3 ms·
“ They're just a free-standing, self-consistent logical structure that can't be justified in any way except by claiming that it justifies itself. It's not that
by mensetmanusman 5y ago
“ They're just a free-standing, self-consistent logical structure that can't be justified in any way except by claiming that it justifies itself. It's not that Aquinas didn't use reasoning; as noted above, he did--lots of it.”
Interestingly, this also describes all of math, logic, and philosophy.
One of the more interesting axioms or assertions is whether there exists free will, which is, by any interesting definition, a supernatural entity.
- guntars 5y ago> Interestingly, this also describes all of math, logic, and philosophy. Which is totally fine, as long as people accept that God exists the same way math exists.
- mensetmanusman 5y agoYes, and ancient Christians asserted that God is love. Many do accept that love exists in the same way math exists.
- ttfkam 5y agoOmnipotent. Omniscient. Omnibenevolent. Like the CAP theorem, you can only have two without substantial compromise.
- mensetmanusman 5y agoCompromise depends on the understanding of the hierarchy. When ancient texts list God as Love, they note that Love is an act of (free) will (free will being considered a supernatural entity, even today). Free will is placed high on the hierarchy, which has interesting consequences. E.g. humans are free to do horrible things, and are free to choose not to love. If humans had no free will and were all instinct, there would be no love.
- ttfkam 5y agoSo you're saying there's evil and suffering in the world, but God can't prevent it because he created free will? Sounds like a limit on his omnipotence. Your explanation makes it out that free will is inherently prone to evil and suffering. If so, that would make free will somewhat inherently evil even though it arises from God. Strikes at the heart of omnibenevolence. Either there's a limit to his ability or a limit to his goodness. No amount of hand waving can remove that. If He is all good but can create creatures that corrupt his good works… You see the logical conundrum there, right? I would understand if you don't WANT to see it. It feels wrong to see it. But it's there if you're being honest. You can ignore it. Many do. It's still there despite any aversion to it.
- pdonis 5y ago> free will, which is, by any interesting definition, a supernatural entity How so? I can think of at least one interesting definition by which free will is a perfectly good physical process going on in human brains, not supernatural at all.
- orestarod 5y agoFree will implies non determinism, that is the important part.
- pdonis 5y ago> Free will implies non determinism Depends on which definition of free will you are using. Some definitions are compatible with determinism. Also, even if we go with a non-deterministic definition of free will, "non-deterministic" is not the same as "supernatural". Quantum mechanics is not deterministic.
- Haiatu 5y agoThats not true for math / science. Math is based on fundamental global laws which exist and can be checked from everyone and they can come up all with the same math. We could isolate a baby and it could create the same math while it couldn't create the same religion.
- mensetmanusman 5y agoMath is based on human chosen axioms. Actually, there are a lot of different sub fields of math that have different subsets of axioms to solve different types of problems. The axioms can never be proven though, they are just grounding. Isolating a human is analogous to removing oxygen. Few would argue that someone brain dead could create anything.
- Haiatu 5y agoI'm really not sure how you can missread my example to come up with 'isoalting a human is analogous to removing oxygen'. My comparison is based on sciencse vs. fiction. 1+1 = 2 is a reality which works in german, africa, usa and everywhere else. There might be a difference on how those symbols (1, 2...) look like but the axiom is true and valid and is discoverable. In religion its not. Concept of god exists but it looks different depending on your believe. Multiply gods, one god, good god, bad god... Even the stuff written down is based on someone who wrote it down and still people interpretate it totally different. Never seen someone implying they are right that 1+1=3 if the interpretation of 3 is not 'next after one'.
- mahogany 5y ago1+1=2 is not really an axiom. There's a set of axioms that lead to that. They are even more primordial statements like "1 is a number" and "x=x" and "all numbers n have a successor number S(n) such that m=n if and only if S(m)=S(n)". Even if it seems clear (to most of us, at least) that these axioms represent some part of reality, they are still human-chosen -- and they have to be agreed upon. At some point, nearly everyone would have agreed that Euclid's 5th postulate was obviously true, and anyone alive could verify this for themself. Well, sometimes it's "true" and sometimes it isn't. That said, the Peano axioms seem less nebulous that the varying axioms relating to the existence of god, as that concept can change so much from person to person.
- mgh2 5y agoThe case for the existence of free will can be analyzed from several bodies of evidence (it is a bias) https://m-g-h.medium.com/free-will-a-rich-fairy-tale-4fecf8095812 https://m-g-h.medium.com/free-will-a-rich-fairy-tale-4fecf80...