3 ms·
Narrower tires, necessarily inflated to a high pressure, are actually inefficient on a bumpy surface. A tire's job is to absorb surface defects in the road, an
by kazinator 5y ago
Narrower tires, necessarily inflated to a high pressure, are actually inefficient on a bumpy surface.
A tire's job is to absorb surface defects in the road, and that is not only for comfort, but rolling efficiency.
The extreme example of this occurs off-road. Off-road vehicles benefit from wider tires that are inflated to a lower pressure. If you have an off-road vehicle, it behooves you to take some of the air out of the tires when you go off-road.
25mm road bike tires basically require a polished velodrome; real roads consist of pitted, eroded and cracked asphalt.
If your bike is vibrating from the crappy road, you're probably not going as fast as you could be. Letting some of the air out for a more efficient, smoother ride is risky, if the tires a narrow; you risk snakebite flats and damage to the rim.
For commuting in run-down city with aging infrastructure, you want at at least 38 mm tires. 40 mm is a nice round number. You can vary the pressure for the kinds of roads you're riding on with a lot of margin, and can take it quite low for dirt roads.
I've commuted around town with pressures as low as 45 psi in the back, 35 in the front, in 45 mm tires.
I have story in relation to that. One time I was riding along NW Marine Drive in Vancouver, from UBC down to Spanish Banks. I came down from the hill and then along the flats there were some Spandex-clad road cyclists ahead of me. I pulled up to them and we were neck and neck. There was road work going on up ahead and the pavement had been scraped, leaving it horribly bumpy. I stood on the pedals and just cranked right through it, hardly slowing down. I saw in the mirror mounted on my eyeglasses that road bike guys dropped off as if a sniper had taken them out.
What is the use of narrow tires? It's just fashion, like stiletto heels.
- fsckboy 5y agoYou're commenting on a article that says "we started to question many of the things we had accepted as ‘facts’... we’ll look at some of these myths. We’ll explain why we (and everybody else) used to believe them, and how things really work" But you aren't qualifying what you're saying: Are you telling us what everybody used to believe? Are you saying you see through what everybody says even without empirical testing? Are you agreeing or disagreeing with the test results presented in the article?
- kazinator 5y ago> Are you telling us what everybody used to believe? No; pretty much everything in my comment is undisputed old hat, so it is kind of tangential. The main myth is not that any of that is false, but rather than thin tires more than compensate for these effects due to their reduced air drag and weight and so always end up being advantageous anyway. (And they almost certainly are on a polished indoor velodrome track, where the effect of surface imperfections is next to nonexistent.)
- baliex 5y agoHave you read the article? It provides the analysis and evidence for what you’re saying in a (mostly) rigorous way
- LAC-Tech 5y ago> 25mm road bike tires basically require a polished velodrome; real roads consist of pitted, eroded and cracked asphalt. Most roads in NZ are not even tarmac, they're chipseal. And people were still buying 23mm tires to ride them back in the day. I felt like a trailblazer back in 2005 or so for getting 25mm :) I was hoping it wouldn't slow me down...
- sliken 5y agoHeh, well thin tires are lighter, accelerate better, and have less rolling friction. Alas, that's only true on perfect roads. Even normal road texture on asphalt and cement is enough to lose a fair amount of energy causing vibrations (which is after all a cyclic acceleration) in the bike and rider. I've ridden 125 psi racing tires on a racing bike and noticed that I was noticeably faster (on the speedo) when riding a painted line than on the asphalt. When riding a gentle slope along a river it was quite apparent as I switched back and forth. It was also much quieter. I also trained with my racing team occasionally with my mtb with slicks and clipless pedals, no such difference at 60psi and 1.8" tires. So it turns out that wider tires allow lower pressures, which are better at absorbing vibrations and allowing most of the energy to return. A compressed tire causes some heat, which some of which is released into the environment, but some also goes back into forward motion as the tire expands again. So the ideal inflation changes with the roughness of the surface. A relatively recent development is improvements in material science that allows for wider rims with a smaller weight penalty and lighter tires. Lower pressures also help lower the weight of the tires/rims (less force) and wider tires generally give more protection to the rims, allowing the rims to be lighter. Tubeless also has been a big help, less weight, less internal friction, and more compatible with the wider tires which have higher volumes and lower pressures. So 10 years ago 50% wider tires/rims had a significant weight penalty, not so much today. So in every biking segment from weight sensitive racing bikes to various flavors of mountain bikes are going wider. A decade ago 1.95-2.1" mtb tires were the most common. Today it's 2.35-2.6", which is a bit deceiving. Tire width for the same performance decreases with diameter. 10 years ago 26" was the most common, today the large majority of decent mountain bikes (say over $1000 for a hard tail or $1500 for a dual suspension) are 27.5" or 29". So the air in a 27.5" x 2.6" tire is significantly more than the old 26" x 1.95". Also, humans frankly stink as an engine, and are VERY susceptible to vibration, rpm, temperature, comfort, etc. So unlike a car where comfort isn't directly related to performance, on a bike a happier rider = riding faster and longer. So being 10% more comfortable can lead to real performance gains, and high pressure tires can be very uncomfortable, even to the point of numbness. So now even road bikes that claim to be the world's most efficient bikes, fastest for a given rider input, are having ever wider tires. People are realizing even at the highest levels of racing a few more mm and a few less PSI can lead to faster race times.