13 ms·
Ex-Wave, Ex-Plus engineer on Google Plus
- megablast 15y agoEx-Wave, Ex-Plus engineer on why javascript is required to read a blog entry. No, it should not be.
- there 15y agoand then readability to fix the ridiculously thin font http://i.imgur.com/9Oy37.png http://i.imgur.com/9Oy37.png
- w1ntermute 15y agoWhat browser/OS are you using? It looks fine for me (Win 7 + Firefox): http://i.imgur.com/BNjXj.png http://i.imgur.com/BNjXj.png
- josegonzalez 15y agoChrome on OS X.
- w1ntermute 15y agoHmm, I don't have an OS X machine to test it on. Chromium on Linux looks like this: http://i.imgur.com/kEiQ2.png http://i.imgur.com/kEiQ2.png I think it's an issue with the font renderer or font specific to your browser/OS combination.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- ctide 15y agoYou're right, javascript should be required to browse the web, not just a blog entry.
- bobbyi 15y agoIf it's any consolation, it doesn't work with javascript either. I middle-clicked the "previously described" link and it took away the blog entry that I was in the middle of reading.
- jerrya 15y agoI see this at many sites, including, most frustratingly of all, within Google's various help sites. I don't know enough Javascript to understand why that behavior is so often created. Is it so hard to respect the "classic" "canonical" middle click behavior?
- dmit 15y agoIt's a WebKit issue: https://bugs.webkit.org/show_bug.cgi?id=22382 https://bugs.webkit.org/show_bug.cgi?id=22382 http://code.google.com/p/chromium/issues/detail?id=255 http://code.google.com/p/chromium/issues/detail?id=255
- jerrya 15y agoWow. Seems like such a simple and obvious problem and fix, it's educational to see how long it has taken to not get fixed.
- acqq 15y agoAnd I didn't manage to read it with Javascript and IE8. It seems that it's all because he uses http://sitebricks.org/ http://sitebricks.org/ for his site. It is also unreadable the same way.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- spullara 15y agoIt amazes me that this engineer appears to not know that Google+ Circles are already implemented in the core of Facebook as Friend Lists (though without a nice UI and pushed aside over time) and that Facebook Groups solve a completely different, unrelated problem.
- nl 15y agoThat's not what he was saying. His point was that he was waiting for Facebook to make their pre-emptive response to Circles, and then FB released Groups. He knows full well is solves a different problem - that was the point of what he was saying. Not only does Groups not really do the same things as Circles/Lists at all, but Facebook appears to think that Lists don't work. Zuckerberg: Just take friends on a site, and cut them into subgroups. Sounds good in theory. But almost no one wants to make lists. We’ve been at this for a few years, and promoted heavily. Most we’ve gotten is 5% to make lists, and most don’t make more than one. http://www.insidefacebook.com/2010/10/06/live-blogging-facebooks-lockdown-products-launch/ http://www.insidefacebook.com/2010/10/06/live-blogging-faceb...
- spullara 15y agoLists don't work and Groups are not a response to Google+ Cirlces.
- nl 15y agoI think we (and the author) are agreeing? Lists (in Facebook) suck - they UI is hidden and terrible. Facebook Groups came out when the author expected Facebook to respond to the concepts behind Google+ Circles. It turned out that it wasn't a response to those concepts at all, and was something unrelated. (BTW, it's not me down voting you.)
- spullara 15y agoSince the author doesn't mention Facebook Friend Lists, I can only presume that he doesn't know about them otherwise they should be top of mind when looking at Google+ Circles. He even talks about "copying circles" even though they are already in the product. I'm not sure why you think he knows anything about them? Did I miss something in his article?
