11 ms·
Tricks of Trench Warfare (2020)
- geoduck14 5y agoOh wow. Some of these were rather gruesome! I really liked having a fake head that snipers would shoot - there by allowing you to calculate where the sniper was. This sounds like something that could still be employed. Any snipers out there to know how to counter this?
- Vecr 5y agoSuppressors, not shooting fake targets (spotter optics, possibly IR), having multiple snipers coordinate so they can fire a single round each all at the same time and go somewhere else before they get shot at. The last is probably the most important.
- paulluuk 5y agoI don't understand how suppressors would work against figuring out the elevation angle of a sniper shot. Likewise, wouldn't multiple snipers all firing on the same fake target simply give away the number of snipers and all of their individual elevations?
- geoduck14 5y agoI think the multiple snipers each fire at separate targets. One sniper per target. All at once, everyone fires (killing any threats), then running like hell before someone else jumps up and grabs a gun.
- potta_coffee 5y agoHow would you figure out the elevation angle of a sniper's shot? It's not like you can do forensics when you are being shot at.
- paulluuk 5y agoDid you read the article? They did exactly this.
- Cthulhu_ 5y agoCould, but a lot of modern warfare is incredibly one-sided with one side being technologically superior to the other. They wouldn't even risk deploying snipers if there's a chance of a counter-attack via artillery. Or ground forces for that matter. First and second Gulf War were started by a massive air raid that took out most of Iraq's defenses, tanks and infrastructure. That said, just because they may have military superiority doesn't mean they can actually win a war on someone else's home turf.
- hutzlibu 5y ago"That said, just because they may have military superiority doesn't mean they can actually win a war on someone else's home turf. " A military superior force can win a war against a enemy population, but it cannot claim then anymore, to fight for those people.
- jeffreyrogers 5y agoSnipers were pretty frequent in Iraq, despite the US's technological superiority.
- samus 5y agoThe British did just that during the Boer wars, against an opponent that engaged in guerilla warfare on their home turfeand had access to modern weaponry. They gained control of the country by partitioning it with blockhouses, strongpoints and barbed wire fences, scorched earth tactics, involving indiscriminate destruction of farms, and forced resettlement of many Boers into concentration camps. Fortunately, many of these tactics have gotten out of fashion. Also, this required the deployment of hundreds of thousands of troops for many years, which could be justified economically only by the diamonds mined in not-yet-South Africa.
- snypher 5y agoSniper units are often deployed behind lines and spend hours or days in observation. They may arrive on site well in advance of their target and be very sure of identity before firing. Also, a marksman deployed with an infantry unit will support small arms fire (~200 yards) with range extension out to say 800 yards. A dedicated sniper team could be taking targets out as far as 3,000 yards. So perhaps a infantry marksman would be more willing to take a shot at a closer target given they are part of a squad, where a sniper team won't shoot at a tin cup or fake head in case they give away their position. It's worth just waiting another hour and see if that guy patrolling comes by again etc.
- hef19898 5y agoModern day snipers, yes. WW1 snipers were in front trenches and sniped at the opposite trench, a couple of hundreds of meters away if so far.
- philwelch 5y agoMy favorite part is the part where you smoke a cigarette through the fake head for added versimlitude. The enemy sniper must be thinking, “is that a papier-mâché head? Can’t be, he’s having a smoke”.
- taylorfinley 5y agoIf you're in to security at all and are not already familiar with The Grugq, you will likely really enjoy his talks and writings. It's fitting that an expert on deception uses an avatar that projects the image he wants you to have of him. Don't be too jarred when you watch a talk and realize the avatar is part of the smoke and mirrors!
- skinkestek 5y ago> The method that actually worked was to get a few boys with rifles up on the parapet and have them shoot down into the trenches, killing everyone they could. Faster, more efficient, and no silly buggers with grenades flying back and forth. It sounds so easy when written this way :-/ Also if anyone is interested in WW2 sniping the Finnish sniper "white death" might be an interesting starting point. He went to extreme lengths - and was very successful.
