4 ms·
Do you trust the central planners to plan better than participants with a vested interest in the outcome? In general, I’m deeply skeptical that central plannin
by sokoloff 5y ago
Do you trust the central planners to plan better than participants with a vested interest in the outcome?
In general, I’m deeply skeptical that central planning and government “picking winners” would achieve an overall benefit. At a minimum, it does not appear to have a strong record so far.
- jhoechtl 5y agoGreed is a miserable planner.
- zthrowaway 5y agoIt is the best so far. Show me one that works better on a large scale. The economy makes up of billions of transactions that are not planned but are there to fulfill greed, each in their separate ways end up acting as a choreographed system that the central planners could never replicate.
- dcow 5y agoThe naive solution I had in mind isn’t a centrally planned economy. It’s some type of addition to the concept of a market to deter volatility in specifically commodities markets where volatility is often disruptive and potentially catastrophic. I don’t trust a gov’t to centrally plan an economy, thats for sure, but I do believe society could iterate and improve on the way it applies markets to solve various problems.
- uhhhhhhhhhhhhhh 5y agoMarketBuffer was leaking resources and was foundationally unsalvagable; it has been deprecated and future implementations of societies are advised to manage their resources via unique_enterprise and shared_enterprise.
- nitrogen 5y agoThere is a vast space of possibilities between (and orthogonal to!) the line between "unregulated market" and "centrally managed economy." Just because someone says "this didn't work" doesn't mean they would say "let's do 100% the opposite." Surely, in this case, there are better ways to smooth out these spikes and dips in flows than just letting the price go sky high so that only the rich can build or repair housing for a year or two.
- CheezeIt 5y agoYou could have some kind of entity that buys up supplies when the price is low and sells when the price is high. In fact, it’s legal for you to create one today, and if you operate it successfully, you’d make a lot of money.
- ddxxdd 5y agoKeep in mind that public opinion is turning against these "speculators" that you describe. Blackrock Investment is doing everything you describe, but for housing. They are being heavily derided by the media for doing so.
- sumedh 5y ago> You could have some kind of entity that buys up supplies when the price is low How do you know the price is low and to start buying or wait because the price might fall down more?
- 8note 5y agoYou'd also be subject to inventory tax on your stored stuff no? The government wants to make sure things are moving in the government, not sitting around
- aaron-santos 5y agoCentral planning has a great track record in corporate governance. Walmart employees 2.3 million people and as far as I know is centrally planned. Central planning can at least scale up that far. Sixteen states have a population less than that. I don't see any indication that scale is holding Walmart back.