- mlinsey 15y agoWe'll see. I agree that Facebook Groups is much less powerful than Circles and much less fundamental to the core Facebook experience than Circles is with G+. On the other hand, Facebook Groups takes less effort to use - each person does not need to sort their friends, a small number of curators can organize the group. More importantly, it is clearer to the user just what is going on. I have been trying to talk to as many non-techie non-early-adopters as possible about Circles, and many get it and love it, but several don't really understand it. In particular, the asymmetry of circles is overlooked by a lot of people, even by some casual users who think they understand how Circles works. On Facebook, there is one authoritative list of who is in the group, and posts to the group stay in that group. On Google+, your circles are not my circles. I may have you in a "close friends" circle, you may have me in a big "co-workers" circle, or you might have all your friends in one circle. When I am browsing my "close friends" feed and see a post by you, I may guess wrong about the social context that you are sharing that message in, and make an inappropriate comment, not realizing who else received the message. (The way to determine on G+ who received a post is by noting and clicking on the gray "Public" or "Limited" in the upper right of the post) Maybe I am underestimating people, or maybe comments are just much less big a deal than posts, but I think this lack of clear social context for individual messages within Circles is going to lead to some serious privacy/sharing accidents. If I had to make a prediction, I'd think that the ease-of-use and clarity of FB Groups will trump the power and flexibility of Circles. I could be wrong, so it'll be interesting to see what ordinary users prefer.
- waterlesscloud 15y agoThere are a number of areas in G+ that seem like they're going to lead to highly-publicized mistakes, and the asymmetry of circles is certainly one of them. You basically have no way to know who can see your comment on a post (outside of the fact that everyone can see it on a "public" post). I also suspect an Weinergate style mis-post of something that was supposed to be private will occur fairly early on. Though to be fair, nothing is as easy to misdirect as a twitter DM.
- DavidSJ 15y agoYou basically have no way to know who can see your comment on a post (outside of the fact that everyone can see it on a "public" post). On private posts, the word "Limited" appears next to the post, on which you can click to see who it's visible to. It's not as obvious as it could be, but it's there.
- kloncks 15y agoI don't mean to distract, but wow. What a gorgeously designed clean website. I meant to read the article - and I did after a while - but the first thing I did was CTRL + U to check out the source code.
- ben1040 15y agoMeanwhile, it's absolutely unusable on my Honeycomb tablet. I would love to finish reading this, but his site design is preventing me from scrolling down to read the rest of the entry.
- kloncks 15y agoHere you go: http://www.ihany.com/article-through-hn-not-mine/ http://www.ihany.com/article-through-hn-not-mine/ (Page not public. Not taking credit. I'll take it down in the morning.)
- ben1040 15y agoThanks a ton!
- possibilistic 15y agoIt's also not rendering correctly in by build of Chromium (11.0.696.71). The interface is slick, but I can't scroll past the bottom margin.
- gojomo 15y agoTotally disagree. No text appeared until I enabled Javascript; even then, in Firefox, the text color/typeface was so faint as to be unreadable. (I was interested enough to try firing it up in Chrome, where the text had better contrast.)
- RK 15y agoI had to select View->No style in Firefox 3.6 just to be able to read all of the text... :(
- Terry_B 15y agoI can see G+ quickly becoming the best way to share links, videos etc amongst friends. The part where G+ becomes your social life like Facebook currently is for many people...I just can't see it.
- est 15y ago> I can see G+ quickly becoming the best way to share links, videos etc amongst friends. And a redundant of them. This is like Friendfeed, where you get reposts from different sources every damn minute.
- g123g 15y agoFinally a well balanced article after a week of non stop hyping of Google+. Google+ is just trying to do what Facebook is already doing with a few new features added to make it distinctive. Nothing really innovative or ground breaking. It is just the early adopter crowd trying to make the masses using Facebook feel inferior for still using it. Regarding the circles concept, if I need to share something with a certain group of my contacts, I will prefer Email or Dropbox rather than putting it on some social network whether it is facebook, google+ or twitter.
