59 ms·
> Real blogs offer RSS/Atom. Only those freaks fighting for user engagement dumping zero content articles offer newsletters. The thing is, ever since Google Re
by mschuster91 5y ago
> Real blogs offer RSS/Atom. Only those freaks fighting for user engagement dumping zero content articles offer newsletters.
The thing is, ever since Google Reader got terminated, the user base of RSS/Atom clients has been steadily dropping down. Firefox IIRC terminated "dynamic bookmarks" years ago, and even back when it existed it didn't support notification.
Yes, us nerd crowd knows that RSS exists, but ever tried asking your boss or your teenage kid what "Atom" is?
Actual mail newsletters are the only way left other than even more obnoxious browser push nags to get your users notified that you have new content.
- inshadows 5y agoYour point is valid. Still, I find that most "blogs" offering newsletters these days are frivolous content dumping ground, and the reason for their existence is likely just building Internet persona or something. EDIT: Lots of such noise (often appearing here on HN) comes from Substack.
- k1m 5y ago> the reason for their existence is likely just building Internet persona or something. Another appeal of newsletters I think is distrust (rightly in my opinion) in corporate algorithms powering people's feeds. I'd love to see more widespread adoption of RSS again, rather than a push to get everyone signed up to a bunch of different email newsletters. Perhaps once people feel overwhelmed with their inbox getting filled with email newsletters, RSS will make a resurgence. I wrote the piece linked here, and it wasn't intended to be an anti-newsletter post. Just against newsletters being pushed on readers in the middle of the article they've started reading, as opposed to a sidebar or at the end of the article. We have web apps that produce stripped-down articles to be read on e-readers or printed out. These newsletter signup requests often blend into the content as just another paragraph of text, which can be a little jarring when you're engrossed in reading. Quite a few of the writers I like are on Substack, and earn money through it. Substack also offers full-text RSS feeds (for publicly-accessible content, not sure what level of RSS support there is for paid content - perhaps that's still email-only). And their Reader has RSS support too - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25444507 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25444507 - I hope that's a sign that they'll be doing more with RSS in the future.
- Breza 5y agoI still miss Google Reader. I wonder if Google wishes it had kept it running now that their efforts to launch social networks failed and Twitter/Facebook have taken over much of the space that RSS used to occupy. Google could have built such a huge dataset of individual-level reader preferences (not saying that's the best use of RSS, just that there's a business case).