2 ms·
The first paragraph gives it all away: "The clock is slowly ticking toward Aug. 2, the date on which the U.S. faces "fiscal Armageddon" — according to the Obam
by scarmig 15y ago
The first paragraph gives it all away:
"The clock is slowly ticking toward Aug. 2, the date on which the U.S. faces "fiscal Armageddon" — according to the Obama administration — unless Congress agrees to raise the debt ceiling. But would we?"
Yes, it's an Armageddon according to the Obama administration. But also Speaker Bohner. And Senator McConnell. And Moody's. And the CBO. Etc.
It's also terribly inaccurate, even from a Cato perspective. A 44% cut in federal spending really isn't accurately described as something that will "almost certainly hurt." Pretending to believe that that's doable in any sensible way doesn't lend much credence to the writer.
Even if it were possible to do things as he suggests, it wouldn't solve the central problem. The United States has _legal obligations_ to pay Social Security benefits, make sure our retired soldiers receive their pensions, and other civil servants get the healthcare benefits they're entitled to as part of their agreed upon compensation package. These aren't things you can go "oopsies, I don't feel like paying it, maybe next month." And even if you were to do this with extremely questionable legality, it wouldn't help the central issue, which is faith in the credit of the United States. If I pay off my credit card bill but have to renege on my mortgage and car payments to do so, my credit is still going to be shot.
Lastly: this is about two weeks late in Republican messaging. It's now Obama who's pushing for larger long-term deficit reduction and spending cuts than Republicans (on the order of 4 trillion instead of 2 trillion over the next decade). This is, it should be said, not merely twice as big as the Republican package but also twice as stupid and boneheaded. Regardless, that's how things stand--Republicans are likely to refuse Obama's 4 trillion in favor of their 2 trillion, which is only half as stupid so on net good for the country. Good for them, but unfortunately it undermines the Cato dude's argument about it being about the deficit.
- freerobby 15y agoI don't understand your last paragraph. Of course we should make good on what we can but if Medicare and/or Social Security (mostly the former) need reform to remain solvent, then why is it stupid to make the cuts that keep them solvent? A working less-than-ideal program is better than a not-working ideal program, no?
- scarmig 15y agoThey need reform on the scale of decades, though, not years and definitely not months. Large super-majorities of the public oppose cuts to SS and Medicare. This, by the way, includes self-identified conservatives and Republicans. In large part this is the public being ignorant and wanting something for nothing--if the public had their way, we'd balance the budget and double Medicare and SS benefits by cutting foreign aid payments. That said, for something as important and widely supported as these two programs, we should be discussing solutions to their long-term funding issues as a standalone debate. Cutting them after a month of backroom negotiations while using the credit worthiness of the USA as a hostage strikes me as very inappropriate and not politically sustainable. Edited to add: the reason these cuts are stupid is because many of them would come into effect immediately, which would be disastrous for our already weak economy. The size of the cuts are appropriate if projected into the future and not the immediate present.
- freerobby 15y agoI'm not persuaded by public polling on these issues for the very reason that you point out: the hypocrisy in their demands. The public super majorities that you speak of are also much too casual observers of the political process to understand what any of this means in isolation. Hell, over 60% of the public doesn't even _want_ the US to raise the debt ceiling (I forget the exact number cited in the press conference, but it was in the 60s). This is despite the fact that the leadership of both parties has acknowledged it needs to happen to avoid disaster. I'm also not sure the cuts are as immediate as you say. I can't find any details on what is being negotiated (both leaderships and Obama have refused to give specifics), but on the revenues side for example, Obama said today that even the tax increases that are being talked about wouldn't come into effect until 2013. If they are talking about raising the retirement age or restructuring Medicare, I wouldn't rule out that it would take place over time or have a grandfathering period. I agree that the debt ceiling and deficit reduction discussions should be separate, but the ship sailed on that a while ago, so all of the above is written from the perspective of dealing with this stuff in the present context.
- 3pt14159 15y agoThe people that existed at the time these benefits were enacted shouldn't have accepted or allowed a cash-in-cash-out program if they wanted the government to have a _legal obligation_ to pay SS, pensions, etc. The baby boomers are double dipping in almost every way. They live longer, but don't want the ceiling on the retirement age lifted. They want extravagant senior medical programs from the government, but don't want to actually save up to pay it. They want pensions that never did real actuarial accounting to figure out if they could meet their "defined benefits" obligations. They (rightly or wrongly) legalize abortion leading to 50 million (http://www.guttmacher.org/pubs/fb_induced_abortion.html http://www.guttmacher.org/pubs/fb_induced_abortion.html) fewer people in the demographic that would be supporting them in a cash-in-cash out scheme. They exported dollars when the US was the only major capitalist power. They took inheritance from their parents but (generally) failed to either pay for their children's post secondary education, save up for retirement, and/or leave an inheritance for their children. They are banking on their house capital and reverse mortgages to pay their bills. They have debt on their cars, houses, and anything else that is remotely a non-depreciating asset. Don't even get me started on the cheap oil and coal that they pulled out of the ground without investing in longer term (and ultimately cheaper) power sources like nuclear. It's as if Joseph told the pharaoh that "7 years of plenty are coming..." and the pharaoh cut him off before he could finish and said "hey everyone, we'll be doing really well for a while, let's start a huge party!" And everyone partied so hard they had to borrow from their poorer neighbors because the party was going so strong all their neighbors just said to themselves "oh they are good for it," and after 7 years of partying really hard they said their children had a "legal obligation" to make sure they could still party during the 7 years of famine that all of them ignored. But it is ok, right? Because "in the long run we are all dead" and it takes a Austrian Economist so long to be right, by the time it come to paying the piper everyone has forgotten and is asking themselves "why didn't anyone see this coming?"
- scarmig 15y agoThere's a lot to agree with here and a lot to disagree with. But I think of it as a separate debate. The fact remains that those obligations do exist. Even if conceded that it was stupid for us to enter into these agreements, they're still legal and still have legal force. If your company agrees to pay another company for some service or product but then refuses to do so at the end of the month, that's both illegal and immoral. Same deal here.