3 ms·
> I always ask what particulars are you missing or not there? I should have been clear it was M1 Mac against similar segment competitors. Not the Pro / Gaming
by ksec 5y ago
> I always ask what particulars are you missing or not there?
I should have been clear it was M1 Mac against similar segment competitors. Not the Pro / Gaming segment.
Most of those are comparing hardware spec on paper. As much as I like to shit on Apple's pathetic 1mm key travel keyboard, USB-C charging that fried the CPU, Touch Bar or ridiculously sized trackpad. Build quality of MacBook is still better than Dell XPS. Both external and internally down to component layout. From Trackpad to Speakers. I actually think the closest competitor is the Microsoft Surface Laptop 4.
Touch ID, M1 that has NPU for many ML task. Speech Recognition that is far better than on Windows. ( Both Apple and Google gets the benefits of their Smartphone scale ). Much better thermal with 5nm SoC. On a 25W max CPU+GPU system there are simply no competition. WiFi and Bluetooth that gets the benefits of being tested by the 1 billion+ of iPhone and iPad Devices. Generally faster SSD because not all NVMe SSD are made equal. Then there is the macOS and its ecosystem where its UI and UX are better designed. ( Control Panel vs System Preferences ? ) While macOS is now in its 3rd if not 4th facelift. Windows still have screens that are coming from its 2000 era. And there are possibly hundreds if not thousands of little things. ( Font Rendering, App latency, etc )
Most of the suggestions are 32 / 64GB Windows system which the M1 Mac currently does not offer (yet). And Gaming. If you Game you will need a Windows PC.
None of these includes the benefits if you already own an iPad or iPhone. Unless Windows 11 offer some massive leap forward. I dont see any thing on the roadmap in PC industry that could compete with the onslaught of ARM Mac. For the first time ever in Apple history the Mac has an BOM cost advantage compare to PC. ( Apple has higher margin so RSP would be about the same as PC )
- nobleach 5y agoI have an XPS15 and an M1 MacBook Pro sitting side by side all day. I'll concede the MBP is far superior in build quality. The speakers, the trackpad, the body... they're nearly flawless. XPS is running ArchLinux, the Mac is running macOS. The experience between the two is night and day. Having to alias all the stuff that runs in emulation mode, having to deal with The Apple Way. Having file sharing that is spotty at best.... I really hate it. But dang the machine sure is beautiful.
- ksec 5y agoYes It is like all these tiny small things add up. And when people ask what are the difference or they are about the same I clinch. It is exactly the same as saying Fonts typefaced dont matter and they are all the same in 1980s. Sometimes all I ask is the other manufacture just to copy Apple MacBook to the atomic level. There should be a lot of learning in doing so for them. The only notebook I see that is taking a lot of MBP design learning is actually Microsoft Surface Laptop. Still let down by its software though. And my god the leaked Windows 11 is still awful.