20 ms·
Could face and voice recognition become the new 'phrenology'?
- UnknownEmpire 5y agoMetadata phrenology has been around for a long time
- gentleman11 5y agoFor anyone else not sure what phrenology is, the article says: > In the early 19th century, some scientists became convinced that they could predict someone's personality and behaviour based simply on the shape of their head. > Known as phrenology, this pseudo-science accelerated notions of racism, intellectual superiority, and caused many to suffer just because of what they looked like—some people were even imprisoned because the contours of their skulls suggested "criminality."
- spywaregorilla 5y agoThe problem with phrenology as a policy-making tool isn't that it's largely bullshit (though it was), but that it was, on its principles, unfair. The same is here with this tech. Accuracy isn't the issue, even if this one's also largely pseudo science.
- version_five 5y agoYes, exactly! Accurate or not, its completely unfair to generalize about people in relation to anything nontrivial.
- josephcsible 5y agoI'd use a slightly different metric for unfairness: it's unfair to use factors that people have no control over to make predictions about things that they do have control over.
- fighterpilot 5y agoIf we're running airport security - putting aside the security theatre aspect - do we really want to search a 90 year old female pensioner as often as a 21 year old man, when the former is significantly (as in, 100x thereabouts) less likely to pose a threat to a flight? Isn't that just a waste of resources? Or consider health insurance. Do we really want young people paying the same premiums as 80 year olds? Perhaps you think there's a negative societal byproduct of making a certain group of people feel marginalized/targeted. Does wanting to reduce this justify clear resource wastage, such as in the airport security example above?
- magicalist 5y ago> putting aside the security theatre aspect > Does wanting to reduce this justify clear resource wastage, such as in the airport security example above? Hold on, your argument can't put aside the "security theatre aspect" while also using it as justification for policies. If it really is theatre, this wouldn't be doing anything more effectively except getting more people invested in the show going on.
- fighterpilot 5y agoI should've said "to the extent that it isn't security theatre"
- sudosysgen 5y agoNow your argument hinges on it not being security theater. You have to make the case that airport security is so vital and effective that we need to profile people to get that slight edge.
- josephcsible 5y ago> do we really want to search a 90 year old female pensioner as often as a 21 year old man, when the former is significantly (as in, 100x thereabouts) less likely to pose a threat to a flight? Terrorist organizations aren't stupid, and they have members of all ages. If we made it our policy not to search 90-year-olds anymore, then they'd suddenly end up committing most of the attacks on flights. > Or consider health insurance. Do we really want young people paying the same premiums as 80 year olds? In this example, what are you saying that the 80-year-olds have control over?
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- quotemstr 5y agoSuppose we lived in an alternate universe where personality characteristics could be inferred (with statistical confidence) from skull bumps (i.e. a world where phrenology worked): in such a world, you could argue that it would be unfair to disadvantage an individual based on his specific skull bumps. Those bumps aren't dispositive in individual cases. At the same time, it'd be wrong (again, in our pretend universe) to ban noticing the statistical connection between skull bump and personality, because that'd just be a fact about how our alternate universe worked, and censoring facts is always wrong. Back in our world: I don't believe in demonizing technologies because of what people might do with them. Facial recognition works, at least for identification of individuals. I cannot get on board with mandating denial of this fact for the sake of fear of bad policy based on this fact. It never, ever, under any circumstances whatsoever acceptable to ban people noticing true facts about how the world works.
- TchoBeer 5y agoWe wouldn't ban noticing the statistical connection, but we might ban using it in court cases and hiring decisions.
- spywaregorilla 5y ago> I don't believe in demonizing technologies because of what people might do with them. What about demonizing technologies because of what people do with them, all the time, in positions of power? > Facial recognition works, at least for identification of individuals. I cannot get on board with mandating denial of this fact for the sake of fear of bad policy based on this fact. That's not really what this article is about, the article is just poorly titled. > It never, ever, under any circumstances whatsoever acceptable to ban people noticing true facts about how the world works. That's fine. In this case you should have no issue that I've noticed people who say stuff like this tend to harbor supremacist ideals.
- prvc 5y agoThe first portion of the audio (comprising all I heard) is just some guy kvetching about Alexa to a clueless but still pompous interviewer. As for "biometrics", per sei, it seems to be a marginally small addition to all the other information channels that are available to the surveillance industry. Not momentous in and of itself, and the concern seems to stem from questionable categorical distinctions (e.g. what you say vs. how you say it; wrong for others to consider the latter, not the former). And, regarding phrenology: its previous incarnation was discredited as a pseudoscience on the basis of its vagueness and potential inaccuracy. Now that it can be implemented using deep learning, its predictions' accuracy quantified and vetted empirically, that criticism no longer applies.