- icarus_drowning 15y agoIt is quite obvious that Google+ is far, far from perfect, and I don't think that it is going to make even the smallest dent in facebook's market-share. But that doesn't mean that many of the features that make it distinctive-- including Circles-- aren't a positive step forward. (If anything, if the "defining features" of + serve no other purpose than forcing facebook to integrate similar features, I'd call it a success). Indeed, suggesting that Google+ is simply some sort of "copy" of facebook plus a few new features is a pretty short-sighted view of the service, as the entire model of Google+ is hugely different: instead of viewing one's social graph as one monolithic entity, Google+ views it as a series of graphs that are often intersecting and often entirely different. And that is very useful, especially for people who might want to be able to share things with their coworkers that are entirely different than what they share with their friends. I'm not going to argue with the assertion that a great deal of Google+'s early "success" is simply due to "non stop hyping", rather than the service's actual strengths. But that doesn't mean that the strengths it does possess are somehow frivolous or meaningless. They simply aren't. Simply put: sure, you might be happy sharing with email/dropbox, but a great deal of people would rather that our current social networks had a more granular view of sharing/following/etc. (this includes me). And I hardly think its fair to criticize them the way you have-- it is more than just "the early adopter crowd trying to make the masses using Facebook feel inferior for still using it" (indeed, many of the early adopters have been very critical of the service, even noting when facebook or twitter is superior-- see Jeff Jarvis' comments about how difficult it is to follow live events on G+[1]). It is still far too early to tell whether G+ is a 'facebook killer'-- I strongly suspect that it isn't. But that doesn't mean that unfair poo-pooing of it simply because it is over-hyped is the right response. Both Twitter and facebook could learn a great deal from what Google has done, and I genuinely hope they do. As I said above, if that happens, I for one will consider G+ a rather startling success. [1]:https://plus.google.com/105076678694475690385/posts/JSWreaGrBY9 https://plus.google.com/105076678694475690385/posts/JSWreaGr...
- briandon 15y agoFrom the post: A few years ago, before the CEO cared a whit about social networking or identity, a Google User Experience researcher named Paul Adams created a slide deck called the Real Life Social Network. In a very long and well-illustrated talk, he makes the point that there is an impedence mismatch between what you share on facebook and your interactions in real life. So when you share a photo of yourself doing something crazy at a party, you don't intend for your aunt and uncle, workmates or casual acquaintances to see it. In real life, the crazy party photo you would be showing your friend would be on your phone's screen or (in olden days) it would be a hardcopy photograph. Putting your phone or the hardcopy photo back into your pocket would be the end. The potential for blowback would be limited to whatever could be whipped up by your friend's verbal description of what he'd seen. Whenever you put anything on the Internet, though, there's not really any way to control its spread. Whatever privacy mechanisms a sharing/social site puts in place will be broken by crackers at some point or part of the system will break on its own and leak information. Long before that, though, one of the people you permitted to access the controlled content will simply copy it and share it with other people. Don't put anything online that you wouldn't be comfortable with your grandma or work colleagues/boss reading.
- tbh2347 15y agoIt's not about the technical restrictions, the edge cases. It's about what a user expects when posting, the overall experience when sharing. There will be the occasional embarrassing reshare, but for the most part users will (in theory...) feel more comfortable sharing more sensitive information if they better control who sees it. I found this post on technical vs social privacy interesting: https://plus.google.com/116222833568410151476/posts/QDwkrxrpqXg https://plus.google.com/116222833568410151476/posts/QDwkrxrp...
- billswift 15y agoThe problem is that on the Internet you don't have that control. How and where you post something can influence how it can spread, but nothing can control how it spreads, just ask the RIAA. The problems are mostly caused by people who "feel more comfortable" because they wrongly think they can control it. As many people have said, "If you don't want it to get out, then don't put it on the Internet."
- notarant 15y agoDo we believe in a complete coexistence between Google+ and Facebook? Google+ : Facebook :: Facebook : Twitter Facebook allows some directionality in posting that offers you some assurance. Twitter offers you none. Google+ offers a whole other control. The problem is, I've had to explain the difference between Incoming, Following and more. I think Google needs to be explicit in their comparisons: 1. Circles allow for directional sharing. You can target an album of photos to your family easily, or pics from the bar to your friends just as quickly and safely if you setup your default Family and Friends circles sanely. 2. Incoming shows posts from those who are sharing with you, despite you not having added them to a circle of some sort. This is like Twitter, basically, except for you can also take it a level further and share only with certain people on certain posts, depending on the type. (I think they can extend this with tags and be able to have more focused and detailed sharing patterns between people. 3. By combining the long form and discussion-prone posts of Facebook, with the public conversation space of Twitter... they have a strange mass-forum quality. I'm following Googlers that are posting about all sorts of things. I've commented, and even been added by others (and some who seem to be from Google). I'm not sure Google has clearly articulated all of the ways that their offerings are unique or better. I hope they do, it's so funny, I thought of Picasa as neat, but for others. Today I was given an SD card and asked to copy the photos. This is for a fairly tech illiterate family. I could easily upload to Picasa from my chromebook, and then from Google+ I could share it to my Family circle. I have no doubt that relatives could use this and get value from it. I think with a slight bit more integration, Google will have a wide and fairly smoothly integrated offering, and one that brings value to a diverse set of people. Google+ allows me to share bits of news among my friends quickly, and they want to converse about it in a smaller space that is determined based on post to an automated degree. Imagine if, instead of "adding friends on reddit", you share link on G+ to a select group of people who share those interests. It could be reddit but tags instead of subreddits, if circles or circles+tags are done right. If this is the case, why would I use Facebook, it seems like shouting... like, uh, Twitter. If this usage of Circles is too complicated, why would G+ have a shot?
