3 ms·
We'll probably still need natural gas for heating for a few more decades. But it's pretty clear that everything that moves on wheels is going electric.
by Animats 5y ago
We'll probably still need natural gas for heating for a few more decades. But it's pretty clear that everything that moves on wheels is going electric.
- Robotbeat 5y agoNah. It’s pretty easy to electrify heating, too. A ground source heat pump or even a good (not mediocre) air source heat pump can reduce the energy cost of heating with electricity to the same as gas.
- boulos 5y agoYeah, depending on your climate, a heat pump can have a Coefficient of Performance [1] of like 3.5. If you don’t take this into account and just take “natural gas in therms => kWh” it often seems like a heat pump would be a large increase. Divide by 3 and it’s suddenly much better :). [1] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Coefficient_of_performance https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Coefficient_of_performance
- sbradford26 5y agoAlso ground source heat pumps can have COPs in the 4-4.5 range and also keep that performance through a wide temperature range unlike air source heat pumps. Sadly air source heat pumps COP really start to drop around 0F even with the new hyper heat models. Given that I would still probably prefer an air source heat pump over using heating oil or propane.
- pitaj 5y agoYeah the reason they stay in the higher range is because they're pumping from a source of higher temperature in the first place. They're also more effective at air conditioning because they're pumping into a cooler medium.
- SketchySeaBeast 5y agoAs someone who lives in a climate that pretty reliably sees -40C and a week of the mid -30's ever year I think that the only option is a ground source heat pump - I can't see an air heat pump putting out 80,000 BTUs when it is at its least efficient. I wonder how that works for a city - is the idea that everyone drills their own 15 foot hole? Our frost can reach down to ~8 feet.
- sbradford26 5y agoThe solutions I have seen for cities would be community/public ground loops. Piping would run similar to potable water but would return to a centralized location where they would have large wells. This would be impractical for suburban/rural environments but denser cities it would most likely work.
- Ekaros 5y agoPretty standard in Nordic countries. The source of heat is real question, but there are some options like burning garbage, or waste heat from factories, data centres and so on.
- sbradford26 5y agoThe source could also simply be the ground. With a heat pump the water doesn't have to be hot to provide heat to a building. The difference with the system Nordic countries have is that they provide hot water to residences which is directly used for heating.
- acdha 5y agoThis very much depends on where you live. We just did an all-electric conversion in the DC area and the cost works out to be ~$50/month more in the coldest winter months for our single-family home (also paying $0.01/KWh more for wind/solar than coal power). That's obviously not free but it's completely manageable in terms of home expenses, and the variable heat pump's efficiency saves on cooling as well as being notably better for humidity and temperature swings because it'll run more frequently at the lower levels rather than the cool-to-full-blast cycle of our old gas heater. Obviously, this approach is less viable the further north you go as you spend more time in the lower end of the efficiency curves but there are a _lot_ of people living in areas where it's basically trivial to do now. If I set policy, I'd have subsidies for the upfront costs (maybe a base credit with 0% loans?) and especially consider things to push geothermal installs which are expensive up front but might be worth it long-term. We didn't want to deal with the extra hassle but I have been wondering whether we should have done that since it'd save in the summer, too.