4 ms·
The argument is not that the science is same as religion. The argument is that individuals dont rationally objectively verify or figure out every experiment an
by watwut 5y ago
The argument is not that the science is same as religion.
The argument is that individuals dont rationally objectively verify or figure out every experiment and scientific claim. I stead, we all rely on trust to institutions and processes to tell us how it is.
Which is how it is. Most people dont even know how science actually work beyond elementary school level of simplification. And even if you actually do science as a job, you know only small part of it relying on trust everywhere else.
- j4yav 5y agoYes, and my response is that the average person doesn’t rationally need to intellectually revalidate every scientific and technological fact from first principles because we are surrounded by overwhelming evidence, and that highlighting that not everyone has done that is not actually all that clever or relevant if you think about it. No faith in shadowy institutions is required to see the facts of technological and scientific progress all around me.
- foolinaround 5y agothe person of faith would also counter you with 'overwhelming evidence' of what God is doing for him... sometimes, this evidence is just subjective, at other times, it is clear and can be measured. Another analogy that I have heard is that 'magic' is when one is just wowed by what they see without being able to understand how it happens. Apple products bring that 'magic' though it can all be explained away in technical terms if one tried.
- j4yav 5y agoWhat is the (sometimes) clear and measurable evidence of what god has done for someone?
- mensetmanusman 5y agoFor some, it is clear that this brief moment of consciousness is an amazing gift. Soon our bodies will go back to the dust that we began as:)
- j4yav 5y agoI agree, but how do you measure that though? Or prove that it isn’t an incredible thing regardless of if it was given to you by god?
- mensetmanusman 5y agoWell, things I think about: -this ‘Universe’ (seems to me) is so incredibly intelligible and information rich (information theory rise, e.g. entropy timeline of the observable universe). -there seems to be something rather than nothing -there doesn’t seem to be anything that happens without a cause (except, it seems to me, our will). These seem to be important data points… :)
- greycol 5y agoThe problem is your clear and measurable points don't actually point to a god. If you see some meaning in them that enriches your life that's great but they don't really count as evidence to those outside your religion (except perhaps when they also claim it as 'evidence' of their flavour of goddess). 1. Your brain/body evolved to interpret this richness in a universe that is unintelligible to us a conscious brain that evolved in that universe would almost certainly view those unintelligible to us rules as intelligible lest there be no purpose to that consciousness. Our brains also quite demonstrably processes unintelligible (to us) things as intelligible when they are not. 2. This is true in any universe where someone is around to point out that something exists and is a priori with or without creator beings. 3. Our will is either deterministic (happens with a cause) or it is not. In the case that it is deterministic we can ignore this example (which personally is my view). In the case it is not then the non deterministic part is reduced to the result of quantum coin flips altering the result in the larger scale world. Assuming so there are two possibilities either everything else is also happening at that level without a cause (which is counter to your point that it is only will that behaves this way) or the quantum coin flips are in some way deterministic which means so is will.
- zosima 5y agoAnd then you have done validation of some of the proposition of modern science and technology. But quite a lot "science" can not verified in the same manner as some physics, math, chemistry and biology can. And to go from the fact that some science is verifiable and then conclude that everything which tries to take on the label science or follow similar rituals to the verifiable sciences, also deserves the same respect is quite a long jump. In fact "science" or scientism seems to be one of the more dangerous religions nowadays, as the rituals of peer-review, papers and conferences, holy institutions like universities and sacraments of tenure and ph.d are very easy to adopt without being even remotely verifiable (or even slightly rational).
- j4yav 5y agoSome (most even that is relevant day to day?) is quite easy to validate and yet we still have flat-Earthers.
- mensetmanusman 5y agoNote that a lot of the flat earth stuff is a large troll to make people mad, crazy stuff comes out of 4chan…
- UncleMeat 5y agoTrust develops over time. We can trust scientific institutions because of past successes and how their construction promotes future successes. Scientific institutions are also constrained in their function. It is not the case that all forms of trusting institutions are intellectually equal.
- pdonis 5y ago> We can trust scientific institutions because of past successes For those that have them, yes. Not all institutions that are called "scientific" have them, though. > and how their construction promotes future successes. For those for which this is true, yes. It's not true for all institutions that are called "scientific". > Scientific institutions are also constrained in their function. I'm not sure how true this actually is. Top tier universities like Harvard call themselves "scientific institutions", but they're really just hedge funds that happen to do research and teaching as a side gig. And the fact that almost all university research is funded by governments means that along with the expansion of government into more and more areas of our lives, comes the expansion of what is called "scientific" for purposes of getting government funding.
- ttfkam 5y agoWhich is why the blanket "lying media" and "fake news" rhetoric is so dangerous. It removes that trust—often unjustifiably and usually in total—without specifying what other institutions or processes can be trusted instead for reliable information besides a known orange-tinted salesman with an affection for Mein Kampf. GANs and other deep fakes are going to be weaponized and absolutely obliterate the foundations of this country if that trust in legitimate journalism cannot be adequately restored in time. All journalism is biased, but we're not talking about bias; we're talking about up is down. Very soon literally anyone can be shown saying anything… to anyone else… anywhere… wearing anything (or nothing)… with resources akin to a typical gaming computer. As a nation, we are woefully unprepared for that day, and we will pay dearly for that lack of preparation.
- pdonis 5y ago> Which is why the blanket "lying media" and "fake news" rhetoric is so dangerous. It removes that trust—often unjustifiably No, often justifiably. If the media didn't lie so often and so consistently, they wouldn't have a problem rebutting accusations of lying. > without specifying what other institutions or processes can be trusted instead for reliable information That's the problem: there aren't any. Our society has no institutions that can be trusted for reliable information.
- ttfkam 5y agoOkay, you've made the claim they all lie. It's up to you to provide the evidence since I can't prove a negative. I can't point to a news story that lacks lies and claim they're all true. It's up to you to put up specific examples and demonstrate a pattern of deception. PBS News Hour Frontline Reuters BBC News NPR's morning and evening news Associated Press Then papers of record (excluding editorial column or op-ed): Washington Post Chicago Tribune Miami Herald etc. Please provide specific examples of their lies. I'll even take honest errors that never received a retraction. Move on to more opinion-based outlets like: The Hill The Atlantic Pro Publica Mother Jones In these, provide examples where what's written goes beyond bias or persuasion into "lie" territory. While we're here, show where dedicated fact checkers like FactCheck.org have lied or omitted their sources so as to prevent outside verification. Even Fox News rarely if ever lies. Biased as all hell, but no outright lies at the main news desk. Their opinion shows on the channel on the other hand, it's hard to find an honest hour among them. And local NBC, CBS, and ABC affiliates? Yeah, I'm gonna need some specific examples where they regularly lie to the American public beyond, "They were mean to Trump."