- notarant 15y agoThe first application for Google, should use link submissions in subredits on reddit, to filter your link submissions to target them to users that subscribe to those subreddits (as to not bore or off put others). Or that filter everyone's links submissions to only include links that appear in a subreddit you subscribe to. It's like tags, but instead inferring link interest from reddit subscriptions.
- samj 15y agoPerhaps Facebook just understand that for a social network to be successful you need to encourage sharing at all costs; Google+'s Circles actively constrain sharing, increase complexity and raise the barrier to entry.
- cbs 15y agoPerhaps Facebook just understand that for a social network to be successful you need to encourage sharing at all costs Unfortunately it also discourages meaningful sharing. My G+ "stream" is already home to discussions and photos the likes of which would never have popped up in my facebook feed.
- foxylad 15y agoSo on the one hand this guy says FB is lean and agile because they use PHP - but produced a less than compelling response to circles. And on the other hand he says Google's "toolchain is not well suited to fast, iterative development and rapid innovation" - but they produced a polished social product from scratch in a remarkably short time. I'm afraid I don't ascribe much value to his analysis. Maybe there's a good reason why he's an ex-wave and ex-plus engineer, and that could explain why I think I hear an axe being ground.
- bonch 15y agoBelieve it or not, it is possible for Facebook to be lean and agile yet produce a less than compelling response to circles. Google's internal process has also been criticized before by other former employees, such as the infamous color survey. Your eagerness to dismiss an account from someone on the inside is a little weird and doesn't refute the points he made.
- code_duck 15y agoI have to agree, I don't find the analysis or the train of thought particularly insightful. It seemed apparent to me that facebook being 'unable to change their core product' meant exactly what he figured out it meant 6 paragraphs later... not that they couldn't do it, technically. Also, does he understand the extent to which Facebook actually uses PHP? "quick, adaptable tools like PHP" ... um... seriously?
- heydenberk 15y agoI stopped reading exactly there.
- alecperkins 15y agoThe way I read it, the author was explaining his expectation that Facebook would beat Google to implementing that model. This then emphasizes his misunderstanding of the point of that quote about building it before others. Even when agile about specific features, the inertia of Facebook's existing core product can be hard to overcome; entirely unsurprising given their huge userbase. Google was effectively starting from scratch. Google has a lot of work to do, but with a mostly blank slate and less inertia to overcome. It's also remarkable how they have used this as an opportunity for improvements across the board, a the very least visually.
- tilt 15y agoWonderful inside-view. With this the "Facebook Browser" makes even more sense. Facebook is probably more scared of being dethroned on the data-gathering (therefore advertising) than losing the social "battle" itself. Well, actually Google is probably scared on the same (money) level.
- bonch 15y agoI think Google+ will be a social network for techie hipsters and other early adopters seeking a Facebook alternative, but the novelty will wear off, and the mainstream will barely notice. Just my initial impression. There isn't a compelling enough reason for Facebook's 750 million users to switch.
- sunchild 15y agoWith social networks, what really matters is how users think they should use the graph. It matters whether it's a personal or professional graph. That's why social networks are "balkanized" across personal/professional lines. I find G+ especially useful in a "semi-professional" use case. G+ is just an extension to gmail that adds some easy ways to organize work groups. For example, a meaningful percentage of my gmail activity is sharing links and info with project teams. It's more intuitive to me to create a circle for each team and post to them via G+ than it is to prepare an ad hoc email to them each time. Also, I'd rather organize that conversation as a private stream with discussion, etc. It avoids clutter in my gmail inbox. I also spend a lot of time chatting and talking on Skype. Now that I can organize group video chat via G+, I can cut Skype out of my workflow. I don't like using the Skype client at all. I realize that solutions to these use cases existed before G+, but G+ provides a unified interface that has a powerful effect on my willingness to organize a graph inside Google. I can see Google+ taking off for enterprise users of Google Apps, once it's released to them.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- haakon 15y agoInteresting post, but it seems strange to me how he properly capitalises company names such as Microsoft and Google, but consistently doesn't capitalise "facebook". Is there some point to this, or is it just stylistic?
