3 ms·
Hi. Article author here. May I suggest that you read to the end of something before you comment? To address your point about the Linux version: I do not thin
by lproven 5y ago
Hi. Article author here.
May I suggest that you read to the end of something before you comment?
To address your point about the Linux version:
I do not think that you are correct. Corel Corp, which is still alive and well, explicitly made a free version of the app and released it, along with a press release (which I link to). This has not been revoked or cancelled subsequently; the Linux version of the product was discontinued.
If someone makes a piece of software available for free, even if it's just a binary, then it remains free unless or until the company revokes that status. Corel has not revoked its status. Ergo, it remains freeware.
- wila 5y agoEasy to miss this bit: " Corel offered both a free edition with fewer bundled fonts, as well as a paid version." as it is at the end of a paragraph. Maybe put this either on a new line to draw more attention to it or add a title just underneath it? Like: "That's right, Corel released a FREE edition"
- lproven 5y agoOK, fair point. Thanks for the suggestion. I've added that at the start, and clarified why Corel got out of Linux, and added a PS about where you can get a good free legal DOS wordprocessor.
- Jiro 5y agoThe "free edition" was free to download directly from Corel. You can no longer download it from Corel for free, and downloading it from someone else is not permitted by copyright law.
- Jiro 5y ago>If someone makes a piece of software available for free, even if it's just a binary, then it remains free unless or until the company revokes that status. This is not in accordance with copyright law. Corel granted permission to get copies from Corel. If you already have a copy from Corel, it remains free. But this isn't GPL; you don't have permission to make further copies of one of the free copies. If you get a copy from one of the third parties that still has it available for download, you're violating copyright, even if the third party themselves got their own copy for free.
- lproven 5y agoIt is not as simple as that. Other companies distributed the free version, too. It was bundled with at least one print book. It was included with old versions of both SUSE Linux and Mandrake Linux. It was sold, on CD, by various long-gone vendors. It was available from multiple other sources than Corel, and has been since the early days. I entirely see where you're coming from, and I've added a paragraph clarifying its status to my blog post. However, given its wide distribution over more than 20 years, which Corel has never seeked to stop, I think it is fair. This is not "abandonware". Corel made this one version free of charge and has never rescinded that.