- jamal-kumar 5y agoI had clearview AI try to hire me when nobody in the wider public knew about them and that was pretty much how I felt about it at the time when I turned that offer down. I'm glad to see it being talked about now. I like to call it inspector gadgetarianism. Cops LOVE this shit. They do all sorts of practices like denying that you can easily pass lie detection testing, penile plesmography (like if they want to determine a potential recruit is a pervert they hook their meat up to this machine and show them shit like dudes copulating with chickens), and that time the us military got those ridiculous fake bomb detectors that did literally nothing. It's a miscarriage of justice but that's what you get when you have an organization that does stuff like not even letting you in if they think you're too smart https://abcnews.go.com/US/court-oks-barring-high-iqs-cops/story?id=95836 https://abcnews.go.com/US/court-oks-barring-high-iqs-cops/st...
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- DonHopkins 5y agoApparently they have seat pads for lie detectors to detect anal clenching, a technique for fooling lie detectors. https://lafayettepolygraph.com/products/seat-activity-sensor-lx4000 https://lafayettepolygraph.com/products/seat-activity-sensor... >Activity Sensor Seat Pad for LX4000, Model 76879S. Price: $ 475.00* https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20312004 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20312004 >Does the technique of clenching your butt hole actually work to beat a polygraph? (As described in my favorite "The Americans" season 2 episode 7, "Arpanet".) Does it also help to visualize someone you love at the same time? ;) If it actually works, the photo of Charles Wayne Humble in the article looks like he could lie through his teeth while passing a polygraph exam with flying colors! https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Arpanet_(The_Americans) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Arpanet_(The_Americans) After consulting with Arkady and Oleg, and with the promise of coaching from Oleg, Nina tells Stan that she will take the FBI's polygraph test. Oleg suggests a few techniques including that she visualize him in the room as well as clenching her anus. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=s3OMSMq9zPA https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=s3OMSMq9zPA The Americans Season 2 Episode 7 "Arpanet" Review: "I like when I learn something from an episode, and now I know ..." "If you're having to do a polygraph, squeeze your anus." https://tv.avclub.com/the-americans-arpanet-1798180091 https://tv.avclub.com/the-americans-arpanet-1798180091 (One of the ways to beat a polygraph turns out to be clenching one’s anus. This show is full of helpful hints.) >https://www.esquire.com/entertainment/tv/a28316/spy-on-the-americans/ https://www.esquire.com/entertainment/tv/a28316/spy-on-the-a... >ESQ: The show featured Nina learning to beat and eventually beating a polygraph. How easy is it to do that? >PE: We have a number of real-world instances. The Aldrich Ames case. He went through the polygraph twice, after he went to work for the Soviets. Administering a polygraph is an art, not a science. That's why it's not admitted in court. People have claimed to have had training to beat the polygraph. Everything from tightening your sphincter to breathing a certain way, and so forth. >ESQ: Speaking of sphincters, the trick she's told is "squeeze your anus." Is that a thing? >PE: I can't confirm. [Laughs] I took several polygraphs. Taking them is a standard thing in the intelligence life. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20311928 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20311928 >Or if you deliberately clench your anal sphincter, that's enough to change results. And yes, that actually works; that's why some lie detectors now feature ass-clenching detention technology.
- wumpus 5y agoI have a friend who's terrified of this new phrenology. She's missing some muscles in her face, such that she blinks weirdly. She can only mostly close her eyes, thanks to an operation in her childhood that took a muscle from her butt and placed it diagonally on her forehead. At best, her blinks are asymmetrical. At night, she has to sleep with dark cloth over her eyes because she can never fully close them. Her terror revolves around being profiled as being overly nervous at airports. Of course, that worry makes her actually nervous at airports.
- Permit 5y agoThis article is talking about two very different things: 1. Using video/audio of a person to make statements about their personality. 2. Using video/audio of a person to identify them. The former seems as though it’s largely pseudoscience and should be avoided on the basis that it simply does not work. The latter may be innaccurate, biased and problematic but it does not seem to qualify as pseudoscience. I would imagine such systems will continue to improve in accuracy. Do others really consider facial recognition and voice recognition (as the title suggests) to be like phrenology?
- wumpus 5y agoYou might want to check out the bit in the article mentioning the study that claimed you could figure out a person's sexual orientation from their photo. There are also many well-known algorithms that attempt to predict how nervous or angry a person is from a photo. Edit: as for criticisms of image recognition systems themselves, they have different false positive rates for different skin colors.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- akiselev 5y ago> Do others really consider facial recognition and voice recognition (as the title suggests) to be like phrenology? I won't jump to that conclusion but I'm skeptical. Phrenology seemed like it worked (to some) until real rigor and statistically significant sample sizes put it to rest. I suspect that may happen to facial and voice recognition too - if limited to a small, known group size or heavily controlled circumstances it works well, but the second you apply it to nontrivial real world populations over time it loses most of its predictive power. Obviously even in limited applications the technology is far more useful than phrenology ever was, just going by the number of people using Face ID. At the end of the day, the predictions facial/voice recognition algorithms make are far more specific and obviously testable than phrenology ever was, but we don't even have conclusive evidence that humans can precisely identify individuals using only sight or sound without a mental context that would approach a general AI. Even parents, for example, can have trouble differentiating identical twins without contextual clues like personality traits, schedule, or preferred fashion.