- stickfigure 15y agoThis article should be titled: Former Google Engineer Builds Uncrawlable Blog Website
- wccrawford 15y agoI think it's cute that he thought Facebook would suddenly start thinking about people's privacy and that their new big product would address that issue. They've been very clear that they think giving people their privacy by default would kill them. I wish I had the MZ quote on hand that proved that.
- BANANARCHY 15y agoIf you're not paying for it, you're the product.
- mcfunley 15y agoI am a little puzzled at the importance ascribed here to the core idea of G+ Circles, as laid out in the slide deck. Mostly because we designed an identical sharing model and even gave it the same name at Etsy, without having read the deck. (Then we decided that was way too complicated and implemented something significantly simpler, but kept the name.)
- JohnLBevan 15y agoA suggested improvement to circles. . . Have 3 types - personal, group and owned group - defined by a simple editable property. * Personal work as circles do currently - i.e. its your way of organising your own contacts; no one else knows what personal circles you have or who's in them (including the members). * Group is a shared contact list - any member of that group has a copy of it, and has permissions to maintain it as if they'd created it. This would be useful if I wanted a group of people in my sport team / band, since when one of the band already in the group adds someone to this group, everyone in the band can then talk to them; and it's not up to me as the creator to do all the admin. * Owned Group - essentially the same as Group, but with additional security / more like FB's groups. I specify who's in the group and what access they have - i.e. if they're just a member, or if they can also administrate the group. This is more useful for application fan pages, where you want a mailing list of people to contact, but only want a few of the people in the group to be able to add / approve new members. With this model, it would be OK to have an option for non members to request access; then be added once approved. What do you guys think? JB
- JohnLBevan 15y agoOne other thought around circles. It would be cool if some kind of backwards circle functionality could be created. For example, I post a few links to my feed about tech stuff which only a handful of my friends are interested in, so I have two options: 1) post to just my "techies" circle so as not to spam my other friends 2) post to public so that anyone who's interested can see (including people who follow me but whom I haven't circled as I don't know them). The first option excludes my followers, the second spams my friends. I could create another circle of followers and message them and the techies, but that doesn't sit comfortably, especially as I don't know which of my posts caused those people to follow me (perhaps a music video I favourites on youtube caught their eye and now they're getting spammed with HN links). Having some way where I could create circles to publish stories to, but have others subscribe to those would be handy - I then publish to my "tech stuff" circle, and anyone who cares to subscribe to "JohnLBevan.TechStuff" sees it, whilst it's hidden from others (to prevent annoying them - not for security). Again, I'd welcome your thoughts. Cheers, JB
- marknutter 15y agoBest part of the article: Game of Thrones reference. Or maybe I'm just excited for tomorrow..
- mathiasben 15y agoWould it help to have a visual repesentation of how each circle on google plus interactes with the others? A sort of Venn diagram attached to each post, so you could just drag the circles around to set who sees a certain post or reply. Seems some of the confusion on plus is do to the menus used to set which circle you are posting to. I know the first time I used it I didn't get it right away. Seems a visual repesentation of those relationships would clear things up.
- parfe 15y agoFacebook already has circles! Facebook groups is a distinct feature from facebook lists. Facebook lists are the same feature as Google circles. And the only reason you didn't know this already is that you did not care enough to look, so circles cannot be all that much of a killer feature. To utilize "Facebook Circles" first you must put categorize some friends into a list. https://www.facebook.com/friends/edit/ https://www.facebook.com/friends/edit/ Click "Create a List" and drop some friends in. I have restricted permissions for anyone not in a list. A "Good People" list for those that I'll share anything with, and a few others. Now to utilize sharing type some stuff into your status box. Anything, but lets go with "I can have circles too." Now click the lock icon to the bottom right of the status entry widget. It will say "Make this Visible To:" And you see have a text box you can now type your list name into. I type "Goo" and it auto completes "Good People" You can even exclude lists! So you can have a "Friends" list and a "Coworkers" list with people who overlap, but then post status that only go to your "Friends who are not coworkers." The only difference is that google puts the UI in your face, which I like. But saying that Facebook cannot do this is absurd. It's there, you just never cared to look.
