4 ms·
I don't recommend using the Economist as your only source for international news. It's very deeply ideological in a way that is almost invisible if you can't ea
by sudosysgen 5y ago
I don't recommend using the Economist as your only source for international news. It's very deeply ideological in a way that is almost invisible if you can't easily compare it to a known truth.
It's certainly not only interested in solutions that can be implemented. It's interested in solutions that enforce the free market, and it paints non-market solutions as infeasible, even though they often work and are implementable. But this is invisible ideology and very easy to mistake for pragmatism, because a pure pragmatist will certainly appreciate many market solutions.
The final synthesis is not after having treated both sides. It's after having treated two sides, which are editorially chosen.
As far as dialectics it would be much more interesting if they could dialectically analyze their own internal contradictions between democracy and interventionist realpolitik, or between free-market fundamentalism and concern about externalities. But it doesn't really grapple with those, which is a sign that it's only applying dialectical thinking in convenient ways.
In any case, the Economist is not any worse than any other mainstream publication. Often they do pretty good reporting. But you absolutely must not rely on it solely especially for foreign reporting where you don't have bearings.
- pydry 5y agoAn example of such thinking from last week: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27392455 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27392455 It used to be a much better magazine.
- JAlexoid 5y agoThe Economist is one of the least biased sources of news, that routinely publishes letters, opeds and articles contradicting the sated editorial agenda. Very few other news sources actually do that. They're not perfect, but it sure beats NYT. If you want the optimal news coverage without needing to read a million sources - The Economist, Financial Times, WSJ and The Guardian.
- sudosysgen 5y agoAs I said, they show both sides, but they choose which two. They are not as forthcoming with their biases as it seems. They mainly set up their ideological oppositions as conservatives, but they in fact have a lot in common with them. This is especially true for foreign relations. I'd be happy to see examples of articles that go against the Economists' editorial agenda in profound ways and that pertain to foreign policy. If you want news coverage that is any good at all and you care about foreign affairs you absolutely have to include at least one and preferably two non-anglophone or non-western sources that preferably oppose each other. A good barometer I have for journals as far as foreign policy is their coverage of the Iraq War before it began. As far as I can see the Economist published almost nothing opposing it, limiting themselves to surface-level reporting of anti-war arguments in the sole goal of defeating them. I don't understand why you would limit yourself, if you had to choose 4 sources, to 4 centrist anglophone sources. It seems like a very biased media diet.
- crazygringo 5y agoIf you only read the English language then you're kind of mostly limited to "anglophone", no? And how can 4 "centrist" sources be "very biased"? Isn't it literally the opposite?
- dragonwriter 5y ago> And how can 4 "centrist" sources be "very biased"? Isn't it literally the opposite? No, centrism isn’t the opposite of bias. Centrism is a position toward which there can bias of any strength. Position of bias on a left/right (or any other ideological) axis and strength of bias or two orthogonal, continuous dimensions.
- crazygringo 5y agoIn theory, perhaps. But in practice "centrist" news sources are far more likely to present multiple points of view -- e.g. a left and right one -- while "left" and "right" news sources generally do not. But at a deeper level, centrism isn't really an ideology at all, in the way the left and right can be. You can be a hard-core leftist or you can be a hard-core conservative, but the idea of a "hard-core centrist" doesn't really exist. So I'd argue centrism can be the opposite of bias in a very real way. It's about dropping bias towards ideologies, and treating issues in a practical balanced way.
- dragonwriter 5y ago> But in practice "centrist" news sources are far more likely to present multiple points of view No, in practice less strongly biased sources are more likely to present multiple points of view. Now, the same amount of variation can seem more diverse when you tend to bucket things into “left/right” binary categories, if the center of variation is near the point where you draw the line between buckets. But that's an artifact of forcing things into binary buckets making a centrist outlet providing center-left to center-right views look more diverse than a right-wing publication providing center-right to far-right views.
