3 ms·
This post shows an astonishing lack of awareness of cost-benefit tradeoffs and indeed the very nature of the web. If you design for the lowest-common denominat
by dasil003 15y ago
This post shows an astonishing lack of awareness of cost-benefit tradeoffs and indeed the very nature of the web.
If you design for the lowest-common denominator, where do you draw the line? IE6? IE5.5? Win98 fonts? Do you render images for everything in order to create the "correct" brand impression in as many browsers as possible while sacrificing organic search traffic? Do you sacrifice the mobile experience to cater to the 10-year-old computer crowd?
Even if you forge ahead through the cognitive dissonance to create a graphic-design/visual-brand-centric priority system, for a given budget you have to decide whether you want to dumb it down for consistency's sake or create a more polished design that 50% of people will see today and 90% will see in a few years.
The bottom line is that these decisions need to be made on a case-by-case basis, and pounding on some creative hubris about the sanctity of each pixel will not guarantee anyone a more successful project. If you ran some A/B testing on the rounded corner issue you might be horrified to find out how inconsequential it ends up being in any given case.
- smackay 15y agoIdentifying whether the client wants a cutting edge design or one that has the widest possible browser support would seem to be requirement #1.
- Isofarro 15y agoI'd have thought identifying the target audience and the actual use-cases the site needs to meet as being the #1 requirement. Everything else derives from this, and is built to support it.
- macavity23 15y agoAgree 100% - and I would bet that the same A/B testing would show that those users who DO care about rounded corners, text shadows et al are using Chrome/FF/Safari.