5 ms·
The fix is for the government to make it a service. Right now, the government is punting responsibility to private actors who do not have the legal tools to op
by lotsofpulp 5y ago
The fix is for the government to make it a service. Right now, the government is punting responsibility to private actors who do not have the legal tools to operate an identity service.
The government already operates an identity service via passports. The only reason they do not have an electronic identity service yet is because it is beneficial for them to be able to blame private actors when things go wrong.
- specialist 5y agoThis is The Correct Answer™. Misc governments already operate 1,000s of identity, credentialing, and licensing services. Wouldn't it be great if profiles on DoorDash, Yelp, Hotels, etc. were required to be linked to IRL identities and licenses?
- nkohari 5y agoI suppose it depends on how much you want ~all of your online activity to be attributed to your real identity, in such a way that could be easily examined by the government.
- specialist 5y agoAuthenticity and anonymous speech are not mutually exclusive. Stop pretending they are.
- d110af5ccf 5y agoYou are the only one who mentioned speech, "online activity" is what was referred to. You specifically suggested linking profiles to government identification. "Linking" wouldn't seem to leave much room for anonymity regardless of activity.
- specialist 5y agoWhat's online activity if not speech? If DoorDash has a fake profile for D111af5ccf's Divine Donuts, is that not a crime? Impersonation, fraud, theft of IP, etc. Again, how does authenticity conflict with free speech? Examples, please.
- danShumway 5y agoBut at a fundamental level, why do Discord and Clubhouse need to verify my identity? I don't think the question GP is asking is whether or not Stripe is a good way to confirm someone's real-life identity, or whether it would be better for the government to do it. I think what they're asking why we're doing identity verification for chat applications. Is this a good direction overall for the Internet to be moving in? I don't like the idea that I should have one real-life identity that every service I sign up for online knows, even trivial services like social networks. I would argue a world like that is abridging on people's Right to Hide (https://anewdigitalmanifesto.com/#right-to-hide https://anewdigitalmanifesto.com/#right-to-hide)
- lotsofpulp 5y agoWho is “we”? Maybe the people operating the chat app have determined that it is in their businesses’ best interest to verify identity. I can certainly see it reducing costs for the business. I am not suggesting all businesses be required to do it. But I do not see why businesses should be prohibited from doing it. If you do not want an identity linked service, then buy a website name, and start a business and do not require people to identify.
- danShumway 5y ago"We" in this context means the overall population of users on the web, including non-corporate users and individuals who are exercising their freedoms online. We can't justify every architecture decision about the web via only business costs, if that was the case we'd make adblockers illegal and deprecate HTML. You need a stronger argument if you want me as a user to care about or support your business interests. If you want my support you have to show how this benefits the web overall, not just your company.
- lotsofpulp 5y agoIs this a discussion about the architecture of the web? Or about specific websites? If Costco wants me to login to their website to buy things, or Facebook wants me to use real identity, that does not stop me from using alternatives that do not. Am I entitled to alternatives that do not verify identity? Maybe the operating costs are too high?
- toomuchtodo 5y agoThis is coming, it’s just taking Government Time (Login.gov, USPS for in person proofing, etc).
- markdown 5y ago> The fix is for the government to make it a service. Agreed. An example: https://www.realme.govt.nz/ https://www.realme.govt.nz/
- duped 5y agoThis isn't a problem to fix. Internet businesses don't have an absolute right to your identity. The government (in the US at least) does offer some form of identity services like everify for employment.
- lotsofpulp 5y agoThey do not have a right to your identity. But I do not see why people have an absolute right to use a business without providing identity either. If both parties agree, then they can exchange info. The government is using 2FA SMS as your identity (for government services themselves), effectively offloading their liability into the mobile operators. But not really, because the mobile operators are not liable either. So as a little person, you are screwed all around. If the government were to make an electronic identity, which it needs to for its own services, it might as well be accessible for all so you do not have to trust private businesses with it.
- karaterobot 5y agoThis is one of those suggestions where I can immediately see some downsides, and am struggling to think of upsides, though I'm sure they exist. 1. I don't trust my government to have better security than anybody else. 2. I'm worried that I would lose the ability to opt out of a government-provided IaaS. Unlike Stripe, and I can't avoid using the government even if I try really hard. They already have my identity, so my privacy is dependent upon whatever their current policy happens to be. I do not trust unknown future administrations not to sell my data to the highest bidder. 3. The U.S. government has an... uneven track record delivering services and software, especially when there is no competition. Those are my anxieties: what are the advantages to this approach that I'm not seeing?
- lotsofpulp 5y agoThe advantage is the government is the one liable for it working. Right now, I’m at the mercy of ATT/Verizon/T-Mobile keeping my phone number working for identification purposes. And they have no legal mandate to continue doing that, and I have no recourse if they stop doing that for whatever reason. It is all the same reasons the government does not outsource issuing of passports. It needs to be from an official source with legal protections.