- 5y ago
- whimsicalism 5y agoI read both the NYT and the Economist, they are quite different publications so not really comparable in my view. That said, the editorial stance of the Economist comes through extremely clearly in their writings and they are unabashedly economically liberal. Your characterization of NYT as being less ideologically diverse really doesn't match my experience. Your list is incredibly West focused and honestly not that ideologically diverse, with the Guardian I guess supposed to take the "left" position.
- JAlexoid 5y ago> NYT as being less ideologically diverse NYT has lost my subscription, after they just straight up started running exaggerated stories. > Your list is incredibly West focused I read in 4 languages, would you like some news sources in Russian, Lithuanian or Italian?
- tomkat0789 5y ago+1. I sometimes regret subscribing to Financial Times, but their bias is pretty easy to identify and accept/reject once you understand it. I counterbalance it with Jacobian (far-left/communist - choose your adjective - news). There's an adage in math modeling/statistics: all models are wrong, but some are useful. Here, all newspapers are biased, but some are useful.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- whimsicalism 5y agoJacobin, not Jacobian :) Unless there is some link between calculus and socialism that I have yet to discover
- ghostpepper 5y ago> In any case, the Economist is not any worse than any other mainstream publication. Often they do pretty good reporting. But you absolutely must not rely on it solely especially for foreign reporting where you don't have bearings. I think this is perhaps misguided. It's not fair to the economist to compare an article on, eg. politics in Brazil, against the nuanced understanding that a Brazilian citizen would have, because most people from North American with no other ties to Brazil would have no frame of reference. In other words, the choice is not, a simplified version of the issues vs a nuanced understanding, it's a simplified understanding of the issue vs none at all.
- sudosysgen 5y agoBut this is a bit of a false dichotomy. There is no reason why you would have to limit yourself to North-American sources here. Plenty of news agencies around the world have articles in English without the anglophone bias it may bring. And even non-local sources may still bring some enlightenment. If you were trying to understand Brazilian politics but couldn't read any Brazilian sources, it would still be much better to read Anglo, European and, say, Middle Eastern reporting and then consider the differences in reporting and how they might be linked to their worldview. Besides, oftentimes a simplistic and biased understanding whose inaccuracy is not understood is much worse than no understanding at all. At least in the second case you are aware of your ignorance and will probably be more weary of rash action.
- crazygringo 5y agoI lived in Brazil for many years and read the local news closely. Whenever the Economist published an article on Brazilian politics, it was generally far superior and far more insightful than anything in the local press. Which genuinely surprised me. Remember -- most local news sources, whether in the US or Brazil, aren't nuanced at all. They're surface-level and sensationalistic. But while Brazil has a home-grown news equivalent of Time ("Veja"), as well as USA Today (O Globo) it simply doesn't have any home-grown news source at the level of sophistication of the Economist, not even for domestic news.
- ghostpepper 5y ago
- 13415 5y agoI don't understand why people keep arguing against journals or newspapers because they are allegedly ideological or biased. Everybody is ideological and biased. Are they afraid they might lose all their critical thinking skills once they read such a journal and somehow be influenced or brainwashed without realizing it? The people who recommend against those medias already believe of themselves that they are better informed and able to recognize the bias. If they are that critical, then they should have no troubles consuming biased and ideological media, and they shouldn't assume without further evidence that others don't have the same ability. Especially in this case it's weird, because the journal is called The Economist. Obviously you'd expect some bias pro economy there.
- sudosysgen 5y agoOf course not, I myself read it often. I'm arguing against the GP that said that it's okay to read only the Economist. It's not okay to read only a single source. You can be as critical as you want but if you no longer have any bearings on a subject you're being led by the nose. Also, "pro-economy bias" is pretty vague. There are many ways one could be biased in a way so as to focus on a better economy, and they can be radically different.
- bena 5y agoMedia is already plural. Medium is the singular.
- 13415 5y agoThat's true. Although it's worth mentioning that "mediums" is also accepted as a plural of "medium" in English, but not when it's used for communication media.