7 ms·
I highly recommend the Economist. Their articles mostly follow a dialectical format -- thesis, antithesis, synthesis, with about a third of the article spent o
by crazygringo 5y ago
I highly recommend the Economist.
Their articles mostly follow a dialectical format -- thesis, antithesis, synthesis, with about a third of the article spent on each one. I don't know of any other publication whose house style is so rigorous in this.
It's also highly editorialized, but very open and transparent about the positions it takes -- any bias they have is in the open, but is in the final synthesis after they've treated both sides.
It also doesn't fall neatly into any liberal/conservative divide. It tends to be socially progressive yet only interested in solutions that can be practically implemented, pro-free market but deeply concerned about externalities and the environment, pro-democracy but with hard-headed realpolitik.
Plus probably half of what each weekly issue covers is news you won't find in any other American publication, at least -- it's a global publication and one of the best ways to simply learn about the entire world's political and economic news.
- whimsicalism 5y agoThe Economist skews conservative in the sense that it is who I wish the conservatives were.
- bosswipe 5y agoI agree, it's a traditional conservative business view point: less regulation, free trade, free press, democratic government with a strong fair legal system.
- rootusrootus 5y agoThe Economist strikes me as very liberal, and not particularly conservative. And by that I mean the traditional definition of liberal, not Democratic-Party-of-the-US liberal.
- sudosysgen 5y agoConservatism is a relative term. You can be a conservative right-winger, a conservative socialist, a conservative liberal or any other kind of conservative as long as your social situation fits it. Many articles by the Economist are conservative in that they intend to defend and conserve the status-quo, especially when dealing with foreign policy.
- JAlexoid 5y agoYou're using conservativism vey much in American GOP understanding of the term, which has stopped being conservative a while ago. Conservativism is a relative position, but you can't be a conservative liberal. Economist literally had a massive article what is conservativism. And - SPOILER - UK Torries used to be conservative, while GOP has been reactionary/populist for a while now.
- sudosysgen 5y agoI am not. I don't think the GOP definition of conservatism admits conservative socialism. You definitely can be a conservative liberal. The American society by and large is founded on liberal principles. All you have to do to be a conservative liberal is to stick to 18th-19th century liberalism, in being a so-called "classical liberal". I agree that the GOP is reactionary more than conservative.
- JAlexoid 5y agoClassical liberalism - complete laissez faire market, no government interference and individual wealth creation. Today's libertarians are closest to classical liberals. The term classical liberal exists specifically, because conservative liberal creates a massive ambiguity. And getting back to The Economist - they aren't conservative at all. It's a modern liberal magazine, that routinely promotes wealth redistribution and support for the poor.
- whimsicalism 5y agoThis is a frustrating comment chain for me to read. The person you are responding to clearly is already familiar with the concept of classical liberalism, and you are responding as if they are a dunce.
- JAlexoid 5y agoJust because you and him are both ignorant on political philosophy, doesn't mean that they know anything. https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/liberalism/ https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/liberalism/ https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/conservatism/ https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/conservatism/
- JAlexoid 5y agoThey're not. To the point that they had a whole issue dedicated to the death of modern conservativism and how their editorial policy is classic liberal.
- whimsicalism 5y agoIt's a semantic debate, and not a particularly interesting one at that. "Classical liberal" and "conservative" are not necessarily at odds. "Liberal" in the sense that you are using it is a political philosophy, conservative is just a slot to fill in.
- JAlexoid 5y agoSo you're using conservative(adjective to mean slow), as not same as Conservative(political philosophy). Because as political movements they are vey much at odds.
- bogota 5y agoI have been reading the economist for a while now and im curious if you have felt a decline in quality or maybe its just my differing in opinion from recent articles. Mostly i feel more articles coming up that are worded in a way to convince the reader or a certain point without any data. This is something i never really noticed in the past. It might just be me though.
- akvadrako 5y agoThat certainly seems true though I wouldn't say it's specific to the economist. I've noticed the change in every publication, even stuff like the Financial Times.
- atty 5y agoI like their articles, but I can’t recommend the Economist after attempting to cancel my subscription the last time I had one. It took me over an hour of digging through the website, and then phone calls where they tried to up-sell me, side-sell me, every-way-sell me on discounts and different packages no matter how many times I said I just wanted to cancel my account. It’s possibly the worst experience I’ve ever had cancelling something.
- ngngngng 5y agoJust use a privacy.com card and cancel the card when you're done with the subscription. I agree that it's trash to have to do something like that, but it's a pretty easy solution.
- JAlexoid 5y agoYou do realize that people that manage the subscriptions aren't the same that write the content, right?
- cwkoss 5y agoIf you can't opt out of one but not the other, is this distinction meaningful?
- JAlexoid 5y agoYes. Substance is critical here. Arguing that Economist is bad, because it was complex to cancel your subscription (I see a massive button on my account page) is like arguing that a restaurant is bad, because they don't accept gold coins as payment.
- vincent-toups 5y agoThe Economist certainly doesn't break down easily on the American political spectrum, but in the more coherent language of higher level policy, the Economist is almost 100% liberal. I agree its a well put together publication, but a socialist (for instance) would argue it is deeply ideological.
- sudosysgen 5y agoWell, it is deeply ideological. But if we're being honest, everything is. The Economist is fine to read as long as you really deeply understand it's ideology.
- JAlexoid 5y agoThe Economist doesn't hide their ideology and advocacy. Unlike many "well renowned sources" (ahem... NYT)
- sudosysgen 5y agoWhat would you think the ideology of the Economist is and where in their website do you get that from? Just asking for the sake of argument.
