3 ms·
I think we will never know what the reasoning behind the two bombs really was. I could imagine that after using large scale carpet and fire bombing against civi
by hef19898 5y ago
I think we will never know what the reasoning behind the two bombs really was. I could imagine that after using large scale carpet and fire bombing against civilian targets, a nuclear bomb with a similar effect doesn't make much of a difference.
- redis_mlc 5y agoWe know exactly: - 5 Japanese cities were set aside from B-29 carpet bombing for possible nuclear bombing - US generals debated whether using these bombs was immoral or not. They were on the fence. - Truman's civil administrator pushed for using them - 2 were dropped. I believe 3-ship formations were used: bomber, meteorology plane, photo plane. A customized Lancaster wing was initially created, but Americans preferred to use their own B-29. You are correct that it didn't matter whether an atomic bomb or 1000 bombers with napalm were sent. Also, "civilian targets" is incorrect - Hiroshima was a naval base, and also built submarines or torpedos. This was downplayed by peaceniks for several decades, but it turned out that Hiroshima was a military target. There's even an interview with a worker from one of the military factories online. The Japanese military's goal after Midway was to win a crushing defeat over the US in a battle, so that there could be a favorable peace treaty with the US. That's one of the reasons for their refusal to surrender.