3 ms·
Your views remind me of this article I read a while back: https://thefederalist.com/2019/10/18/gender-studies-professor-calls-twerking-with-lizzo-an-act-of-pol
by dangus 5y ago
Your views remind me of this article I read a while back:
https://thefederalist.com/2019/10/18/gender-studies-professor-calls-twerking-with-lizzo-an-act-of-political-defiance/ https://thefederalist.com/2019/10/18/gender-studies-professo...
I find the concept of pleasure oppression to be interesting. Essentially, the idea is that puritanical roots teach us that things that are pleasurable must be sinful and wrong, and that the oppression is felt most strongly by marginalized groups.
Your positive manifestation of the simple life is living like the Amish. What you’ve omitted is the fact that the Amish/Mennonite societies run as authoritarian patriarchies, where the bishop figure and head of household (the husband) have the final word.
I think there is a misconception that religious people have about the non-religious where they assume non-religious people are living a life of consumerism and materialism in lieu of God.
Ultimately, those concepts aren’t related: believing in a particular brand of God isn’t a prerequisite to helping one another and living a life of service to others. The non-religious just don’t accept biblical stories as fact, and they might believe that any sort of afterlife is not a realistic expectation.
The religious and non-religious alike live within a wide spectrum of materialism. There are certainly materialistic Christians and materialistic atheists, but there are also the opposite.
Locking yourself in a self-imposed religious prison for 30 years is on the extreme end of the spectrum. The reason it’s a news article is because it’s an incredibly rare, strange thing to do. In my opinion, this reputation of strangeness is rightfully deserved.
- agomez314 5y agoI think you're misunderstanding and reading too much from my argument. The thrust of it is that I sincerely believe modern society (by which I mean Western, US culture 2020s) places a heavy emphasis on consumption and reaping of pleasure as much as possible and that this culture is oppressive and coerces people to do the same lest they be labeled "old-fashioned, cultist" or worse, "religious" (which in itself carries a bad connotation nowadays). The fact that the story is strange to you goes straight to my point. Throughout history, monks, wisemen and religious figures have retreated from the world to seek spiritual peace. There's extensive literature and history that shows this to be valid path for a person to take, if they so wish and are in the disposition to do so.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- dangus 5y agoFrankly, I read into your comment as much as I did because it came across as not-so-subtle preaching.