- ineedasername 5y agoThey don't actually mention any company using this for personality assessment. That would be a useful detail to include. They mention Clearview AI, but only in the context of facial recognition, not personality.
- pdkl95 5y agohttps://www.voiceofsandiego.org/topics/education/college-students-are-learning-hard-lessons-about-anti-cheating-software/ https://www.voiceofsandiego.org/topics/education/college-stu... > At the self-described “heart” of the company’s monitoring software is Monitor AI, a “powerful artificial intelligence engine” that collects facial detection data [...] to identify “patterns and anomalies associated with cheating.” > "... people who have some sort of facial disfigurement have special challenges; they might get flagged because their face has an unexpected geometry.” This is literally phrenology with a bunch of linear algebra instead of calipers.
- unishark 5y agoMy guess is they're trying to classify behaviors like glancing off in some direction repeatedly to look at a cheat sheet or a phone, the same things human proctors watch for. Presumably the system can fail to accurately estimate the gaze direction for some people because they are too different from the design assumptions made. i don't really think that's the same as phrenology. It's more akin to BMI being a poor estimate of obesity for bodybuilders.
- ineedasername 5y agoWow that's awful. There might be some very general common characteristics of body language and facial movements the very roughly correlate to certain general situations. (Panic comes to mind) but those are still going to vary incredibly widely over the population based on so many factors, not the least of which are culture, peer groups, and general personal quirks. A person with a history of panic attacks, for example, may have learned to cope well enough not to completely lose it in a meeting at work. The list of other examples would be endless. And how do you get a reliable data set for this to begin with? Most schools allow for a formal appeal or inquiry process precisely because anything but very blatant cheating can be a murky area. Even if you had videos and a tagged set of the outcomes of inquiries like that, you still wouldn't have intercoder ratings for reliability and therefore an no verified data set. I know some methods that can be used against untagged data, but at the very least you actually have to know if there was cheating or not. And talk about black box-- this isn't even something that human review of specific incidents could validate. If a human couldn't reliably come to the correct conclusion based on available data, an AI using pattern matching with a questionable data set sure won't. When the article mentioned companies using it I figured it was just early stages of testing it. Or used for some low stakes marketing/advertisement targeting. That would still be bad, but this is world's worse. Life ruining worse.
- jdonaldson 5y agoCould divisive click bait titles become the new journalism?
- wmf 5y agoAlways has been.
- tlrobinson 5y agoBetteridge's law of headlines: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Betteridge%27s_law_of_headlines https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Betteridge%27s_law_of_headli...
- microdrum 5y agoFacial recognition works pretty well, as anyone who works in the field can tell you. So it's already different from phrenology. It's even more different from prenology in that facial and voice recognition are search and surveying tools, not conclusion or judgement tools.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- catlifeonmars 5y agoI’m struggling a bit with the layout of the arguments in this article. In particular, it seems to conflate several related, but different things. - Face/voice recognition, which is just statistical modeling and threshold testing at the end of the day. - (Mis)use of face/voice recognition to test for things that these technologies aren’t going to accurately measure - Equating the former to phrenology, when it’s a more accurate of an analogy to equate the latter to phrenology. Overall, I agree with the basic premise that face/voice recognition being misused to apply prejudice is a valid concern.
- mikeiz404 5y ago>"However, he warns that attempts to assess someone's personality from their voice—or even their facial expressions—is fraught with ethical and accuracy issues. "Even though there are physiological signals, it's quite possible that the way we interpret them is very culturally biased," he said." A relevant article on this which talks about some of the evidence for cultural specific interpretations balanced against existing evidence for their universality: Do Feelings Look the Same in Every Human Face? (https://greatergood.berkeley.edu/article/item/do_feelings_look_the_same_in_every_human_face https://greatergood.berkeley.edu/article/item/do_feelings_lo...) Some additional sources as well: - Misinterpretation of facial expression: a cross-cultural study (https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/10201283/ https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/10201283/) - Perception of Facial Expressions Differs Across Cultures (https://www.apa.org/news/press/releases/2011/09/facial-expressions https://www.apa.org/news/press/releases/2011/09/facial-expre...) - Are Facial Expressions the Same Around the World? (https://greatergood.berkeley.edu/article/item/are_facial_expressions_the_same_around_the_world https://greatergood.berkeley.edu/article/item/are_facial_exp...)
- stuntkite 5y agoA decade ago I left a startup I helped found that did deposition video editing because (among other things) our timestamp provider was offering micro tremor stress (lie) detection in their API and people were VERY interested in using it. Even if you buy into that bullshit, in this instance the source audio was 32kbps mono. There was nothing keeping us from underlying text red, yellow, and green. It wouldn't be admissible as evidence (like a polygraph) but you best believe that shit would be used for awful shit. I left, they never did that, but I bet it's going on somewhere. I get the desire for tools like this, but it's really just a way around doing better work to determine factors. The only thing it's really for is coercion.
- bitwize 5y agoYes, especially since "AI" is the new Paracelsan alchemy.