into that location search. I'd think it similar to a journalist reporting on a story. Its public, butthe value they add is private