I'm sure NYT and Bitdefender both have "the contract auto-renews unless explicitly cancelled" in their terms. The only place NYT allows you to cancel online is

I'm sure NYT and Bitdefender both have "the contract auto-renews unless explicitly cancelled" in their terms. The only place NYT allows you to cancel online is California, because of relatively recent regulation. Elsewhere you need to contact their retention department. I'm really not seeing the difference between their actions.