3 ms·
> do we really want to search a 90 year old female pensioner as often as a 21 year old man, when the former is significantly (as in, 100x thereabouts) less like
by josephcsible 5y ago
> do we really want to search a 90 year old female pensioner as often as a 21 year old man, when the former is significantly (as in, 100x thereabouts) less likely to pose a threat to a flight?
Terrorist organizations aren't stupid, and they have members of all ages. If we made it our policy not to search 90-year-olds anymore, then they'd suddenly end up committing most of the attacks on flights.
> Or consider health insurance. Do we really want young people paying the same premiums as 80 year olds?
In this example, what are you saying that the 80-year-olds have control over?
- rrdharan 5y ago> they'd suddenly end up committing most of the attacks on flights They really wouldn’t. There aren’t that many 90 year olds available and it’s pretty hard to recruit them into terrorism (relative to 21 year olds).
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- wruza 5y agoIf we made it our policy not to search 90-year-olds anymore, then they'd suddenly end up committing most of the attacks on flights. And skewed statistics accordingly, so that it would include them again. That’s how it already works, but on an intuition of particular security workers and/or general guidelines they receive.
- fighterpilot 5y ago"If we made it our policy not to search 90-year-olds anymore" Even if that isn't the optimal policy (and I didn't suggest that it was) due to its exploitability, it doesn't then follow that having the same search probability for 90 year old women and 21 year old men is optimal. Perhaps searching young men with a 3x higher probability compared to old women is optimal. What we can say with confidence, when considering only the immediate objective of flight safety (or venue security), is that an exactly equal search probability is definitely not optimal, due to nearly all instances of lone shooters and so on being young or middle aged men.