6 ms·
I'm surprised to read that despite persecution, Russia allowed them to transit through their country.
by duxup 5y ago
I'm surprised to read that despite persecution, Russia allowed them to transit through their country.
- redis_mlc 5y agoI believe early in WW2, Japan had a treaty with Russia. So Japan did not torpedo US Liberty ships headed to Russia, and various other surprising things. (Japan obeyed international treaties to the letter, but did not follow any human rights conventions.) Of course, at the end of WW2, Russia turned their vast army and artillery eastward, and annihiliated the Japanese army. Source: I study WW2.
- metters 5y ago> and various other surprising things. This makes me curious. What other things?
- redis_mlc 5y agoAlthough the Axis countries did not cooperate to the extent of the US and Britain, there was some effort: - Japan sent a military observer to Berlin. Unfortunately for Hitler, he made daily extensive notes, then sent them via a broken code - Japan received a Bf109 and a light German bomber, and evaluated them against the Zero and a Japanese bomber - Japan also received a couple of tanks and some nuclear technology, usually via submarine.
- skhr0680 5y agoThe Soviets would have needed friends if the Allies accepted German's surrender then immediately took control of the German military to destroy the USSR, and Japan was in a natural position to be that friend. Stalin only agreed to break the non-aggression pact once it became clear that no invasion from the west was coming, which was fairly late in the war (Yalta).
- enriquto 5y agoit is interesting to note that at no point during the war both sides fought simultaneously against the other side. E.g., the USSR was on Germany's side during the battle of Britain (supplying fuel for german bombers). The Japan non-aggression pact was kept until after the defeat of Germany. The many European countries that fought on both sides along the course of the war, etc.
- LatteLazy 5y agoActually the Soviets already defeated the Germans. 80% of German forces were on the Eastern front and Russia was cutting through them like a hot knife through butter before d-day even occurred. They took Berlin despite the German high command basically trying to give it to the Western allies. The turning point of WW2 was Stalingrad, not D-day.
- hef19898 5y agoOne could also make the case for the Germans failure to take Moscow to be the turning point, followed by the US entry into the war. After that it was just a question of when the Axis would be crushed by the Allies industrial capacity. Not if.
- miles 5y ago> Of course, at the end of WW2, Russia turned their vast army and artillery eastward, and annihiliated the Japanese army. Of the ~1,092,400 Japanese soldiers facing Russia, only 22,300-23,600 were killed according to Japan (Russia places the figure at 83,737): https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Soviet–Japanese_War#Summary https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Soviet–Japanese_War#Summary
- LatteLazy 5y agoBecause Japan surrendered almost as soon as Russia declared war. They were more afraid of the red army than 2 nuclear bombings...
- hef19898 5y agoI think we will never know what the reasoning behind the two bombs really was. I could imagine that after using large scale carpet and fire bombing against civilian targets, a nuclear bomb with a similar effect doesn't make much of a difference.
- redis_mlc 5y agoWe know exactly: - 5 Japanese cities were set aside from B-29 carpet bombing for possible nuclear bombing - US generals debated whether using these bombs was immoral or not. They were on the fence. - Truman's civil administrator pushed for using them - 2 were dropped. I believe 3-ship formations were used: bomber, meteorology plane, photo plane. A customized Lancaster wing was initially created, but Americans preferred to use their own B-29. You are correct that it didn't matter whether an atomic bomb or 1000 bombers with napalm were sent. Also, "civilian targets" is incorrect - Hiroshima was a naval base, and also built submarines or torpedos. This was downplayed by peaceniks for several decades, but it turned out that Hiroshima was a military target. There's even an interview with a worker from one of the military factories online. The Japanese military's goal after Midway was to win a crushing defeat over the US in a battle, so that there could be a favorable peace treaty with the US. That's one of the reasons for their refusal to surrender.
- 5y ago
- protomyth 5y agoThe ships headed to Russia were Russian flagged. They were the reason US submarines had to be very careful in their target selection in certain waters. Thunder Below has a lot of commentary on the subject.
- himinlomax 5y ago> but did not follow any human rights conventions If I'm not mistaken, they hadn't signed any.
- ssijak 5y agoRussia did not have a plan to exterminate them, you are thinking from a Nazi POV. They were probably just interested in not having them in Russia because of the religion.
- vmception 5y agoThe Nazi solutions weren’t all extermination either, until the final solution. There were several solutions/plans that were thwarted due to poor calculation. The Madagascar Plan makes so much more since for longevity than the Jewish Nationalist plan on the Mediterranean.
- yawaworht1978 5y agoSorry, but this is a very naive point of view. The Nazi solution was to kill as many of everything as fast they can, the t4 programme and hands on killings were already daily business. The only thing holding the Nazis back was a functional USSR, as soon they anticipated the fall of Moscow, the termination camps have been built in no time. They also maintained many concentration camps long before the decisive conference at Wannsee. The systematic killings started in June 41. The construction and initial glassings via gas vans started before the Wannsee conference, they couldn't wait long enough to get started. Hitler stated as early as 1922 to a journalist that his first and foremost task will be the annihilation of Jews. He simply had to keep a bit of international reputation and was not sure if the army and other lackeys would be ready to commit mass genocide on civilians. After the cowardly operation Barbarossa, there were no doubts any more. There are no ifs or whatever about this, the German population will forever be marked as the biggest suckers in mankind for allowing this man to power and have him and his rich buddies stay in power. There were heroic people who had seen the painting on the wall and died for the cause, then there were the complicit, active clogs in the machine and the most cowardly, the "neutral/passive" parts of the population who accepted the state of affairs and hoped it might either away without consequences for them. And then there's people like you, to this day believing the Jewish solution would have seriously been a peaceful relocation, which would have killed many as well. Ask yourself in which of the 3 aforementioned groups you would most likely be.
- metters 5y agoMaybe because it was such a bureaucratic system.