8 ms·
Webvan, 20 years ago, had the right idea - don't pick from retail stores, use a proper fulfillment center. But they had 3% market share in 30 cities, instead of
by Animats 5y ago
Webvan, 20 years ago, had the right idea - don't pick from retail stores, use a proper fulfillment center. But they had 3% market share in 30 cities, instead of 30% market share in 3 cities, because their VCs thought the "first mover advantage" was crucial. So they had too much infrastructure for their volume.
At Amazon scale, though, that approach works.
- choxi 5y agoA lot of the famous dot com busts were basically just ahead of their time: https://money.cnn.com/galleries/2010/technology/1003/gallery.dot_com_busts/ https://money.cnn.com/galleries/2010/technology/1003/gallery... To me these all sound like predecessors to Facebook, Amazon, and Uber
- code_duck 5y agoThey may have had similar ideas to those very successful companies, but besides the timing, lacked the talent at execution.
- sharkweek 5y agoI remember in high school learning how to build little websites and thinking, “it sure would be cool if we could build a little online yearbook for our school! Everyone could have their own little profile page!”
- epmaybe 5y agoDoesn’t even feel like some of these were necessarily ahead of their time, almost like investors didn’t take as many risks as they do now with burn rate etc. of course, the dot com bubble burst in a bad way, so perhaps this theory isn’t very sound
- tsjq 5y agoYes. Also : internet wasn't this good. Wasn't this widespread. Did not have the minimum usage levels for such endeavours to pickup.
- zupreme 5y agoI would say that a primary difference is the investment runway the successful players have enjoyed. Some of them are still not objectively profitable to this day, but their massive topline revenues, scales of operations, and levels of name recognition makes many of them remain attractive investment targets nevertheless.
- MattGaiser 5y agoIndeed. The willingness of VCs to fund a big vision is a game changer from companies having to incrementally bootstrap themselves.
- askafriend 5y ago> I would say that a primary difference is the investment runway the successful players have enjoyed. No. The market size expanded exponentially for each of these opportunities - changing the economics of the business models and making them viable at scale. The internet was nothing in the 90s. A place for mostly nerds in first world countries. Today we've connect 4 billion+ humans around the world.
- alluro2 5y agoFor better or for worse. When you say "connect", that means get them in front of a couple of hundred platforms (globally, comes down to couple dozen in the west) to transact on and generate revenue for those market players. It's like we took the 32bit color animated GIF internet and made it a 128 color static PNG of mostly similar shades of 10 colors.
- askafriend 5y agoI don't think the implications of connecting 4B+ people should be downplayed. It is an absolutely massive accomplishment that has many many far reaching positive effects that far outweigh the negatives. Don't let cynicism be your only guide.
- an_opabinia 5y ago> No. The market size expanded exponentially for each of these opportunities - changing the economics of the business models and making them viable at scale. Maybe. Labor in China and the Chinese market absorbing inflation also helped. My expectation is grocery delivery just barely missed the boat, because of import malfeasance crackdowns since April that is affecting everything.
- RosanaAnaDana 5y agoAskJeeves I still want an internet butler.
- ping_pong 5y agoActually it reinforces that the idea actually is the easiest part of the equation. Execution is the key and the winners are the ones who executed the best. You can't compare Webvan to Amazon.
- Animats 5y agoYou can't compare Webvan to Amazon. Amazon ended up owning and operating Webvan.com.[1] The people who developed Webvan went on to develop Amazon Fresh.[2] The founder of Kiva Robotics, which was acquired by Amazon, was from Webvan. Amazon's grocery business is directly descended from Webvan. [1] https://web.archive.org/web/20160303194049/http://www.webvan.com/ https://web.archive.org/web/20160303194049/http://www.webvan... [2] https://www.reuters.com/article/net-us-amazon-webvan-idUSBRE95H1CC20130618 https://www.reuters.com/article/net-us-amazon-webvan-idUSBRE...
