2 ms·
I would love to see a coordinated push by people simply refusing to pay hospitals' post facto billing nastygrams. AFAIK, medical "debt" doesn't even end up on y
by mindslight 5y ago
I would love to see a coordinated push by people simply refusing to pay hospitals' post facto billing nastygrams. AFAIK, medical "debt" doesn't even end up on your social credit report in the US.
Without any up front prices, there is no contract that obligates payment. Instead, hospitals collect under the idea of "unjust enrichment" - you needed help, they provided it, and so you should compensate them. But that still doesn't allow them to set arbitrary prices the way they do ($6 for a $0.02 aspirin!), but only to recoup their actual costs. A few form letters that billing department victims could use to assert their legal rights would go a long way.
You wouldn't pay a second post-facto bill from your grocery store based on some justification that "the cashier you went to didn't actually work for the grocery store", and we shouldn't accept similar nonsense from medical providers.
- CPLX 5y agoI totally agree with the sentiment here but is this actually true? My understanding is that health care providers have legislative power and influence and have used it to actually ensure that a legal obligation to pay is created in situations like these. Is that not correct? Would they actually sue under an unjust enrichment cause of action, or is there statutory authority most of the time?
- mindslight 5y agoI would believe that could be the case, at least in some states. But on that front, all of these articles about terrible hospital bills are doing a grace disservice by failing to mention those laws, so that public support can build against them. If anyone were given the power to create legally valid debts out of thin air, they would of course abuse it. Preventing that is one of the main purposes of contract law.
- hansvm 5y ago> If anyone were given the power to create legally valid debts out of thin air, they would of course abuse it. Which, incidentally, does exist in places. E.g., when CO mints a new transportation authority they give a private corporation oversight-free permission to set their own rates and penalties, enforceable by law. That's resulted in a long string of complaints about toll roads charging not just the toll, but for the first bill they never sent, an extra 1000% interest here and there, a fine because they had to "send a second bill," ....
- noelsusman 5y agoA lot of people already do this, which is one of many reasons why hospitals charge $6 for an aspirin.
- mindslight 5y agoThere are other approaches to profitability besides committing billing fraud.