- MrJagil 15y ago"The only difference is that google puts the UI in your face," Yeah, and the fact that I don't need step-by-step instructions.
- parfe 15y agoso use http://www.circlehack.com/ http://www.circlehack.com/ The point is that facebook has the ability but chose NOT to deploy it. There isn't some barrier to "Changing their core product" that the blog author seems to think. with code: https://github.com/voloko/facebook-circles https://github.com/voloko/facebook-circles
- bmelton 15y agoSpecifically, the blog author says that they would be able to technically deploy a 'Circles-like' feature very quickly, but that they would choose not to, because it changes the BEHAVIOR of the core product. You're trying to disagree with the author, but you're both saying the same thing. Oddly enough, that is his point.
- gospelwut 15y agoThere really should be a feature (lab) to let circles inherit. Friends > Friends I like > Friends I want to screw
- nl 15y agoFriends > Friends I like > Friends I want to screw | People I don't like but are hot enough to screw if I got the chance
- gospelwut 15y agoThat might warrant an entirely new circle. I suppose it's up to your tastes though.
- JohnLBevan 15y agoPerhaps Google Venn's required?
- sequoia 15y agoDidn't read the article, design was too distracting (mouse wheeling with the mouse over the left side does NOT scroll the page). But check out that scrollbar! ::-webkit-scrollbar { width: 10px; } ::-webkit-scrollbar-thumb { border-radius: 10px; background: #ddd; } Thought it must be JS but it's webkit stuff. Can't decide if silly or nice, but I think it's pretty nice.
- steilpass 15y agoWell I gave it a try. But I am missing something: <html> <head> </head> <style> ::-webkit-scrollbar { width: 10px; } ::-webkit-scrollbar-thumb { border-radius: 10px; background: #ddd; } </style> <body> <div style="background:red; margin-top: 1000px;">hi</div> </body> </html>
- riklomas 15y agoTry adding a background color to your ::-webkit-scrollbar
- cjoh 15y agoThe author seems really angry at Google and clearly wants to demonstrate how much smarter he is in comparison to the rest of the organization. Nearly every sentence is drenched with this sort of stuff: "It hits all the notes that a facebook clone merits, and adds a few points of distinctiveness that are genuinely compelling, sure--but I don't find it all that interesting, personally." ". I listened politely, all the while rolling-my-eyes in secret at their seemingly implausible naivete." "I laughed, disbelieving. Facebook has a hacker culture, they're only a handful of engineers, and they develop with quick, adaptable tools like PHP." This post isn't about Google+ or Facebook. This post is about "Look at me, I'm so much smarter than my old bosses" Something clearly upset him pretty significantly at Google. I'm not sure he's got a clear point of view on this.
- hackinthebochs 15y agoDid you finish reading the article? Towards the end he admits that even he missed the boat. In my opinion all the snark was setting up for the fact that, even though he was so confident he had things figured out, he turned out to be completely wrong. The point is that no one can really predict how this will turn out.
- carbonica 15y agoPersonally, I think you're right, but you sort of take a risk when you go for hyperbolic sarcasm. I'm not sure how much of the first paragraphs he believes; much of it, if he did, somewhat discredits him in my eyes as an engineer (let alone as an unbiased source). The takeaway certainly doesn't depend on whether the preceding paragraphs are gospel truth, but one's judgement of the author's credibility, in my opinion, does.
- nfarina 15y agoTotally agree. His begrudging "It's ok, I guess" conclusion doesn't make the rest of it any more insightful. It's all the worst sort of locker-room gossip.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- mark_l_watson 15y agoWow, great content on his site! I ended up reading every one of his blog posts today while I was waiting for builds, etc. Also, I am going to do a careful read-through of his crosstalk code when I have a free hour or two - looks very interesting.
- nvictor 15y agohow the hell did he get that scrollbar?