- JAlexoid 5y agoThey routinely repeat that their editorial policy is liberal. Straight up in the articles they publish, they note that. I listen to their articles and they often repeat this. Literally typing this into Google would have provided you with the link to their website. https://www.economist.com/news/2020/06/19/frequently-asked-questions https://www.economist.com/news/2020/06/19/frequently-asked-q...
- sudosysgen 5y agoFrom that webpage, they say that their bias is between classical liberalism and centrism. Now, what is a classically liberal bias, concretely, as far as international affairs are concerned?
- jarjoura 5y ago100% agree, but the problem I have with the economist is that it requires serious mental commitment to engage with their articles. The meat of the story is buried deep. The only times I find myself capable of reading are when I'm traveling or commuting. The issues come weekly with really interesting topical stories, so I always add them to my reading todo list, but they just pile up so fast. This past year and 1/2 of WFH life meant, I now have about 50 issues to go through LOL.
- anonfornoreason 5y ago"the problem with this news source, is that it requires thinking to parse!" Sorry for the jab, but I think this is our current political situation in a nutshell - surface level, emotional takes are the primary way people engage in news and thus politics. It's hard to engage deeply, but it's required in order to build your own narrative, rather than just take on someone else's.
- dandersh 5y agoThere are some benefits to the Economist, such as the ones you mentioned but I don't know that I could recommend it, at least without a secondary source for what you're reading there. I stopped reading it about 10 years ago for a few reasons. During the housing crisis the coverage wasn't as deep as it should have been and I would read articles that were nothing more than "nationalizing banks is bad" without explaining why. Their coverage of US politics was also laughably bad. During the push to pass the ACA they overstated the GOP's position and willingness to deal. I used to get it from a library a few towns over so I would be 3-4 weeks behind. One time I was reading an article where Charles Grassley was being made out to be principled and respected and I'm laughing because he had recently endorsed the death panel nonsense. I really, really wish I could recommend the WSJ, however they declined pretty heavily after Murdoch bought them. The number of long form articles declined and I was seeing less journalism and more ideological fluff in the non-editorial sections.
- jollybean 5y ago"Their coverage of US politics was also laughably bad." It's an English magazine that's not even 'News'. Also this: "During the push to pass the ACA they overstated the GOP's position and willingness to deal." Is a pretty petty reason to not read something. Also, they could have been right. There are better reasons not to read the Economist.
- dandersh 5y agoMultiple examples of a publication's analysis being found lacking and a reaction of no longer consuming it as a result is not "pretty petty". I'm reading them for their non-US coverage, and if I find their US coverage to be lacking(which it was despite your attempts at gaslighting otherwise) than it is reasonable to question their non-US reporting and not waste time on it. No, they were proven to have been wrong. I provided a specific example of their analysis being wrong, one which you did not address. The ACA passed along party lines after almost a year of deliberation. The GOP spent the subsequent decade running on "repeal and replace" only to get seriously close once. There are multiple other examples (McConnell declaring the goal of making Obama a one term president, refusing to conduct hearings to confirm Garland to the SC after recommending him, etc.) of where the GOP was acting in bad faith, which is also what you are doing here.
- sudosysgen 5y agoI don't recommend using the Economist as your only source for international news. It's very deeply ideological in a way that is almost invisible if you can't easily compare it to a known truth. It's certainly not only interested in solutions that can be implemented. It's interested in solutions that enforce the free market, and it paints non-market solutions as infeasible, even though they often work and are implementable. But this is invisible ideology and very easy to mistake for pragmatism, because a pure pragmatist will certainly appreciate many market solutions. The final synthesis is not after having treated both sides. It's after having treated two sides, which are editorially chosen. As far as dialectics it would be much more interesting if they could dialectically analyze their own internal contradictions between democracy and interventionist realpolitik, or between free-market fundamentalism and concern about externalities. But it doesn't really grapple with those, which is a sign that it's only applying dialectical thinking in convenient ways. In any case, the Economist is not any worse than any other mainstream publication. Often they do pretty good reporting. But you absolutely must not rely on it solely especially for foreign reporting where you don't have bearings.
- pydry 5y agoAn example of such thinking from last week: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27392455 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27392455 It used to be a much better magazine.
- JAlexoid 5y agoThe Economist is one of the least biased sources of news, that routinely publishes letters, opeds and articles contradicting the sated editorial agenda. Very few other news sources actually do that. They're not perfect, but it sure beats NYT. If you want the optimal news coverage without needing to read a million sources - The Economist, Financial Times, WSJ and The Guardian.
- sudosysgen 5y agoAs I said, they show both sides, but they choose which two. They are not as forthcoming with their biases as it seems. They mainly set up their ideological oppositions as conservatives, but they in fact have a lot in common with them. This is especially true for foreign relations. I'd be happy to see examples of articles that go against the Economists' editorial agenda in profound ways and that pertain to foreign policy. If you want news coverage that is any good at all and you care about foreign affairs you absolutely have to include at least one and preferably two non-anglophone or non-western sources that preferably oppose each other. A good barometer I have for journals as far as foreign policy is their coverage of the Iraq War before it began. As far as I can see the Economist published almost nothing opposing it, limiting themselves to surface-level reporting of anti-war arguments in the sole goal of defeating them. I don't understand why you would limit yourself, if you had to choose 4 sources, to 4 centrist anglophone sources. It seems like a very biased media diet.
- ErikVandeWater 5y agoI was listening to all of The Economist's podcasts on Spotify until recently. I found their bias grew and grew over time until it was just too annoying to listen. I think they realized their target market was yuppie (lean strongly left) and made the (correct) business decision to cater to them exclusively.