4 ms·
Many IRC networks have had drama. But does anyone know the motivation for recent actions by Freenode? I'm discounting conspiracy theories (e.g., flipping, sab
by neilv 5y ago
Many IRC networks have had drama.
But does anyone know the motivation for recent actions by Freenode?
I'm discounting conspiracy theories (e.g., flipping, sabotage) because I think anyone acting strategically wrt IRC knows that forking an IRC network has been part of the standard toolkit for responding to "damage", since almost the start.
I'm starting to lean towards a theory of there being no longer being a business reason nor ideological reason to Freenode's recent actions. At least not after the first few days.
- progval 5y agoThere is some speculation about the motivations here: https://ariadne.space/2021/05/20/the-whole-freenode-kerfluffle/ https://ariadne.space/2021/05/20/the-whole-freenode-kerfluff...
- neilv 5y agoI don't know these particular people, but, absolutely, many people grew up with IRC and similar earlier online social forums as a refuge from trauma, or to find community or acceptance. (That started in the age of https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/On_the_Internet,_nobody_knows_you%27re_a_dog https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/On_the_Internet,_nobody_knows_... , before more conventional social dynamics took over the 'Net.) If that theory is correct, I'd guess there's a good path to something that everyone feels better about. But it might involve Freenode being turned over to a nonprofit. I think many traditional users wouldn't go back, but the right nonprofit might find a way to pivot to new service to the world. In the credible nonprofit scenario, the value of the Freenode brand now might be of the flavor: we made mistakes, learned dearly, came out much stronger.
- manabi 5y agoI doubt any nonprofit credible enough is going to risk damaging their reputation by taking on Freenode after what Lee's done with it. Nearly everyone's already moved to Libera & OFTC, people aren't going to want to move back after all that work, and well, frankly, Freenode's very name is toxic now. Also, I doubt Lee would ever give up control, because it's clear controlling the network is what he wanted all along.
- jeltz 5y agoMy personal theory is that rasengan had a boyhood dream of running his own IRC network. A dream he tried to realize by buying Freenode. The actual purchase happened under very dubious circumstances which (plus some other disagreements in the Freenode team) led to the creation of Libera. This just rasengan lashing out when they broke his toy.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- geofft 5y agoAndrew Lee also claims to be the Crown Prince of Korea - because he claims to be distantly related to a very old king, contacted one of the aging claimants to the throne who has no male children, and organized a "ceremony" with him in a Vietnamese restaurant in Beverly Hills. I think if you want to form a theory of mind re his Freenode actions, you'd be well informed by forming a theory of mind re his Korea actions. Obviously part of it is the monarchist philosophy, the idea that an autocratic government over Korea with no input from the people is somehow worth something. Even in the case of the North, you couldn't call the restoration of the monarchy an improvement. And even in monarchism in general, there's still a vague idea of government by at least a little bit of consent from at least a few of the governed, from the Glorious Revolution to the concept of the Mandate of Heaven. The so-called crown prince has none of that. But more interestingly, Lee thinks something happened at that dinner to make him crown prince. The claim to the throne by the scion in question is already disputed, and it's far from clear that he had the power, according to the old royal rules, to make some random person who happens to have the same last name his heir. And if he does, it would be via adoption, not via a "Passing of the Sword Ceremony" and a seafood entree. There's no evidence that Lee has once participated in the yearly cultural ceremonies in Korea that honor the late royalty and still to this day involve members of the former royal house - the other claimant to the throne does that. If you're not going to stick by the very practical rule that the legitimate ruler is the person physically on the throne, you at least need to stick by the rules of the royal house about legitimacy, and he's done neither. I believe he approaches Freenode in the same way. He genuinely believes that it is possible and reasonable to transfer control of Freenode without the involvement or consent of Freenode's users and that the good users will stay loyal to the name "Freenode," instead of to the intangible community. So he didn't even anticipate the possibility that the staff would set up their own network and manage to move almost all of the community over. He also believes that all that needs to happen is to contact one person who has a bit of a claim to Freenode and arrange for DNS to be transferred, and everything will work itself out. What we're seeing is him operating as if everything will soon work itself out, once he deals with a few small problems. Once people forget about Libera, once the uncooperative channel ops "spamming" suggestions to try Libera are removed, once #python is turned from a channel run by the PSF to a channel with Python enthusiasts, etc., Freenode will eventually emerge as the home of FOSS, like it's always been, and he'll be on the throne.
- manabi 5y agoI believe everything we're seeing Lee do is because he's a narcissist[1] and is simply incapable of accepting failure. I read an article[2] recently on how a narcissist handles failure and it fits this situation perfectly. Just some of the steps (it's a long article): ▣ Insist everything is fine, claim any evidence otherwise is false. ▣ Attack not only the evidence, but anyone presenting it. ▣ Find someone to blame for their troubles (in this case Libera). ▣ Never take responsibility, EVER, it's always someone's else fault. ▣ Lies increase and are repeatedly exponentially. ▣ If it appears the narcissist is going to be brought down, they will start lashing out to make others suffer. They will NOT go down alone. ▣ As the end nears, the suffering of others becomes paramount. IRC was important to Lee growing up as jeltz noted. So he obtained control over Freenode because it was the largest IRC network in the world, and owning it made him feel good. But eventually, because he's a narcissist, he wasn't satisfied merely owning it, he wanted to run it. He probably felt only he knew best how to do so, because he's a narcissist. That started the failure and it's all been downhill ever since, because he can't accept that failure. If I'm correct, it's going to get much worse, and much uglier, in the weeks and months to come. Lee's going to start attacking his current toadies and enablers as well, and doing more and more things to cause suffering to anyone he feels is remotely connected to the "appearance" of him failing. (Because remember, he's incapable of admitting he failed.) [1] In particular Malignant Narcissist Personality Disorder, an actual mental health disorder, not just someone who likes themselves a bit too much. [2] https://www.psychologytoday.com/us/blog/spycatcher/202007/when-the-narcissist-fails https://www.psychologytoday.com/us/blog/spycatcher/202007/wh...