4 ms·
If a quack doctor in the India performa a malicious surgery and kills a patient, do we blame doctors in the USA? If not, why does a bad cop from some backwater
by dragontamer 5y ago
If a quack doctor in the India performa a malicious surgery and kills a patient, do we blame doctors in the USA?
If not, why does a bad cop from some backwater town speak for all college educated cops from an arbitrary suburbia?
The first problem is that the USA has over 10,000 police departments. This means that one cop from Kentucky has absolutely no connection to one from Boston.
And yet, the current culture blames the Boston cop for the actions that the Kentucky cop does.
- ebiester 5y agoBoston may be a bad example. https://www.nbcnews.com/news/investigations/report-problems-state-drug-lab-where-chemist-faked-tests-n30746 https://www.nbcnews.com/news/investigations/report-problems-... https://www.stevelocke.com/blog/i-fit-the-description https://www.stevelocke.com/blog/i-fit-the-description
- dragontamer 5y agoI've never heard of asset forfeiture being abused in the bigger cities. And the small town cops in my area are known for harassing African Americans more than the city cops (the city cops have significant numbers of African Americans: less than the proportion of the population but way better than the town-cops) ------------ > https://www.stevelocke.com/blog/i-fit-the-description https://www.stevelocke.com/blog/i-fit-the-description Uhhhhh. That's... not really a problem on my scale. I mean, yeah, that's a hassle but... https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hOZwRBXfFmU https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hOZwRBXfFmU This here is small town cop harassing an African American. And we only know about it because he's an Army Officer (a low ranking one, but still, the Army sticks up for their members). Who knows how many African Americans did those small town cops harassed before they messed with the wrong man? Don't get me wrong here: any kind of stop is a big hassle. But... my bar for "serious police misbehavior" is set at a certain level based on what's going on in my area. The blogpost, while a hassle, is not anywhere close to some of the stories I'm hearing just in the past couple of months. > https://www.nbcnews.com/news/investigations/report-problems-state-drug-lab-where-chemist-faked-tests-n30746 https://www.nbcnews.com/news/investigations/report-problems-... Sounds to me that someone was double-checking the results and caught the problem. We don't have those assurances in other locations. In a city, you have a citizen's board, good defense lawyers, and other "defenses" who can stand up to injustice from the police departments. That's WHY a city-cop can get their ass busted if they make these kinds of mistakes. I mean yeah, it sucks that they're still finding injustices, but at least people are tasked with finding abuse. In a small town cop where the Sheriff is elected every 4 years by a population who just doesn't give a care, no one has any recourse or defense system against the Sheriff or their deputies. None at all. Its "Wild West" mode, where Sheriff can do whatever the heck they want, and the citizens are ignorant of the injustices their Sheriff does (so they keep electing them over and over again). I have more faith in Police Commissioner systems, or straight up adversarial systems like NYPC (which has an adversarial Citizen's Review Board to represent citizens: https://www1.nyc.gov/site/ccrb/index.page https://www1.nyc.gov/site/ccrb/index.page).
- jmcqk6 5y agoit's not hard to see why. Accountability is a major problem with the police in the US. I'm not sure there is anywhere I can trust that a bad police officer is going to face consequences for their actions. That's not to say it doesn't happen. It does happen. But for every example of accountability, there seems to be several examples of police officers, out of control, power-tripping, many time in the presence of other police officers, without any of them standing up to them. When we cannot trust the police to do what's right, when we cannot trust the police to stand up to their own, when we can have no idea whether a police officer is going to do their job, or power-trip to ruin your life, this is exactly what happens. I have very little interaction with the police personally, and I hope that continues. Every interaction is a roll of the dice, and that shouldn't be the case in a civilized nation.
- dragontamer 5y agoDifferent police departments have differing amounts of citizen review associated with them. That's my point. The sheriff of (insert small town) has no accountability aside from an election that's all but guaranteed to go his way again. Other municipalities have better accountability systems. In particular, you need to have the accountability to come from outside the police department.
- jmcqk6 5y agoI get what you're saying, but expecting police officers to stand-up to their colleagues when they are breaking the law in their presence is not unreasonable. Citizen review and oversight it definitely important and necessary. The police themselves are also radically failing their responsibilities in this regard.
- jmcqk6 5y agoI get what you're saying, but expecting police officers to stand-up to their colleagues when they are breaking the law in their presence is not unreasonable. Citizen review and oversight it definitely important and necessary. The police themselves are also radically failing their responsibilities in this regard.
- kthejoker2 5y ago> This means that one cop from Kentucky has absolutely no connection to one from Boston. This premise is false. The blue wall is real. If the Boston cops would stand up and say they don't support that Kentucky cop, it would make every other cop in America pause. They absolutely have power over each other with their words and actions. They could wholeheartedly support civil and criminal actions against police officers who do wrong. But they don't; they protect each other, one and all. And that empowers every cop everywhere to act extrajudicially. Their silence is the connection.
- dragontamer 5y ago> If the Boston cops would stand up and say they don't support that Kentucky cop, it would make every other cop in America pause It was a cop who told me about citizen review boards, my rights as a citizen, and how to legally fight cops. In particular: it was an African American cop who was very explicit about the abuses of cops in various municipalities. It was my local school department that worked with the police department to host this "community cop" discussion with school-children. Etc. etc. Its not quite as black-and-white as you're making it sound. If a cop does X-abuse, then you go to Y. You have a right to know their badge number (at least in my municipality. And in practice, a cop has the badge and the force and can probably refuse. Still, if they fail to present their badge and there's a recording of it, you might be able to get them. Don't talk to cops unnecessarily, talk to them with a lawyer, etc. etc.) These discussion points are commonly pointed out by cops who are trying to do the right thing.