- ping_pong 5y agoYes, it was a descendent. Instacart is a descendent of Webvan too. The idea is the same but Amazon already had preexisting technology and market dominance. You can't compare Webvan to Amazon.
- choxi 5y agoThat might be a factor, but given that they all failed at about the same time I think there's a good chance that timing is just as important. Adding billions of people to the internet and mass adoption of smartphones may have been necessary precursors to the success of Amazon/Facebook/Google/Uber.
- musicale 5y agoI greatly prefer Geocities to Facebook. ;-) Webvan and Kozmo.com were also brilliant.
- steveBK123 5y agoIn NYC area we have Freshdirect now, which follows that sensible model.
- mjmahone17 5y agoI switched to FreshDirect during the pandemic, and I am probably never going to depend on a large grocery store again. FreshDirect is my weekly delivery, and the nearby bodegas have what’s needed when I need a couple things. Every large NY grocery store consistently seems to have either poor-quality or extremely expensive produce, which was drastically exacerbated last April: if you don’t go soon after they stock, people pick over, scratch and generally take all the edible-looking choices. Whole Foods was terrible for delivery: the pickers seemed to just choose what was available, which inevitably tends to be what in store shoppers left over. I’d much rather on average get an average apple or onion, without having to spend time figuring out whether it’s “good”: average is almost always good enough. My total time spent grocery shopping went down, while the quality of the food went up. Their website does a really good job of focusing me on what’s fresh, in season, and otherwise likely to be good this week, and it seems like there’s a lot less waste in this model. I can also order more than I can walk home myself, which is pretty valuable when you don’t own a car.
- lotsofpulp 5y agoThe situation is completely reversed outside of a NYC like dense area where everyone has cars. Once you have a car, it makes economic sense to use it and you will likely drive near a grocery store at some point in the week. The grocery stores are also not constrained on space so the quality is much higher and rent or land costs less so prices are lower too. Although, I do have to say grocery stores in London and Toronto were much nicer than NYC in my experience, so it may be a cultural/customer demand thing too.
- oddthink 5y ago+1, I've been very impressed by FreshDirect. I have a Morton Williams across the street (crowded, bad produce, iffy selection) and a Whole Foods around the block (pretty nice, but long lines and I didn't really want to go in before vaccination), but FreshDirect has just worked. Their site and app are glacially slow, though. Not sure what's going on there. And for a while they've had some text-entry glitch that reverses text every now and then. But that's just griping. Also, with kids it's nice having the weekly 3-4 gallons of milk just show up rather than schlepping them home from the bowels of Whole Foods.
- prestigious 5y agoYa I find it wild that Walmart employees for example run around an actual Walmart for fulfillment. Can’t be worth it.
- latchkey 5y agoI recently needed to buy a propane heater. Ordered it online for pickup at Walmart because there was only one left in stock. Showed up at the Walmart thinking I could just pick it up right away. Turned into a huge big thing. The staff only goes around 1-2 times a day to fulfill these sorts of orders so I would have ended up waiting. I ended up buying the last one on the shelf, which was mine anyway, and cancelling the online order. I wonder what would have happened if someone else bought it first. I see this more as iterating on an idea to provide this service, and what I experienced, is the MVP.
- keanebean86 5y agoWalMarts inventory system preemptively orders based on sell through rate, on-hand, and historical trends. Backroom stock is logged so a pick order can be fired when shelf count gets too low. Source: worked in a few Walmart back rooms picking and binning among other things. The was about 8 years ago so things are likely a little bit different. Hopefully better since shelf max counts were always way off or we'd get flooded with freight and lose stuff in the bins.
- lotsofpulp 5y agoI order for pickup all the time nowadays, at various retailers (Walmart, Target, Home Depot, Walgreens, Staples), and I have only had 1 time I can recall that one of the retailers reported they did not have the item I ordered. I must have picked up at least a 100x by now, and I feel like as long as I wait for the email that says it is ready for pickup, I am good to go. I actually order online for pickup to ensure no one else buys it if there is only a few of the item in stock.
