3 ms·
I think the real issue is laid out at the end >"If matters of good and evil are not to be resolved by an omniscient God in the future, then Americans will judg
by Barrin92 5y ago
I think the real issue is laid out at the end
>"If matters of good and evil are not to be resolved by an omniscient God in the future, then Americans will judge and render punishment now. We are a nation of believers. If only Americans could begin believing in politics less fervently, realizing instead that life is elsewhere. But this would come at a cost—because to believe in politics also means believing we can, and probably should, be better"
I think the author is part of a group of largely public intellectuals in the US who have subscribed to the theory of "religion is the opium of the people, but that's a good thing".
Yes, the loss of religion does away with a glue that in some sense kept a sort of false peace intact. Injustices can no longer be explained away with metaphysical explanations, superficial alliances under the banner of faith cannot be maintained. The people who stand to lose from this are the kind of people who write these op-eds. People who benefit from delaying conflict. The people who stand to benefit from the loss of religion are the people who need some justice in this world, not in the next one.
- snypox 5y agoI don't know if you saw it, but Sam Harris, Jordan Peterson and Douglas Murray had a debate about this topic a few years ago: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aALsFhZKg-Q https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aALsFhZKg-Q TLDW: we don't know if Peterson is religious or not but he thinks that Christianity must stay. Harris (obviously) is an atheist and thinks religions must go. Now, Douglas is interesting. He's an atheist but thinks that Christianity must stay because much-much worse ideologies would take its place. Peterson and Douglas like to prove their point by pointing to existing ideologies that are already very dangerous. Personally, I don't have any argument to offer. Since seeing this debate, I thought about this topic a lot but I still didn't come to a conclusion.
- me_me_me 5y ago> Christianity must stay because much-much worse ideologies would take its place That is one terrifying statement. And I think I changed my mind about christianity being gone would make for a better world. if qanon is anything but a sample taste of possible future I sure hope christianity stays.
- krapp 5y ago>if qanon is anything but a sample taste of possible future I sure hope christianity stays. Ah... QAnon is mostly an amalgamation of beliefs already commonly held by the extremist fringe of Evangelical Christianity and other right-wing Christian sects, and is based on a Christian apocalyptic worldview. It exists to play on Christian fears of the temporal, secular world being run by vast Satanic conspiracies arrayed against them. It couldn't exist in a world without Christianity.
- me_me_me 5y agoIf anything its a proof that people will believe in anything that suits their narrative. Especially if its random gibberish that can be interpreted anyway you want.
- AndrewKemendo 5y agoThe question for me is: Is a mutually shared narrative required for a society to maintain cohesion and engagement at scale? If the assumption is "yes" then the challenge becomes whether the narrative is actually epistemologically solid enough to bear scrutiny from all angles - something I don't actually believe exists. I think in the US the narrative since the Colonies formed, has been something like "Land of Opportunity" which a healthy proportion of the US and world doesn't believe in, and realistically only some segment of the world population did believe in for a short period after WWII.
- em-bee 5y agoif we want to maintain cohesion and engagement, we must have something that binds us together. current and past mainstream religions are not capable of achieving this. they were not meant to. they did achieve it for the society at the time they were founded, but the world has moved on and religions stagnated. and it's not just society at a national level. we live in a global society. our interconnections worldwide are to deep to be able to separate societies by nation. a religion today must be capable of creating cohesion and engagement on a global scale. it must bear scrutiny from all angles indeed, from every corner of this planet. if we can't find a religion that is capable of achieving this, then indeed we may be better off without any religion.