- ovi256 5y agoSimo Hayha, nicknamed "The White Death", was not just a successful sniper, using a rifle, but also a successful ambusher, surprising enemy small groups like patrols and devastating them using an automatic submachinegun.
- jacobwilliamroy 5y agoHow many times do you think he pooped or peed in his pants?
- unwind 5y agoWikipedia knows more [1] as usual. Häyhä is believed to have killed over 500 men during the Winter war (inculding 259 killed by sniper rifle), the highest number of sniper kills in any major war. That is just ... gruesome. I was confused when I looked at this article, I misread the URI as "gnu.org" (laptop screen too far away, thanks Covid WFH) and started trying to figure out the analogy they were making for a paragraph or two. :) [1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Simo_H%C3%A4yh%C3%A4 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Simo_H%C3%A4yh%C3%A4
- skinkestek 5y ago> That is just ... gruesome. Yep. But the alternative were worse. Anyone who hasn't been occupied by Stalin era Soviet should be very happy. As a kid I heard a bunch of stories from my dad who had friends in Finland and also from my friends who had been there. One was that the Finnish soldiers always carried a backpack on night patrol so they could safely backstab anyone they came up behind in the night and couldn't identify as if it was one of theirs it would end in a blanket or something anyway. Another was that of Finnish troops not being to careful when they packed the hay they slept in so some of it would fall on the ground. Only there would also often be a mine there as well. Oh, and most of the time the Russians stopped to examine the hay there was just hay on the ground but sniper fire from the hillside behind it. As Wikimedia points out: the Finnish were lucky because of Stalins great purge, but still they should not be messed with. Oh, another one, from air combat, this one I learned later from a book probably: according to that source the planes the Russians used for the invasion of Finland had landing gear that had to be lowered using a pulley system. Again, according to that source, some Russian planes were lost after the Finnish pilots figured out this and started ambushing them while they approached landing.
- docdeek 5y agoAs an Aussie schoolkid I remember learning about the ANZAC retreat from the trenches in Gallipoli after hacking together a way to fire their rifles using dripping water, and I always thought that was pretty neat: "Invented by Lance-Corporal William Scurry, 7th Battalion, AIF, these ‘drip’ or ‘pop off’ rifles fired at intervals to convince the Ottomans that the Anzacs still occupied their trenches. The drip rifle incorporated two ration tins. The top one was filled with water, while the empty bottom one was attached to the trigger by a piece of string or wire. Before leaving, a soldier punched a small hole in the upper tin to allow water to trickle into the lower one, which eventually toppled over, pulling the trigger.” https://nzhistory.govt.nz/media/photo/drip-rifle-gallipoli https://nzhistory.govt.nz/media/photo/drip-rifle-gallipoli
- somedangedname 5y agoIf you're interested in doing a deep dive into the Gallipoli landings I found this analysis of the operation by a USMC officer to be great reading: https://apps.dtic.mil/dtic/tr/fulltext/u2/a279563.pdf https://apps.dtic.mil/dtic/tr/fulltext/u2/a279563.pdf
- tigerlily 5y agoMāori invented trench warfare in the 1800s. Their fortifications were surrounded by palisades, and they dug trenches beneath, shooting hapless British soldiers from the gaps between the ground and the bottom of the wall.
- enkid 5y agoYou have a source for that?
- comicjk 5y agoIt's true, though it wasn't the first use of these techniques. They beat the British this way at the battle of Gate Pā. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tauranga_campaign https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tauranga_campaign
- hutzlibu 5y agoFortifications and trenches are waaay older. I think the romans were the first to master it. But I am not sure, if what you describe qualifies as trench warfare.
- w0de0 5y agoA pivotal moment in the Koran is known as "The Battle of the Trench."