- code_duck 5y agoAt the least, it’s a waste of time putting the items on a physical sales display when the customers are shopping online.
- Eridrus 5y agoWhy is a real fulfilment centre better? I can see an Amazon centre with robots etc being more efficient, but other warehouses seem no more efficient than going through shelves at a walmart.
- ping_pong 5y agoBecause you're paying on top of Walmart's margins. And you're limited to whatever Walmart wants to carry and wants to charge you.
- r0b05 5y agoDon't you then have to pay the delivery fees to bring it from the fulfilment centre which is generally further away than a store?
- mandelbrotwurst 5y agoI would think there might be lots of reasons, but one that comes to mind is that supermarkets are physically designed to get the customer to spend as much time and money as possible in the store as opposed to finding the items on their list(s) as efficiently as possible like a grocery delivery service would want its workers to be able to do.
- hef19898 5y agoAmazon just recently started to use robots. Most existing operations still use physical labour. FCs are more efficient, as single entities, because they are designed as such. They have proper infrastructure, tools, people, processes. For grocery fulfillment, I don't think they are better at scale. Because they are for from the customers, they are not everywhere. Existing stores, so, are there. They use established replenishment from existing warehouses. Which means you have to use existing staff and store processes (and software) to fulfill orders. Which is hard. So it's either expensive or hard to do (which could expensive in itself). Over simplified.
- sascha_sl 5y agoMostly because markets deliver a less consistent experience (delays, cancellations due to vacations), and you face situations where your employees and customers are fighting over the last bag of chips. It also becomes harder to plan logistics because most stores (at least where I live) have limited real estate. The semi-automated ones have different issues. Only Amazon really has the tech fully figured out to a degree where issues are resolved almost instantly. Amazon can also use less but larger scale fulfillment centers because they deliver mostly small objects at an arbitrary time, whereas you can't leave 6 bags of groceries at a front door.
- s0rce 5y agoGood Eggs seems to be doing this, I've looked at ordering a few times and it just seems astronomically expensive, even by Bay Area standards.
- Closi 5y agoThis approach is much more expensive in the U.K. at least - I’ve done these sums for retailers (I’m a logistics consultant who specialises in e-commerce and grocery) and it’s hard to make a distribution centre cost competitive if you have an established store estate that you don’t want to get rid of. In short, a distribution centre gives you: * improved pick efficiency (depending on the level of automation), offset somewhat by maintenance costs and the cost of capital. * increased delivery/transport costs (stores are generally closer to the customer than the cross dock point / outbase, vehicles are already going to the store for the main delivery) \ flowing more product through existing retail points reduces waste (expiring products). * increased property cost (you have to pay for a distribution centre at c£9 per square foot incl rates etc, while in retail the space is more expensive but you are already* renting it). The one thing a fulfilment centre does give you is better service though. You can hold more range, better track dates/batches so you can give your customers the expiry dates on the website and increase availability. So the honest answer is that delivery from a central point isn’t a slam dunk, and can definitely work but probably won’t be cheaper.
- hef19898 5y agoWhile I never ran the numbers, that was my conclusion as well. Cost wise, use your existing retail infrastructure. It is easier so, to set up a separate fulfillment flow for home deliveries. It's a trade of, like always.
- Animats 5y agoWhich indicates fulfillment is best done by a company whose primary business is fulfillment, not brick and mortar retail. This is a classic disruption scenario.
- ghaff 5y agoI don't read that at all. I read it as there are pros and cons and, in practice, the relatively limited grocery delivery/pickup that happens seems to be from B&M stores. I expect that any delivery/pickup businesses that didn't thrive in the past 18 months aren't going to.
- 5y ago
- pbreit 5y agoThe model that I think is going to work would be the equivalent of traderjoes.com TJs apparently does not want to do it. It makes no sense to package items to be placed on shelves and then have people go pick the items off consumer shelves and deliver. There is so much vertical optimization that could be done.