3 ms·
The people that existed at the time these benefits were enacted shouldn't have accepted or allowed a cash-in-cash-out program if they wanted the government to h
by 3pt14159 15y ago
The people that existed at the time these benefits were enacted shouldn't have accepted or allowed a cash-in-cash-out program if they wanted the government to have a _legal obligation_ to pay SS, pensions, etc. The baby boomers are double dipping in almost every way. They live longer, but don't want the ceiling on the retirement age lifted. They want extravagant senior medical programs from the government, but don't want to actually save up to pay it. They want pensions that never did real actuarial accounting to figure out if they could meet their "defined benefits" obligations. They (rightly or wrongly) legalize abortion leading to 50 million (http://www.guttmacher.org/pubs/fb_induced_abortion.html http://www.guttmacher.org/pubs/fb_induced_abortion.html) fewer people in the demographic that would be supporting them in a cash-in-cash out scheme. They exported dollars when the US was the only major capitalist power. They took inheritance from their parents but (generally) failed to either pay for their children's post secondary education, save up for retirement, and/or leave an inheritance for their children. They are banking on their house capital and reverse mortgages to pay their bills. They have debt on their cars, houses, and anything else that is remotely a non-depreciating asset. Don't even get me started on the cheap oil and coal that they pulled out of the ground without investing in longer term (and ultimately cheaper) power sources like nuclear.
It's as if Joseph told the pharaoh that "7 years of plenty are coming..." and the pharaoh cut him off before he could finish and said "hey everyone, we'll be doing really well for a while, let's start a huge party!" And everyone partied so hard they had to borrow from their poorer neighbors because the party was going so strong all their neighbors just said to themselves "oh they are good for it," and after 7 years of partying really hard they said their children had a "legal obligation" to make sure they could still party during the 7 years of famine that all of them ignored.
But it is ok, right? Because "in the long run we are all dead" and it takes a Austrian Economist so long to be right, by the time it come to paying the piper everyone has forgotten and is asking themselves "why didn't anyone see this coming?"
- scarmig 15y agoThere's a lot to agree with here and a lot to disagree with. But I think of it as a separate debate. The fact remains that those obligations do exist. Even if conceded that it was stupid for us to enter into these agreements, they're still legal and still have legal force. If your company agrees to pay another company for some service or product but then refuses to do so at the end of the month, that's both illegal and immoral. Same deal here.
- Locke1689 15y agoI think this is just ranting and doesn't really add to the discussion.