4 ms·
It’s Apple’s Internet Now
- gigatexal 5y agoThat’s fine by me.
- upforgrabs 5y agoI gave the idea to Apple a year ago during a long rant about privacy. Glad to see it come to fruition.
- nicolaslem 5y agoWonderful, soon the standard way to access the web will be user --> Apple/Google proxy --> Cloudflare --> website.
- machello13 5y agoGoogle's World Wide Web running on Apple's Internet.
- olliej 5y agoif you read the details of private relay you see apple doesn’t know the details of the request, so the idea that apple gets filter specific content is nonsense. It’s specifically set up so apple doesn’t know the content of the request and cloud flare doesn’t know who made the request. It’s like tor-light
- Mindwipe 5y agoThe problem is that it presents a single point for massive control by governments, many of whom will see a fantastic opportunity to pass legislation. Private Relay doesn't let Apple see the request now, but that doesn't mean it won't. They also don't need to see the request to deny exit point access to any number of sites they arbitrarily decide not to foward any traffic to.
- olliej 5y agoApple doesn’t control the exit point (that’s cloudflare?) and if cloudflare wants to block access to something they already have a huge swathe of the internet under their control, w/o needing a proxy in the middle. Finally you can always just turn it off - it asks you the first time as well, it is explicitly opt in, and isn’t available in countries that have strict censorship laws.
- Mindwipe 5y ago> Apple doesn’t control the exit point (that’s cloudflare?) I mean they do, Apple can switch provider at any point, and Apple is the legal entity controlling the service. Cloudflare will do whatever Apple contracts them to do. Any legislation will target Apple. The UK Online Safety Bill will almost certainly require Apple to censor it. I don't think it's at all certain such legislation would apply to Cloudflare - Cloudflare do not offer a consumer service that I buy (well, they do offer 1.1.1.1 but that has a fairly small amount of users and is irrelevant). > Finally you can always just turn it off - it asks you the first time as well, it is explicitly opt in, and isn’t available in countries that have strict censorship laws. The problem is that Apple are going to have to restrict the number of countries a lot or start doing more control. The US is very unusual for example in not requiring ISPs to block access to the Pirate Bay. European law is pretty settled that all member states need ISPs to do blocking in trademark cases in some circumstances. And yes, a VPN provider already bypasses this, but laws tend to ignore when they don't work for 5% of the population, in a way legislators suddenly can't ignore when 40% of the population is sailing past the blocks.
- simonh 5y agoSo your concern is that things that currently work the way they do might, and this is where it gets sinister, work differently in the future! Your neighbours might be nice now, but in the future they might spy on you for the Russians! If we condemned everyone for things they might do one day, everybody would be behind bars.
- Mindwipe 5y ago
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- poorman 5y agoI can see the headlines now. "Apple relay is down, millions without internet access."
- simonh 5y agoSettings-> Safari -> Disable private relay
- jug 5y agoAnd this is honestly something iOS could detect and ask the user to disable if Internet connectivity is there but relay is not.
- st3fan 5y agoIt actually already does that. Earlier today Safari popped up a notification saying that it was temporarily disabled. The beta is not super stable at the moment.
- michelb 5y agoHow often is Google’s DNS down?
- cblconfederate 5y agoI see it as privatizing the work of nsa
- simonh 5y agoYou mean by, er, encrypting and/or obfuscating the origin of everything? Although in general actually I think you’re right. Free world security services should be working to secure our communications and protect us from identity theft. Hopefully the rise of ransomware as a systemic economic threat will wake them up to the fact their primary job is actually to protect us.
- spzb 5y agoYeah, but it's not, is it?