- 5y ago
- dugmartin 5y ago> The method that actually worked was to get a few boys with rifles up on the parapet and have them shoot down into the trenches, killing everyone they could. Faster, more efficient, and no silly buggers with grenades flying back and forth. The American's brought shotguns ("trench guns") to do that work. It was seen by the Germans as violation of the law of war. "On 19 September 1918, the German government issued a diplomatic protest against the American use of shotguns, alleging that the shotgun was prohibited by the law of war." https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Winchester_Model_1897 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Winchester_Model_1897
- JackFr 5y agoThe Thompson submachine gun also picked up the nickname “trench broom”.
- philwelch 5y agoThough the war ended before the Thompson was in production, this was absolutely the intended use. Similar to the BAR, it would later see service in a world war much different than the one it was designed for.
- hutzlibu 5y agoThe hypocrysis of the german government/army of that time, is staggering. They were the the ones, who introduced chemical weapons, poison gas, to the battlefield - and then cried about shotguns?! Oh and later, when the war was lost, it was of course the fault of the communist and socialdemocrats, who stabbed the army in the back and not of the glorious, heroic army. And there are still lots of people glorifying the Kaiserreich. I am glad its gone.
- Bost 5y ago> The hypocrysis of the german government/army of that time, is staggering. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chemical_weapons_in_World_War_I#1914:_Tear_gas https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chemical_weapons_in_World_War_... All sides started to develop these weapons before the war, and apparently it's the Germans who were capable of deploying these weapons sooner and with greater success. What you present here nothing less than a one-sided propaganda. It reminds of French villages hundreds of kilometers far from any WWI front line, deep in the rear with memorials dedicated to "Innocent children fallen in the great war" followed by a list of some 10 to 15 male names. Innocent children, the throat cutter sort, same as those from the other side.
- fnord77 5y ago> once the sniper nest was located, call in an artillery strike. did they have radios? Or would they send a runner?
- nine_k 5y agoA phone. Field phones were very much a thing during WWI and WWII, with point to point wiring laid down very soon after gaining control over the territory, or even before that.
- DyslexicAtheist 5y agoalso carrier pigeons: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/War_pigeon https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/War_pigeon
- inglor_cz 5y agoIn the pre-transistor times, radios were heavy and used a lot of energy. Even in WWII, field radios weighed about 35-40 pounds. A soldier with a radio could not carry a lot of other equipment. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/SCR-300 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/SCR-300 Vacuum tubes are a clumsy technology.
- spywaregorilla 5y ago> The simplest implementation of this trick was leaving shiny tin cans, or other enticing targets for snipers to zero their sights on at the front. Germans would leave cans on the parapet for snipers to shoot at. Due to the high contrast and easy visibility of these targets, they were attractive for naive snipers to use while adjusting their sights. A grave and often fatal error. Wait so... they just put out tin cans and the enemy snipers would shoot them because their sights needed to be tuned? That doesn't feel like it makes any sense. For one, you can't shoot the can unless your sights are tuned, so I guess they're taking multiple shots? Was it really so hard to invent a sight that could be tuned without firing to give away your position?
- radiokicker 5y agoEven modern day rifles need a handful of rounds to sight in. I assume due to the massive casualties suffered by both sides they were sending up troops to the trenches with little time to prepare.
- Mauricebranagh 5y agoSniper rifles in ww1 where custom conversions of the standard infantry rifles or in the early war actual hunting rifles.
- chrisseaton 5y agoYou can use a tool called a collimator to boresight a rifle in the field, but it's only so effective. And back then they didn't have technology like floating barrels.
- spywaregorilla 5y agoWhy didn't they shoot the other way to adjust their sights though? This feels like an obviously terrible idea?
- chrisseaton 5y ago
- newsbinator 5y ago> A periscope could be affixed alongside the head to allow the scout to manipulate the dummy head and observe the environment. > The scout would raise the head above the trench and attempt to get shot by a German sniper. Apparently the sensation of a bullet slamming into a target held mere inches above your head while you were smoking through it was rather bracing.